Clavis Libri

Paradise

Quotes

The 40 passages that decide the work, each with who speaks, the linked themes and characters, and an explanation.

Cantos I to IV: The Moon

all things have order among themselves, and this is the form that makes the universe resemble God
Speaker
Beatrice, to Dante, explaining why he rises
Characters
Beatrice, Dante the pilgrim
Themes
God and the Divine

Explanation and analysis

Dante and Beatrice have just left the earth, and Dante still thinks he rises like a heavy body crossing the air. Beatrice corrects the illusion before he says it, with a smile, and tells him that he is no longer on earth. Then comes the second doubt: how does he pass through light bodies, such as air and fire? She sighs with pity, looks at him as a mother looks at a child who is raving, and begins to answer.

The answer does not describe the mechanics of the ascent. It is a thesis about the universe: all things have order among themselves, and it is this order that makes the universe resemble God. Whoever comes to the canticle expecting a travel account finds a metaphysics, and Beatrice speaks like someone who teaches by principles, not by scenes. The resemblance to God is not offered as ornament. It is the reason each thing has a place and a motion of its own, and it is through it that the text goes on to explain the rising fire, the gathering earth, and the creature with intelligence.

The argument that follows completes the sentence. Each nature inclines toward this order, more or less near its principle, and moves to diverse ports across the great sea of being. The creature with intellect and love, however, can turn toward another part, and then a false pleasure overthrows it. Rising is, in this reckoning, what Dante does when nothing hinders him, and the sentence cited is the basis of everything Beatrice will say in the following cantos about degrees, will, and place.

the water I take has never been sailed; Minerva breathes, and Apollo guides me, and nine Muses show me the Bears
Speaker
Dante, the narrator, in the address to the reader that opens canto II
Characters
Dante the pilgrim
Themes
Language and Narration
Symbols
The reader's little boat
Devices
Metaphor, Allusion

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription

Subscription

The explanation of this quote and the other 38 quotes from Paradise comes with a subscription.

See the plansAlready subscribed? Sign in

brother, our will is calmed by the virtue of charity, which makes us want only what we have and gives us no thirst for anything else
Speaker
Piccarda, to Dante, in the heaven of the Moon
Characters
Piccarda Donati, Dante the pilgrim
Themes
Love
Devices
Metaphor

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription
it became clear to me then how in every part of heaven is paradise, though the grace of the highest good does not rain there in only one way
Speaker
Dante, the narrator, after hearing Piccarda
Characters
Dante the pilgrim
Themes
Justice and Law
Devices
Metaphor

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription
so is born, like a shoot, the doubt at the foot of the true; and it is nature that pushes us up hill after hill
Speaker
Dante, to Beatrice, explaining why he asks
Characters
Dante the pilgrim, Beatrice
Themes
Knowledge and Wisdom
Devices
Comparison, Metaphor

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription

Cantos V to VIII: Mercury and Venus

the greatest gift God, in his generosity, made in creating, and the most in keeping with his goodness, and the one he prizes most, was the freedom of the will, with which all intelligent creatures, all of them and only them, were and are endowed
Speaker
Beatrice, to Dante, opening the lesson on the vow
Characters
Beatrice, Dante the pilgrim
Themes
Justice and Law

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription
be serious, Christians, when you move; do not be like a feather at every wind, nor believe that every water washes you
Speaker
Beatrice, at the end of the lesson on the vow
Characters
Beatrice
Themes
Faith
Devices
Apostrophe, Comparison

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription
diverse voices make sweet notes; so the diverse seats in our life make sweet harmony among these wheels
Speaker
Justinian, explaining why the souls of Mercury do not complain of their rank
Characters
Justinian
Themes
Justice and Law
Devices
Comparison

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription
one opposes the public sign with the yellow lilies, and the other appropriates it for a party, so that it is hard to see who errs more
Speaker
Justinian judging Guelphs and Ghibellines
Characters
Justinian
Themes
Justice and Law
Symbols
The eagle of justice
Devices
Metonymy

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription
you made me glad, and so you make me clear, for in speaking you moved me to doubt how, from sweet seed, bitter can come
Speaker
Dante, to Charles Martel, formulating the doubt about lineage
Characters
Dante the pilgrim, Charles Martel
Themes
Justice and Law
Devices
Antithesis, Metaphor

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription

Cantos IX to XII: Venus and the Sun

here, however, we do not repent, but laugh, not at the fault, which does not return to the mind, but at the worth that ordered and provided. Here one contemplates the art that adorns so much affection, and discerns the good by which the world above makes the one below turn
Speaker
Folquet of Marseille, to Dante, in the heaven of Venus
Characters
Folquet of Marseille
Themes
Love
Devices
Antithesis

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription
your city, the plant of him who first turned his back on his Creator, and of whom so much envy is wept, produces and spreads the cursed flower that led the sheep and the lambs astray, because it made a wolf of the shepherd
Speaker
Folquet of Marseille, to Dante, about Florence
Characters
Folquet of Marseille
Themes
Justice and Law
Devices
Metaphor

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription
now, reader, stay on your bench, ruminating on what was only proved, if you wish to be glad long before you are tired
Speaker
Dante, the narrator, on entering the heaven of the Sun
Characters
Dante the pilgrim
Themes
Language and Narration
Devices
Apostrophe, Metaphor

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription
this one, deprived of her first husband, for a thousand one hundred years and more remained despised and obscure, uninvited, until this one
Speaker
Thomas Aquinas, speaking of Poverty before Francis
Characters
Thomas Aquinas
Themes
Faith
Devices
Personification

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription
not to dispense two or three for six, not the fortune of the first vacant benefice, not the tithes, which belong to the poor of God
Speaker
Bonaventure, recounting what Dominic asked of the apostolic see
Characters
Bonaventure
Themes
Justice and Law
Devices
Repetition, Parallelism

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription

Cantos XIII to XVI: The Sun and Mars

and let this always be lead at your feet, to make you move slowly, like a tired man, both at the yes and at the no that you do not see
Speaker
Thomas Aquinas, to Dante, after explaining Solomon's measure
Characters
Thomas Aquinas, Dante the pilgrim
Themes
Knowledge and Wisdom
Devices
Metaphor, Comparison

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription
well I perceived it was of high praises, because "Resurge" and "Vince" came to me like one who does not understand and hears
Speaker
Dante, the narrator, hearing the hymn of the cross of Mars
Characters
Dante the pilgrim
Themes
Faith
Symbols
The cross of Mars
Devices
Sensory imagery, Comparison

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription
O my frond, in whom I took delight only in waiting, I was your root: such a beginning, in answering, made me
Speaker
Cacciaguida to Dante, answering the request for his name
Characters
Cacciaguida, Dante the pilgrim
Themes
Home, Exile, and Return
Devices
Apostrophe, Metaphor

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription
Florence, within the old walls, whose bells still marked terce and nones, was at peace, sober and modest
Speaker
Cacciaguida to Dante, describing the city of his time
Characters
Cacciaguida
Themes
Home, Exile, and Return
Devices
Personification

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription
All your things have their death, just as you do; but this is hidden in some that last a long time, and lives are short. And as the turning of the sphere of the Moon covers and uncovers the shores without pause, so Fortune does to Florence
Speaker
Cacciaguida to Dante, speaking of families and cities
Characters
Cacciaguida
Themes
Home, Exile, and Return
Devices
Comparison, Personification

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription

Cantos XVII to XX: The prophecy and the Eagle

As Hippolytus left Athens because of his merciless and treacherous stepmother, so it is fitting that you leave Florence
Speaker
Cacciaguida to Dante, announcing the exile
Characters
Cacciaguida, Dante the pilgrim
Themes
Home, Exile, and Return
Devices
Comparison, Allusion

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription
But, even so, with every lie set aside, make your whole vision manifest; and let the scab itch where it is. For if your voice is unpleasant at first taste, it will afterward leave vital nourishment, once it is digested
Speaker
Cacciaguida to Dante, on what he must write
Characters
Cacciaguida, Dante the pilgrim
Themes
Language and Narration
Devices
Metaphor, Antithesis

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription
Now you, who are you that would sit in the judge's chair to judge from a thousand miles away with the short sight of a hand's span?
Speaker
The Eagle to Dante, answering the doubt about the man of the Indus
Characters
Dante the pilgrim
Themes
Justice and Law
Symbols
The eagle of justice
Devices
Rhetorical question, Hyperbole

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription
The kingdom of heaven suffers violence from burning love and living hope, which overcomes the divine will: not as man overcomes man, but it overcomes it because it wants to be overcome, and, overcome, it conquers with its benevolence
Speaker
The Eagle to Dante, on Trajan and Rhipeus
Characters
Dante the pilgrim
Themes
Faith
Symbols
The eagle of justice
Devices
Paradox, Repetition

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription
For I saw and heard the beak speak, and in its voice I and mine sounded, when in thought it was we and ours
Speaker
Dante, narrator, before the Eagle of Jupiter
Characters
Dante the pilgrim
Themes
Justice and Law
Symbols
The eagle of justice
Devices
Antithesis

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription

Cantos XXI to XXIV: Saturn and the fixed stars

They cover their palfreys with their mantles, so that two beasts go under one hide: O patience, you who bear so much
Speaker
Peter Damian to Dante, on the shepherds of the Church today
Characters
Dante the pilgrim
Themes
Faith
Symbols
The ladder of Saturn
Devices
Satire, Apostrophe

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription
The little garden plot that makes us so ferocious, while I turned with the eternal Twins, appeared to me entire, from the hills to the river mouths
Speaker
Dante, narrator, looking down at the Earth from above, in the sphere of the Fixed Stars
Characters
Dante the pilgrim
Themes
Home, Exile, and Return
Symbols
The ladder of Saturn
Devices
Metaphor

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription
Why does my face so enthrall you that you do not turn to the beautiful garden that blooms under the rays of Christ? There is the rose in which the divine Word became flesh; there are the lilies, by whose fragrance the good path was taken
Speaker
Beatrice to Dante, on the triumph of Christ
Characters
Beatrice, Dante the pilgrim
Themes
God and the Divine
Devices
Metaphor, Sensory imagery

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription
So the pen leaps and I do not write it: for our imagination, not only speech, is a color too vivid for such folds
Speaker
Dante, narrator, not writing the song of Peter
Characters
Dante the pilgrim, Saint Peter
Themes
Language and Narration
Devices
Leitmotiv, Metaphor

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription
The broad rain of the Holy Spirit, which pours down on the old parchments and on the new, is the syllogism that concluded it in me so keenly that, before it, every demonstration seems blunt to me
Speaker
Dante to Saint Peter, explaining where his faith came from
Characters
Dante the pilgrim, Saint Peter
Themes
Faith
Devices
Metaphor

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription

Cantos XXV to XXVIII: The Three Virtues and the Primum Mobile

May the cruelty that shuts me out of the beautiful fold where I slept as a lamb, enemy of the wolves that make war upon it, be overcome; with another voice now, with other wool, I shall return a poet, and at the font of my baptism I shall take the laurel crown
Speaker
Dante, narrator, at the beginning of canto XXV
Characters
Dante the pilgrim
Themes
Home, Exile, and Return
Devices
Metaphor

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription
Now, my son, not tasting the wood was not in itself the cause of so long an exile, but only stepping across the sign
Speaker
Adam to Dante, on the cause of the fall
Characters
Adam, Dante the pilgrim
Themes
Home, Exile, and Return
Devices
Antithesis

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription
So that I saw, beyond Gades, the mad passage of Ulysses, and on this side, near, the shore where Europa became a sweet burden
Speaker
Dante, narrator, looking down at the Earth from the Primum Mobile
Characters
Dante the pilgrim
Themes
Home, Exile, and Return
Devices
Allusion, Euphemism

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription
In shepherd's garb, rapacious wolves can be seen from up here across all the pastures: O defense of God, why do you still lie? Of our blood, the Cahorsines and the Gascons prepare to drink: O good beginning, to what vile end it is fitting that you should fall!
Speaker
Saint Peter, in canto XXVII, against the popes
Characters
Saint Peter
Themes
Justice and Law
Devices
Metaphor, Apostrophe, Metonymy

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription
If your fingers are not enough for such a knot, it is no wonder: from so much not trying it, it has grown hard!
Speaker
Beatrice to Dante, in canto XXVIII
Characters
Beatrice, Dante the pilgrim
Themes
Knowledge and Wisdom
Symbols
The point of light and the nine choirs
Devices
Irony, Metaphor

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription

Cantos XXIX to XXXIII: The Empyrean

Florence does not have as many Lapi and Bindi as the fables shouted from the pulpit each year, here and there: so that the little sheep, who do not know, come back from the pasture full of wind, and not seeing the harm does not excuse them
Speaker
Beatrice to Dante, on the preachers
Characters
Beatrice
Themes
Language and Narration
Devices
Hyperbole, Metaphor

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription
Thus I prayed; and she, as far away as she seemed, smiled and looked at me; then she turned back to the eternal fountain
Speaker
Dante, narrator, at Beatrice's last appearance
Characters
Beatrice, Dante the pilgrim
Themes
Love
Devices
Metaphor

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription
The wound that Mary closed and anointed, she who is so beautiful at her feet is the one who opened it and pricked it
Speaker
Saint Bernard to Dante, showing Eve in the rose
Characters
Saint Bernard, The Virgin Mary
Themes
God and the Divine
Symbols
The celestial rose
Devices
Metaphor, Antithesis

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription
From here on my seeing was greater than speech shows, which yields to such a sight, and memory yields to such excess. Like one who sees in a dream, of whom the impressed emotion remains after the dream, and the rest does not return to the mind
Speaker
Dante, narrator, at the beginning of the final vision
Characters
Dante the pilgrim
Themes
Language and Narration
Devices
Comparison, Repetition

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription
Lady, you are so great and are worth so much that whoever desires grace and does not turn to you wants his desire to fly without wings
Speaker
Saint Bernard, in the prayer to the Virgin
Characters
Saint Bernard, The Virgin Mary
Themes
God and the Divine
Devices
Apostrophe, Metaphor

Explanation and analysis

Unlock with a subscription