Clavis Libri

Character

Mathilde de La Mole

The daughter of the Marquis de La Mole, young, extremely wealthy, bored and a reader. She is Julien's second love, and the exact opposite of the first: where Madame de Rênal loves without knowing it, she decides to love.

What moves her

Boredom, and the suspicion that the age itself offers nothing worthy of admiration. She worships an ancestor executed in the sixteenth century because she prefers the bloody grandeur of the past to the comfortable mediocrity of the salon. It is, however, Abbé Pirard who introduces Julien to this ancestor, speaking of her brother, the young Count Norbert, who is bound to scorn him as a petty bourgeois.

His ancestor was at court and had the honor of having his head cut off on the Place de Grève, on the 26th of April 1574, because of a political intrigue. You are the son of a carpenter from Verrières and, on top of that, in the service of his father.
Book II, chapter 1: The pleasures of the country

Her yardstick for judging a man is explicit, and it is what makes Julien interesting in her eyes long before any affection.

I think only a sentence of death honors a man [...], it is the one thing that cannot be bought.
Book II, chapter 8: Which decoration is the most honorable

Ch. VIII. Mathilde at the ball, measuring the suitors:

Which of them, she thought, could get himself condemned to death, even supposing all the conditions favorable?
Book II, chapter 8: Which decoration is the most honorable

Ch. VIII. Mathilde and her maxim:

There, thought Mathilde, is a fine proof of my maxim: noble birth takes away the strength of character without which it is impossible to get oneself condemned to death!
Book II, chapter 8: Which decoration is the most honorable

Ch. VIII. Mathilde at the ball:

What pleasure is there for me, she added sadly, if, after six months' absence, I do not find it at the ball that makes every woman in Paris envious? And on top of that I am here surrounded by all the homage of a society that could not be imagined better composed. There are no more than a few peers here from the bourgeoisie, and perhaps one or two Juliens. And yet, she added with growing sadness, what advantages fortune has not granted me: learning, wealth, youth, alas!, everything, except happiness.
Book II, chapter 8: Which decoration is the most honorable

The leaky barrel and the pendulum

Her boredom has two readings that complement each other without merging. According to Gorgias, Mathilde is the uninitiated of the myth: she has everything and retains nothing, because she lacks temperance, and the life she refuses is precisely the one that is satisfied with what the present day offers. According to Arthur Schopenhauer, she oscillates between the boredom of possession and the pain of lack: she tires of what she has, desires Julien while he is dangerous, despises him after the conquest and suffers again when he withdraws by Korasoff's method. With Plato the lack is hers and has a remedy; with Schopenhauer she is only the extreme case of a human condition.

the part of the soul of the uninitiated in which the passions are located, precisely because it is insatiable and retains nothing, he compared to a leaking barrel, for the very reason that it never shows satiety
Gorgias
The myth has two leaking vessels, and the second is the one that carries the water: the uninitiated, in Hades, carry water to the leaking barrel in a sieve that is also full of holes. By this sieve he understood the soul, as the person who told me the story explained to me. He compared the soul of the foolish to a sieve full of holes, for it retains nothing, since it lacks faith and memory.
Gorgias
The myth serves Socrates to choose between two lives, and temperance is the name of the one that does not leak. Socrates tells Callicles what he would like to show him, that you should resolve to change your opinion, and instead of an intemperate and insatiable life, prefer the well-ordered one that is satisfied with what the present day offers
Gorgias
Man's life oscillates, like a pendulum, between pain and boredom; these are in reality its two final elements.
On the Sufferings of the World

Love as a project

Mathilde does not fall in love with Julien; she falls in love with her own courage to love beneath her class. It is love read before it is lived, with a historical model, a role to play and an imaginary audience, and Stendhal names it plainly.

In truth, her enthusiasm was somewhat deliberate. Passionate love, more than a reality, was still a model one imitated.
Book II, chapter 16: One in the morning

The narrator separates this love from the other by kind, not by intensity, and the sentence is the key to any discussion of the two.

Cerebral love is no doubt more witty than true love, but it has only a few moments of enthusiasm; it knows itself too well, it judges itself constantly; instead of leading thought astray, it is built only by the force of thoughts.
Book II, chapter 19: The Opéra Bouffe

That is why she surrenders only when she is treated with calculated indifference, and the surrender comes in the form of a chosen humiliation, which is what she has always wanted to stage.

There is that proud woman, at my feet! thought Julien.
Book II, chapter 29: Boredom

Ch. XIV. Mathilde, faced with the power she would give Julien:

What will his pretensions be, if one day he has all power over me? Well then! I will say like Medea: amid so many dangers, I have ME left.
Book II, chapter 14: Thoughts of a young woman

What is political in her pride

Her cult of the beheaded ancestor is not an isolated morbid taste: it is the form that the nostalgia of the nobility takes in a house that has lost real power and kept only the name. Her father's salon lives in fear, and Julien reads this fear in the very marble of the door.

Such ostentation displeased Julien. They are so afraid of the Jacobins! They see a Robespierre and his cart behind every hedge; they are always mocking everything, and they display their house in this way so that the rabble will recognize it in case of tumult and loot it.
Book II, chapter 1: The pleasures of the country

This is the material that produces someone like Mathilde. In a class that shields itself from the century instead of contending with it, the only greatness available is that of the past, and she goes to look for it in 1574 because 1830 offers her nothing to admire.

And the ending confirms the reading from the practical side. When she resolves to save Julien, she appeals to no argument at all: she goes to Abbé de Frilair, the Congregation's man in Besançon, has the word "bishopric" reach him through correspondence with the Marechale de Fervaques, and he replies by counting the jurors he says he holds in his hand.

Among the twelve people charged with examining whether the crime of my protégé is incontestable and, above all, whether there was premeditation, I count on six friends devoted to my cause, and I have let them understand that it depends on them to carry me to the bishopric.
Book II, chapter 41: The trial

The same machine she despises in the salon is the one she sets in motion without hesitation when she needs it. This is what separates her pride from Julien's: he wants to enter through the window because the door is closed, and she has the key and pretends not to like the house.

The ending, and what it reveals

After the execution, she performs the gesture she had been rehearsing since the beginning: she buries her lover's head with her own hands, repeating the cult of the ancestor of the sixteenth century.

When Fouqué summoned the courage to look, she had placed, on a small marble table before her, Julien's head, and was kissing it on the forehead…
Book II, chapter 45

The contrast with Madame de Rênal's silent death, three days later and in the same chapter, is the last thing the book does, and it is no accident: one love produces ceremony, the other produces consequence. Stendhal does not say which is worth more; he sets the two side by side and leaves the stage.

Trajectory

In chapter 3 of Book II, she enters the library through a small secret door, disguised among the spines, in search of a volume of Voltaire, and is annoyed to find Julien there. At night, she laughs at the horse fall he recounts simply, and asks him for the details.

In chapter 8 of Book II, at the ball of the Duke de Retz, bored among her suitors, she sees Count Altamira, condemned to death, and formulates the maxim that only a death sentence honors a man. From it, she begins to measure her suitors and concludes that noble birth takes away strength of character.

I think only a sentence of death honors a man [...], it is the one thing that cannot be bought.
Book II, chapter 8: Which decoration is the most honorable

Ch. VIII. Mathilde and her maxim:

There, thought Mathilde, is a fine proof of my maxim: noble birth takes away the strength of character without which it is impossible to get oneself condemned to death!
Book II, chapter 8: Which decoration is the most honorable

In chapter 10 of Book II, she appears in full mourning, the only one in black in the family, on the day her ancestor Boniface de La Mole was beheaded. She walks with Julien in the garden, reads the chroniclers of the sixteenth century, and confesses that she loves the time of the wars of the Holy League, when a beheaded lover was still loved as he should be.

In chapter 11 of Book II, tired of the identical letters of her suitors, she decides in a burst of joy that she is in love, and concludes that only a heroic love will free her from the boredom of her own class.

Ch. XI. Mathilde, deciding that she loves Julien:

I have the happiness of loving!, she thought one day, with a burst of incredible joy. I am in love, I am in love, of course!
Book II, chapter 11: The empire of a young woman

In chapter 14 of Book II, the narrator shows the cost of the letter Mathilde wrote to Julien: the struggle against pride and the fear of dishonor, and above all the fear of displeasing him. She throws him a new letter asking for a definitive answer; he replies with mockery and announces his departure, and she tosses him a note so that he will climb the gardener's staircase to her window.

Ch. XIV. Mathilde, faced with the power she would give Julien:

What will his pretensions be, if one day he has all power over me? Well then! I will say like Medea: amid so many dangers, I have ME left.
Book II, chapter 14: Thoughts of a young woman

In chapter 16 of Book II, she receives Julien in her room and carries out the resolution she had made: to belong entirely to him if he dared to come that far. The narrator says that her enthusiasm was somewhat deliberate and that passionate love, more than a reality, was still a model one imitated.

In truth, her enthusiasm was somewhat deliberate. Passionate love, more than a reality, was still a model one imitated.
Book II, chapter 16: One in the morning

In chapter 17 of Book II, she tells Julien that she is horrified at having given herself to the first man who came along. When he throws himself at an old sword in the library and then draws back, she gazes at him without hatred, delighted to have come close to being killed by her lover.

So I was on the point of being killed by my lover!, she said to herself. This idea transported her to the fine days of the age of Charles IX and Henry III.
Book II, chapter 17: An old sword

In chapter 19 of Book II, after despising him once she was certain of being loved, she reconstructs by herself, with arguments, why it was worth giving in. Doodling absently, she unintentionally draws Julien's profile and takes it as a miracle of love, and the narrator calls what she feels cerebral love.

One of the profiles she had just drawn startled her, filled her with wonder: it was strikingly like Julien. It is the voice of heaven! Here is one of love's miracles, she exclaimed in ecstasy, without suspecting it, I have made his portrait.
Book II, chapter 19: The Opéra Bouffe
Cerebral love is no doubt more witty than true love, but it has only a few moments of enthusiasm; it knows itself too well, it judges itself constantly; instead of leading thought astray, it is built only by the force of thoughts.
Book II, chapter 19: The Opéra Bouffe

In chapter 20 of Book II, one morning in the library, she declares to Julien that she no longer loves him and humiliates him with calculated contempt, while he tries in vain to justify himself.

In chapter 29 of Book II, she finds on Julien's table the letter the porter had just brought, demands explanations and weeps. When she opens his drawer, she discovers eight or ten unopened letters from the Marechale de Fervaques, falls at his feet and says she can no longer live without his love.

She was as if frozen with horror on finding eight or ten unopened letters, altogether like the one the porter had just brought.
Book II, chapter 29: Boredom
There is that proud woman, at my feet! thought Julien.
Book II, chapter 29: Boredom

In chapter 30 of Book II, she offers Julien the excess of her love and suffering, and he resists to the limit of what he can bear. Julien, in thought, compares the two lovers: Madame de Rênal found reasons to do what her heart dictated, and Mathilde lets her heart be moved only after finding good reasons. That evening, she persuades her mother to go to the Opera only to find out whether he will spend the night with the Marechale.

Madame de Rênal found reasons to do what her heart dictated; this young woman of high society lets her heart be moved only after finding good reasons for it to be moved.
Book II, chapter 30: A box at the Opéra Bouffe

In chapter 32 of Book II, for the first time she truly loves: she is submissive with Julien and ever more haughty with everyone else. On discovering that she is pregnant, she writes to her father an eight-page letter in which she takes the blame for having seduced the young man and proposes to live with him in Switzerland as Madame Sorel.

Julien had embraced his role with such diligence that he had come to make her think that, of the two of them, it was she who loved more.
Book II, chapter 32: The tiger

In chapter 33 of Book II, faced with the marquis's fury, who sees her as Madame Sorel and not as a duchess, Mathilde, who has seen Julien's suicide note, swears to her father that she will publicly be the widow Sorel, sends Julien to Villequier for prudence, and rejects all plans for a clandestine delivery.

In chapter 35 of Book II, a note from her ("Everything is lost") makes Julien race from Strasbourg to Paris, where she shows him the marquis's letter, which refuses marriage to a man who seduces a girl for her wealth, and Madame de Rênal's letter.

In chapter 38 of Book II, she enters the tower at Besançon dressed as a peasant woman and proposes to Julien that they die together. After eight days of requests, she manages to speak with Abbé de Frilair, confesses that she is the marquis's daughter, and asks whether it is possible to help Julien escape.

Mathilde felt herself in Paris.
Book II, chapter 38: A powerful man

In chapter 39 of Book II, she asks her own rival, the Marechale de Fervaques, for a letter from the bishop to the vicar general. Her devotion, made of extravagant projects, squandered gold and bribed jailers, wearies Julien, who feels remorse at not returning it.

Julien considered himself unworthy of such devotion; in truth, he was weary of heroism. He would have been sensitive to a simple, naive and almost timid tenderness, whereas Mathilde's proud soul always needed the idea of an audience and of others.
Book II, chapter 39: The intrigue

In chapter 41 of Book II, on the eve of the trial, she brings Frilair the bishop's letter, and he guarantees her the acquittal, because he counts on her to reach the bishopric. Julien is sentenced to death all the same.

Among the twelve people charged with examining whether the crime of my protégé is incontestable and, above all, whether there was premeditation, I count on six friends devoted to my cause, and I have let them understand that it depends on them to carry me to the bishopric.
Book II, chapter 41: The trial

In chapter 42 of Book II, she wakes Julien in his cell, furious because Frilair has betrayed her, and heaps curses on him when he refuses to appeal; she calls in the lawyer Félix Vaneau to fight the refusal.

In chapter 44 of Book II, she tells Julien that on the day of the trial, Baron de Valenod, with his appointment as governor in his pocket, dared to mock Frilair and took the pleasure of condemning Julien to death.

In chapter 45 of Book II, she torments Julien in prison with almost daily scenes of jealousy. After the execution, she places his head before her, kisses it on the forehead, attends the burial, and has the grotto on the mountain above Verrières, where Julien wished to be buried, adorned with marbles sculpted in Italy.

When Fouqué summoned the courage to look, she had placed, on a small marble table before her, Julien's head, and was kissing it on the forehead…
Book II, chapter 45