Clavis Libri

Questions · White Nights

What is the message of White Nights?

White Nights does not close with a lesson but with a question: "A whole minute of bliss! Is that little, even for an entire human life?" What the book shows, over the four nights, is the price of living on daydreams: a man who spent years inventing life in a room is given, for a few hours, a real life, and has to decide what it is worth once it is over.

On the Second Night the Dreamer makes the diagnosis himself. He calls daydreaming happiness and poison in the same line ("New dream, new happiness! A new dose of a refined, voluptuous poison!") and even asks himself: "what have you done with your years? where have you buried your best time? Have you lived or not?" The four nights with Nastenka are the first time that question meets a real life.

The answer comes in the Morning. He sees himself alone in the same room fifteen years from now and, instead of accusing Nastenka, blesses her for the minute of happiness she gave him. The last sentence allows two readings, and the text does not choose: the gratitude of someone at last content with something that really happened, or the last reverie, in which he gives himself the noble role of the one who blesses.

Turgenev's epigraph already asked the same question at the start: whether someone was created "just for this: to be, even if only for a moment, in the vicinity of your heart". The book opens and closes with the instant, and leaves the reader to decide whether it is enough.

More questions about White Nights

See all questions