Clavis Libri

Poor Folk

Discussion Questions

Open questions that the book leaves behind, to bring to class, to a reading group, or to think over on your own.

April 8 to May 20: The First Letters

Makar starts calling "fatherly affection" what was once a poem about a little bird, and then denies having sold his uniform. What do these two attitudes show about what he fears others may see in him?

Varenka refuses the gifts because she knows at what cost they come, but she keeps writing and accepting the help that arrives. What do the April letters reveal about what she can and cannot give up?

Makar describes the boarding house and the Gorshkov couple in detail, and soon returns to talking about Varenka. What relation do the letters establish between the misery he sees around him and what he does for her?

June 1: Varenka's Notebook

Varenka already sees, at twelve, that household decisions are about money and that a child's will does not count: does what she learned from this show in the way she later deals with Anna Fyodorovna, with Pokrovsky and with Makar?

Old Pokrovsky needs a lie to show his son that he has reformed, and Varenka prepares it with him: when does a lie become kindness, and when does it become manipulation?

She sends the notebook to Makar out of gratitude and at the same time without wanting to reread it: what does she want him to do with these memories, and what does this say about what she expects of him?

June 11 to 28: The Best Time

Makar tells of the nickname "office rat" and ends by saying that the rat is necessary and rewarded. What defense of himself does he build, and what does it leave aside of the humiliation he suffers?

Varenka scornfully returns the book Makar sent her, and he replies by praising Ratazyaev. What does his admiration for literature show about what he looks for in books, and what does she look for?

Varenka asks her friend to decide whether she should accept the governess post, and he refuses on her behalf. How does Makar's refusal protect Varenka, and how does it protect himself?

July: Pushkin and Gogol

Makar reads Pushkin and is consoled, reads Gogol and is offended: what does each book show him about himself, and why does one welcome him and the other expose him?

Varenka wants to leave so as not to be a burden and Makar wants her to stay so as not to be alone: who protects whom in these letters, and what does each hide from the other under the pretext of protecting?

In telling of the scandal, Makar says that what no one sees is as if it had not happened: to what extent does his honor depend only on what others know?

August: Shame

Makar defends his boots as a matter of honor and Varenka repeats to him that poverty is no vice: whose shame is at stake in each sentence, and who imposes it?

The draft of Makar's letter, read aloud, turns him into a source of laughter: what does the others' reading take away, and what does it reveal about what he wrote?

Each of the two wants to help the other and ends up wounding: when does the help of Varenka and of Makar protect, and when does it only feed shame?

September 3 to 19: His Excellency's Help

Makar gives nothing to the boy with the letter, whom he imagines hardening, and gives Gorshkov his last twenty kopecks, more than he had asked. What does the difference between the two scenes show about what Makar understands by helping?

His Excellency gives a hundred rubles and shakes Makar's hand, and Makar says the handshake is worth more than the money. What does each of the two gestures mean to the one who receives them, and why does Makar choose to speak of only one?

Ratazyaev says that money is the main thing and Gorshkov answers by withdrawing his hand from his shoulder; a few hours later he is dead. What does the scene suggest about the place of honor in the life of the poor?

September 23 to 30: The Departure

Varenka tells Makar she has decided to marry, says she was not asking for advice and that the decision is irrevocable. What does the letter show about what she expects from him and what she fears he will say?

On hearing the news, Makar answers with the rain, with shopping, and with the figure of Bykov, and speaks of himself only in passing. What does this detour reveal about what he can say to Varenka, and what he cannot?

In the last letter Makar says he is writing without correcting, only to write, after having taken care over his style in almost all the others. What does the end of the book suggest about what the letters were for the two of them?