Clavis Libri

Poor Folk · September 3 to 19

His Excellency's Help

Chapter summary

In two weeks of September the letters go from despair to celebration and back to fear. Varenka writes that she thinks she will die in the autumn, and Makar Devushkin, who does not touch on the subject and walks about the city, comes back from an evening on the Fontanka with the idea that rich and poor alike dream of shoes. Four days later the error in a copy takes him to His Excellency's office, who instead of punishing him gives him a hundred rubles and shakes his hand, and Makar begins to live on happiness, until the news that Bykov is in St. Petersburg. Running through the middle is the story of Gorshkov, the neighbor on trial, who wins his case and dies the same day.

September 3: Varenka and Memories of the Countryside

Section summary

Varenka takes up a letter she left half finished because writing weighed on her. She tells of the autumn afternoons of her childhood in the country, the pond, the evening with the nurse, and weeps as she rereads what she wrote. She is alone at home because Fedora has gone out, she is afraid of being alone, she feels that someone is speaking to her in the room, and she writes in part to make it pass. Of the money from the dresses and the hat she sold, one silver ruble is left, and she thanks Makar for the two rubles he gave the landlady.

Analysis

Я так живо, так живо всё припомнила, так ярко стало передо мною всё прошедшее, а настоящее так тускло, так темно!.., I remembered everything so vividly, so vividly, the whole past became so bright before me, and the present is so dim, so dark!..

Varenka does not tell of her childhood to console herself, but because the present has nothing to tell: memory is the only place where she is still whole. The weeping that follows is the price, and she herself knows that grief worsens her health, which does not make her stop.

Unlock with a subscription

Subscription

The complete analysis of every chapter of Poor Folk comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.

See the plansAlready subscribed? Sign in

September 5: Makar, the Fontanka, the Boy in the Letter and Gorshkov

Section summary

Makar walks one damp night along the Fontanka and Gorokhovaya Street, sees the carriages and the shops, and thinks of Varenka: why is she, who is worth more than all those ladies, not in one of them? The question leads him to a nameless offender who ogles Varenka through a lorgnette and goes unpunished because she is an orphan. He stops before a hurdy-gurdy player and is approached by an almost barefoot boy who holds out a letter begging alms for his sick mother. Makar gives nothing, because he has little, and imagines the boy's future, the cough, the death in a filthy corner. He describes it all to show the style he is proud of, and then he turns around the scene of the rich man's shoes and the poor man's, in which the rich man would need someone to whisper to him that there is a more noble object than his own shoes.

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

September 9: Makar and His Excellency's Help

Section summary

Makar writes beside himself. The day before, dejected, he left a line out of an urgent copy, and the sheet reached the office only the next day, with the flaw. Summoned by Evstafy Ivanovich, he is led from room to room before His Excellency, and the first thing he sees is his own reflection in the mirror. Then the button of his coat falls off and rolls to His Excellency's feet. Makar tries to pick it up, tries to put it back and smiles, and hears the section chief defend him: he has never been noticed, his conduct is exemplary, he has already received advances. His Excellency orders him to copy it again and gives him a hundred rubles from his own pocket. Makar sends forty-five to Varenka, gives twenty to the landlady, keeps thirty-five and, still in the letter, promises to pray every day for His Excellency.

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

September 10 and 11: Varenka Returns the Money, Makar Celebrates

Section summary

Varenka answers calmly: she is glad of his luck, returns what is left of the money, asks him to economize, warns that they will soon have to move and that Fedora is expecting an old debt to be paid, and invites him to visit her. The next day Makar writes that the world has changed: the landlady is milder, he has made peace with Ratazyaev and decided that the nickname Lovelace was a compliment, he has bought boots, he has strolled along the Nevsky. He asks Varenka not to part from him now that he is happy. He adds that at the office he told everyone about His Excellency's help, and that his colleagues laughed.

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

September 15: Varenka Warns That Bykov Is in St. Petersburg

Section summary

Varenka writes again in distress: Bykov, the man who ruined her, is in the city. He met Fedora in the street, wanted to know where they live, and the next day came into the room when Varenka had gone out. He looked at everything, asked who the clerk was who visits her, laughed on seeing him cross the courtyard, and wanted to give twenty-five rubles to Fedora, who refused. She does not understand how he knows so much, and Fedora's hypothesis is a piece of gossip passed through several servants. She asks Makar to come to her room.

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

September 18: Makar Tells of Gorshkov's Death

Section summary

Gorshkov is acquitted, will receive the sum the merchant owed him and comes home pale, smiling, and embraces his wife and children. The neighbors congratulate him, Ratazyaev remarks that money is what matters, and he removes his hand from his shoulder. During the day he walks from room to room without rest, tries to play cards and gives up, looks at Makar in the corridor in a strange way. After lunch he lies down to rest, asks about his dead son, and his wife, an hour later, finds him cold. Makar cannot believe that a man can die like this.

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

September 19: Makar and the New Job

Section summary

A short, practical letter: Ratazyaev has found Makar a copying job with a writer, forty kopecks a sheet, and the handwriting of the manuscript is so bad that he does not know where to begin. He writes to Varenka because money will be coming in from outside, and takes his leave to set to work, without a word about Gorshkov.

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

Questions on this chapter

To discuss

3 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.

Test your reading

8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz