Varenka, Varvara Dobroselova, is the orphaned young woman who lives in a rented room across the courtyard from Makar, with Fedora, and she is the other voice of the book. She is a distant relative of Anna Fyodorovna, the woman who took her and her mother in after her father's death. She embroiders and sews for a living, and is often ill.
Varenka refuses Makar's gifts because she knows at what cost they come, but she keeps accepting the help that arrives. It is she who reads his letters with the most lucidity: she notes that his style is very uneven, suspects the sale of the uniform, and sees that he is ruining himself for her. In June, she proposes to take a post as a governess so as not to be a burden any longer, and he stops her.
Her past is in the notebook she sends Makar on June 1: her childhood in the country, the move to Petersburg, Anna Fyodorovna's house, the student Pokrovsky and his father's death. In September, pressed by illness and poverty, she agrees to marry Bykov, the man who ruined her, and leaves for the steppe. Before going, she writes to Makar: “You are my only friend; only you loved me here.”