Clavis Libri

Questions · Poor Folk

Why does Makar take offense at The Overcoat, by Gogol?

On July 6, Varenka sends Makar Gogol's book, with the note “read one of them, called “The Overcoat”,” in the same paragraph in which she speaks of the invitation to the theater and of his debts. Earlier, on July 1, he had already read The Stationmaster, by Pushkin, and said it seemed written by himself, “my own heart” turned inside out in front of people.

With Gogol it is the opposite: on July 8, he returns the book and writes a letter defending his own honor. He asserts that each station in life was determined by the Almighty, lists thirty years of service without a stain, and complains about those who spy on the life of a poor copying clerk: “Why write about someone else who sometimes goes without, who doesn't take his tea?” What hurts is recognizing himself in the petty economies of the clerk in the book.

He wants a different ending for the hero: that the overcoat be found and that the general, learning of his virtues, transfer him to his own chancellery. The text leaves two readings open: the modesty of a poor man who fears exposure and, without his realizing it, the proof that Gogol wrote truly. In August the fear gets a name: becoming a character in Ratazyaev's literature.

More questions about Poor Folk

See all questions