Clavis Libri

Questions · Confessions

What is the theft of the pears in the Confessions?

It is the central episode of Book II: at sixteen, Augustine and a gang of boys shake a pear tree near the family vineyard, at night, carry off enormous loads of fruit and throw them to the pigs. They did not steal out of hunger or a desire to eat, and that is what makes him return to the episode for an entire book (Book II, ch. 4).

The pear tree bore fruit without beauty or flavor, and he had better fruit at home. Augustine asks God what his heart was seeking there, and answers: to be gratuitously wicked, with no other cause for the wickedness than wickedness itself. To test the thesis, he reviews the sins he knows and shows that every sin pursues some lesser good, such as beauty, honor, power or friendship. The murderer kills out of greed, fear or revenge, and even Catiline, who seemed cruel for no reason, wanted to gain power (Book II, chs. 5 and 6). Each passion imitates a divine attribute in a crooked way: pride imitates loftiness, ambition imitates honor, curiosity imitates knowledge, and theft imitates the freedom of one who does with impunity what is not allowed.

The book corrects its own answer once more. Augustine discovers that he would not have done it alone: the pleasure was not in the fruit but in the company of those who sinned together, in the laughter of deceiving someone who suspected nothing, and in the "let us go, let us do it," which the shame of seeming less shameless than the others kept him from resisting (Book II, chs. 8 and 9).

For this reason the scene admits two readings, and the text keeps them together: pure sin, the will that turns from God without needing a reason, and the boy who only wanted to be accepted by the group.

More questions about Confessions

See all questions