Clavis Libri

Confessions · Book IV

The Death of the Friend

Chapter summary

Augustine summarizes the years from nineteen to twenty-eight as the time when he seduced and was seduced (ch. 1): in public, through the liberal arts and the glory of the theater; in secret, through the false religion of the Manichees, which promised him purification. He teaches rhetoric and, moved by greed, sells the art of winning by the word, but says he prefers good students and teaches the tricks for defending a guilty man, never for wounding an innocent one (ch. 2). He lives with one woman, to whom he is faithful without legitimate marriage, and learns from her the distance between the covenant of begetting children and the covenant of desiring love. He refuses to let a haruspex sacrifice a fly to win him victory in a poetry contest, but corrects himself: he did not refuse out of love for the purity of God, whom he did not yet know how to love, but because he did not want to owe anything to the demons to whom he himself sacrificed through superstition.

For this reason he keeps consulting the astrologers, who sacrifice to no one, and their doctrine, which removes the guilt of sin from man and places it on the stars, is what they teach (ch. 3). An old and shrewd physician, the same proconsul who had set the crown of the contest on his head, warns him kindly, as a father would: he himself studied the astrologers' craft to live by it and gave it up because it was false, and he attributes the hits to the force of chance, like a poet's verse that falls by lot upon the question of whoever opens it. Neither he nor Nebridius, who mocks divination, dissuades him, because Augustine still does not have an argument that shows the hit to be chance.

In chapter 4 the book turns. In Thagaste, where he had begun to teach, he had made a childhood friend, a fellow student, whom he had dragged from the faith into the fables that made Monica weep. The friend falls ill, loses consciousness and is baptized without knowing it. On recovering, Augustine mocks the baptism, expecting that he would laugh too; the friend looks at him with horror, as at an enemy, and asks him to stop if he wants to remain a friend. Augustine, disturbed, postpones the conversation until his friend is strong, but the fever returns and the friend dies in his absence. The grief darkens his heart: homeland, house and familiar places become torment, nothing gives back his friend, the soul does not know how to answer why it is sad, and only weeping is sweet to him (chs. 4 and 5). Once cured, he asks why weeping is sweet, and does not close the answer (ch. 5); further on he will say that the pain went so deep because he had loved a mortal as if he were not one (ch. 8). He hated living and feared dying: a miserable life was dearer to him than his friend, and yet dying seemed to him to let die wholly the one he loved, because the souls of the two had been one (ch. 6). No pleasure gives him rest, and the God in whom he should place his soul is for him a phantom; he flees from Thagaste to Carthage, where his eyes do not seek the friend (ch. 7). Time and new friends restore him: conversations, laughter, books read together, the rare dissent that seasons consensus, everything that makes many into one (ch. 8). Hence the principle: only one who loves all in the one who cannot be lost does not lose the friend (ch. 9).

From chapter 10 on, Augustine moves from episode to doctrine. Everything beautiful and created is born, grows, and perishes, and whoever binds the soul to this with the birdlime of sensual love tears himself apart. The discourse shows us why: a syllable exists only when the previous one has died away. The Word cries out that the soul should return to where nothing passes (ch. 11), and the appeal extends to love of bodies and souls: love them in God, who came down through the Incarnation and departed so that we might find him in the heart (ch. 12). He then tells what he was writing at the time of mourning: books on the beautiful and the fitting, dedicated to the orator Hierius, whom he did not know (chs. 13 and 14). There he discovers that he loved a man for others' praise and not for what he was. He also shows how he erred: he thought of the good as unity and of evil as a substance of division, the monad and the dyad, and he imagined God as changeable before confessing that he himself had turned away (ch. 15). He closes with the knowledge that served him little: he read the Categories and the liberal arts on his own and applied them to God as if God were a body, with his back to the light (ch. 16). It ends with the house that does not fall in his absence, the eternity of God.

Analysis

The book has one wound and three ways of looking at it. First, the narrator who lives it and cannot name it. Then, the one who explains it by the rule that love set on what passes tears us apart. Finally, the one who recognizes that the same rule governs what he was writing then: praise, beauty, intelligence. The mourning for the friend is not one episode among others: it is the scene in which Augustine discovers through pain what the rest of the book teaches through doctrine.

The friend from Thagaste is the one who sees most in the book: he refuses, with sudden frankness, what Augustine still wants to uphold. Augustine, who thinks himself wounded by a death, is also wounded by a disagreement that death froze, and this unsaid thing may weigh as much as the grief. Two readings are possible: the pain is pure loss, or it is also the pain of not having been heard while there was still time.

Seduced and Seducers

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

Subscription

The complete analysis of every chapter of Confessions comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.

See the plansAlready subscribed? Sign in

Rhetoric for Sale

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

The Physician and Chance

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

The Friend Who Was Not Yet a Friend

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

The Baptism and the Horror

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

The Pain That Darkens the Heart

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

What Death Took by Half

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

The Soul in Tatters

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

The Soul Poured Out on Sand

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

Loving the Friend in God

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

Everything That Is Born Hastens Not to Be

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

The Dwelling That Does Not Withdraw

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

He Left, and He Is Here

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

The Abyss of Man and the Praise of Others

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

The Pride of Being What God Is

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

With His Back to the Light

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

Questions on this chapter

To discuss

3 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.

Test your reading

8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz