Chapter summary
Augustine already leaves behind his wicked adolescence, but he still cannot think of any substance that is not like those the eyes see. In chs. 1 and 2 he refuses to imagine God with a human figure, because he learned in the faith of the Church to flee from that, but he can conceive of him only as something corporeal, spread through space inside and outside the world: what occupies no place seems to him to be nothing. This limit is what keeps evil imaginable as mass, which sets a hostile mass against God, and it is the argument of Nebridius, given from Carthage, that frees him from them in ch. 2: if the mass could wound God, he would be corruptible, and if it could not, there would be no reason for the struggle.
Free of the Manichees, but without an answer, Augustine is left with the question of where evil comes from. In chs. 3 to 5 he knows that he wants and does not want by himself, and that this is the cause of his sin, but he does not see how to get out of the entanglement: God made everything good, so where does a wicked will come from, even in the devil? He imagines creation as a finite sponge in an infinite sea of God, and the question only grows worse: if God is good and omnipotent, why evil matter, or evil in general? What holds him is faith in the Church, which he never abandons. In ch. 6 he finally discards astrology, which he had already been dismantling, with the story of Firminus and the slave's son, born at the same hour and with opposite destinies, and with the case of the twins Esau and Jacob. In ch. 7 the anguish concentrates: he seeks where to rest and finds only the weight of the bodily images that the proud man let grow upon himself.
In ch. 9, through a man swollen with pride, books of the Platonists translated from the Greek come to him. In them he finds almost all of the beginning of the Gospel of John, but not the Incarnation, nor the humiliation of the Son, nor his death for us. Turning back into himself, in ch. 10 he sees with the eye of the soul the unchangeable light, hears "I am who am," and in chs. 11 to 16 draws from this the solution: everything that exists, as long as it exists, is good; evil is not a substance, it is the perversity of a will that turns away from the supreme being toward lower things. In ch. 17 he climbs the ladder of the powers of the soul up to the light, but cannot sustain the gaze and is pulled back by the weight of carnal habit. In chs. 18 and 19 he recognizes that the Mediator was missing: he thought of Christ only as a man of excellent wisdom, and the story of Alypius and of the Photinians and Apollinarians shows how confused the doctrine of the Incarnation was for him. In chs. 20 and 21 he closes the account: the Platonists taught him to see, but they inflated him, and only in the Bible and in Paul, read eagerly, does what was true in those books appear together with grace, tears, and the humility that the books lack.
Analysis
The book is an account of gains and losses. Augustine gains from the Platonists the spiritual substance and evil as privation, which undo the materialism and the hostile mass of the Manichees, and he loses the illusion that seeing the path is the same as walking it. That is why the account gives such weight to what he says he did not read: the absence of the Incarnation is the exact measure of what is lacking.
The book also shows how Augustine reads his own story. He says he was thrown into the Platonists before the Scriptures so as to feel in his memory the difference between presumption and confession, and the text sustains two readings: that of one who sees design where there was only the order of readings, or that of one who, already converted when writing, recognizes in that order the remedy he needed.
The Bodily Conception of God and the End of the Manichees
Analysis
Subscription
The complete analysis of every chapter of Confessions comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.
The Search for Evil and the Will
Analysis
Astrology Undone
Analysis
Anguish and Pride
Analysis
The Books of the Platonists
Analysis
The Unchangeable Light and Being
Analysis
Evil as Privation
Analysis
The Vision That Does Not Hold
Analysis
The Mediator and the Incarnation
Analysis
Taking Stock
Analysis
Questions on this chapter
To discuss
3 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.
Test your reading
8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz