Chapter summary
The first nine books told a life; Book X changes genre and examines the instrument with which that life was told. Augustine opens by asking to know God as he is known by God (ch. 1), and asks what use there is in confessing in writing what he has already confessed to God, who sees all. He answers that the fruit lies in others: whoever reads it with charity rejoices in the good that is in it and sighs over the evil, and this helps him not to fall asleep in despair. For this reason he wants to say not who he was but who he is now, without judging himself, because there is in each man something that not even his own spirit knows (chs. 3 to 5). From here arises the double question that moves the book: how to know oneself, if not everything in oneself is accessible to him, and where to find God, who is not the image of any thing the senses have brought in.
He begins from outside. He loves God with certainty, and what he loves is not the beauty of the body, nor light, nor melody, nor perfume, but a light, a voice, a food of the inner man (ch. 6). He questions the earth, the sea, the air, and the sky, and all answer that they are not God and were made by him. Only one who has reason capable of judging hears the answer: it comes through the senses, but it is the inner man who receives it. Augustine then climbs by steps: he passes the force that animates the body and the one that feels, which horses and mules also have, and arrives at the fields and palaces of memory (chs. 7 and 8). There are the images of what the senses brought, each through its own door, and there he finds himself, with what he did, when and how he felt. He marvels: the spirit does not fit wholly within itself, and men admire mountains and stars and forget to admire this.
Then he distinguishes what memory keeps. Of the liberal arts and numbers it keeps the things themselves, without image, which did not enter through any door of the body and were already there before being learned; learning is gathering what was scattered, which explains the verb "cogitate" (cogitare, from cogere, to gather) (chs. 9 to 12). Of the affections it keeps the notion without the disturbance: he remembers having been glad without gladness, as the stomach keeps food without its taste (chs. 13 to 15). Forgetting poses the finest riddle: to recognize the word "forgetfulness" one must remember it, yet what forgetting does is erase memory. Augustine does not resolve it, he passes through: he is certain that he remembers forgetting (ch. 16). None of these faculties is God, and he decides to pass through memory as well, but he meets the difficulty that, if he finds God outside it, it will be because he does not remember him (chs. 17 to 19). The answer comes through happiness: whoever seeks God seeks the happy life, and no one would seek what he did not know, so the happy life is in some way in everyone's memory. All want to rejoice in the truth, and this joy is full only in God; those who hate it hate the truth that reproves them, not the truth that illuminates them (chs. 20 to 23). He concludes that he did not find God outside memory, but neither did he find him in any of its regions, nor in the images, nor in the affections, nor in the seat of his own spirit: he found him above, and for that very reason present within it (chs. 24 to 26). Then comes the "late have I loved you": God was within and Augustine without, and the senses that memory inventoried now serve to say how God reached him (ch. 27).
The second half uses the examined instrument for an examination of conscience. Because human life as a whole is a temptation, it calls for continence, and Augustine asks for what the Lord commands (chs. 28 to 30). He goes through the concupiscence of the flesh: what survives in sleep, eating and drinking, perfume, the chant of the Church, which moves him and makes him waver between the danger of pleasure and its benefit, light and works of art (chs. 30 to 34). He follows the concupiscence of the eyes, curiosity, which disguises itself as knowledge and feeds even on small things, like the lizard that hunts flies (chs. 35 and 36). And he closes with the ambition of the age: to be feared and loved by men through a joy that is not joy, the temptation he least knows how to measure, because he delights in praise and does not know whether it is for the usefulness of his neighbor or for himself (chs. 36 to 39). He then retraces the whole path: without God he distinguished nothing of what he passed through, and none of that was God (ch. 40), and he confesses that he wanted to possess the lie with him (ch. 41). Those who sought a mediator between the angels, out of curiosity and pride, were deceived, and the only true mediator is the man Christ Jesus, mortal with men and just with God (chs. 42 and 43). It is through him that Augustine hopes to be healed, and it is through him that he gives up fleeing into solitude, because Christ died so that the living would no longer live for themselves.
Analysis
The book is the hinge of the work: the question that moves him, who am I, I who cannot contain myself, is answered only by a presence that exceeds him. The examination of memory, at first sight a psychological curiosity, prepares two movements that the book carries out next: to find God without confusing him with anything memory keeps, and to use memory to measure temptations without being kindled again by them. Hence the argument walks from outside inward and from inside upward, and Book XI can ask about time with the instrument already described.
The book ends by returning to its beginning. A book that showed that a human being cannot know himself completely on his own could not end with a conclusion about himself: it ends by handing him over to a mediator that his own examination could not produce. Pride, which escapes self-examination, and Christ, whom medicine reaches, make the same gesture from two sides: Augustine admits the limit of his instrument and, in the same step, says where it is completed.
Why Confess What One Still Is
Analysis
Subscription
The complete analysis of every chapter of Confessions comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.
Loving God and Questioning the World
Analysis
The Fields and Palaces of Memory
Analysis
The Things Themselves, Not Their Images
Analysis
The Memory of Feelings
Analysis
The Paradox of Forgetting
Analysis
Beyond Memory
Analysis
The Happy Life Within Memory
Analysis
Where God Dwells
Analysis
Late Have I Loved You
Analysis
Give What You Command
Analysis
Song and Curiosity
Analysis
The Ambition of the Age and Praise
Analysis
The Lie One Wanted to Possess and the Mediator
Analysis
Questions on this chapter
To discuss
3 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.
Test your reading
8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz