Chapter summary
Augustine arrives in Carthage, and the book opens by saying what he sought there: he did not yet love, and he loved to love. He hungered for an inner food, God himself, but did not feel that hunger, and the emptier he was, the more he was sickened by what is incorruptible. So the sick soul threw itself outward, eager to be scratched by contact with sensible things. He wants to love and to be loved, above all with the body of the one who loves, and he fouls the spring of friendship with the mire of desire. He falls into the love he wanted, is loved in return, secretly reaches the bond of pleasure, and sees himself whipped by the burning rods of jealousy, suspicion, fear, anger and quarrel (ch. 1).
The theater seizes him because it shows him his own misery. He asks why someone wants to suffer watching tragedies he would not endure living, and finds the answer in what the spectator asks of the actor: not to help, only to hurt, and to applaud more the more it hurts. If the play does not make one weep, the audience leaves bored; if it does, they stay attentive and weep with pleasure. What is called compassion there is a loved pain, and Augustine diagnoses it as a daughter of the same vein as friendship, diverted into a torrent of boiling pitch. But he does not order mercy abolished: he distinguishes the pain that charity approves from the pain that one loves, and says that today he feels more compassion for someone who rejoices in vice than for someone who loses a bad pleasure. His life at that time, he concludes, was a scratch on the surface, with a tumor and pus beneath (chs. 2 and 3).
Then came the studies. In the courts he wants to shine, and the more fraudulent, the more he is praised. In the school of rhetoric he grows in arrogance, but keeps away from the "demolishers," young men who humiliate the timid for fun, though he lives among them and sometimes enjoys their friendship. He calls their amusement the work of demons (ch. 3). At nineteen, already fatherless, he studies the program of eloquence and comes to a book of Cicero, the Hortensius, an exhortation to philosophy. What holds him is not the language but what the book says: it changed his affections, turned his prayers toward God, made every vain hope seem worthless, and kindled in him a burning desire for immortal wisdom. Only one thing held him back: the name of Christ, which his heart had drunk in with his mother's milk, was not there. What does not carry that name, however literary and true it may be, does not take him whole (ch. 4).
Then he seeks the Scriptures and finds them unworthy of comparison with the dignity of Cicero: humble in their gait, lofty in their end, veiled by mysteries, made to grow with the little ones, and he refuses to be little. In this swelling he falls among the Manichees, who have on their lips the name of God, of Christ and of the Paraclete, and repeat "truth, truth," but do not have it. They serve him sun and moon and shining phantoms on plates, and he, hungry, eats without being nourished, because they gave him works of God instead of God (chs. 5 and 6). Still he thought he had found the Truth, and God was deeper within him than he himself was. The sect offers him questions he cannot answer: where evil comes from, whether God has a body with hair and nails, whether the patriarchs were just with several wives. Augustine confesses that he did not know that evil is the privation of good, that God is spirit without parts, nor that justice is one, although it dispenses different precepts in different times, like the poet who cannot put the same foot in every verse (ch. 7). What ought to be done stands above each people's custom, and what God commands is just even when it contradicts the human covenant; sins are born of the wish to command, the wish to see and the wish to feel, and they return to God by the path of humility (chs. 8 and 9).
The Manichees led him to laugh at the prophets, and the laughter led him to believe that the fig weeps when it is picked, and that the holy man who eats it exhales angels, particles of God trapped in the fruit, when he prays and belches. To give bread to a beggar who was not a Manichee seemed a capital crime (ch. 10). It is then that God's hand, coming from on high, pulls him from the depths, through his mother's weeping. Monica has a consoling dream: she stands on a wooden rule, a radiant young man asks her the cause of her weeping, and having heard her he tells her to see that where she is, her son will also be, and she sees him at her side on the same rule. When she tells the dream to her son, he tries to twist it so that she would become a Manichee, but she answers at once, without hesitation, that it was not said "where he is, there you will be," but "where you are, there he will be." Nine years pass in mire and attempts to rise, and she does not stop weeping at every hour of prayer. In a second sign, she asks a bishop, who had been handed over as a child to the Manichees and had read and copied their books, to talk with her son. He refuses, prudently: Augustine is puffed up with the novelty of the heresy and has already confused many ignorant people with little questions. He orders that she be left alone, that she only pray, and that he himself will discover the error by reading. Faced with her insistence and her tears, the bishop dismisses her, saying it is impossible that the son of so many tears should be lost (chs. 11 and 12).
Analysis
Book III piles up three misdirected hungers: that of love (ch. 1), that of compassion without help (ch. 2), and that of truth that comes in the package of an empty name (ch. 6). In all of them Augustine looks outside for what is found only within, and the book says so with the formula that appears in the middle of the Manichean lies, that of a God more inward than the most intimate. What is saved at each stage is the question, not the answer: the spectator who wants to weep asks what pain is, the reader of Cicero asks for the name of Christ, and the Manichee asks where evil comes from.
Hortensius and the Manichees are two symmetrical disappointments: in Cicero's book there is serious content without the name, and in the sect there is the name without content. And the mother stands at the extreme: she hardly speaks in the book, but it is she who reads what he does not read. Augustine, who writes after everything, knows that the conversion came by that path, and recounts pride as the obstacle that kept Scripture from entering.
Carthage, Desire and the Theater
Analysis
Subscription
The complete analysis of every chapter of Confessions comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.
The Hortensius and the Missing Name
Analysis
Pride Before Scripture and the Sect
Analysis
What He Did Not Know: Evil, Justice and the Logic of the Sect
Analysis
The Weeping Fig
Analysis
Monica's Dream and the Bishop
Analysis
Questions on this chapter
To discuss
3 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.
Test your reading
8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz