Clavis Libri

Questions · Confessions

What does Augustine say about time in the Confessions?

In Book XI, Augustine says that time does not exist outside the soul: past, present and future are three presents in memory, in attention and in expectation, and time is a distension of the soul. The question that leads him there is another: what was God doing before he created heaven and earth?

He rejects the joking answer, prefers to confess that he does not know, and then answers firmly: before creating heaven and earth God was doing nothing, because if he had been doing something, he would have been making a creature. Time itself is a creature, so there was no "before" and no centuries of idleness, and the question dissolves. God precedes times not in time, but by the height of an ever-present eternity (Book XI, chs. 12 and 13).

From there the question moves to what time is. "If no one asks me, I know; if I want to explain it to someone who asks, I do not know" (Book XI, ch. 14). The past no longer is, the future not yet is, and the present, divided into century, year, day and hour, shrinks to a point without extension. Even so, we measure intervals of time. Augustine concludes that past and future can only exist as presents: the past as memory, the future as expectation, and the present as attention (Book XI, chs. 15 to 20).

He denies that time is the movement of the stars: if the potter's wheel were turning, we would measure the turn and the time of the wheel, and movement is measured by time, it is not time (Book XI, chs. 22 to 24). The measure lies in the soul, and the example is reciting a well-known hymn: while reciting it, the mind expects what is still to come, attends to what passes and remembers what has already passed, so that the future diminishes and the past grows in the very act (Book XI, chs. 27 and 28).

In the end, the theory turns into personal confession: Augustine's life is distension, scattered among times whose order he does not know, and only the Mediator gathers it, so that he may go on, not distended but stretched out, toward the heavenly prize (Book XI, ch. 29).

More questions about Confessions

See all questions