Chapter summary
Having finished narrating his own life, Augustine turns back to Scripture and asks why he still tells so much to a God who knows everything. He answers that it is not to inform him: it is to stir up his own affection and that of the readers, and because God first wanted him to confess (ch. 1). He asks for time free from the obligations of the body and of ministry to meditate on the Law, and asks that the closed passages be opened, because what he seeks in Christ is hidden in the books of Moses (chs. 2 and 3). Since he cannot question Moses, who has already passed on, he appeals to the Truth that speaks within without any tongue, and that would make him say "it tells the truth" (ch. 3, par. 5).
He then starts from the first verse of Genesis. Heaven and earth change, and what changes was made: their evidence is their voice (ch. 4). God did not make the world as a craftsman, who gives form to a matter already existing with an ingenuity that also came from him: there was no place or matter before creation, and he made by what he said (ch. 5). But how did he say? Not with syllables that sound and pass, like the voice that came down from the cloud at baptism, since that presupposes a bodily creature already there to vibrate. God's saying is the coeternal Word, in which everything is said at once and forever, and what begins and ends begins and ends only when the eternal reason knows it must (chs. 6 to 8). This Word is the Principle and the inner Teacher who brings back the wanderer: Augustine trembles at being unlike him and burns at being like him (chs. 8 and 9).
Then the objection that organizes the book appears: what was God doing before creating? If idle, why did the will to create suddenly arise, which would wound eternity? And if the will was eternal, why not the creature (ch. 10)? Augustine says that the heart of those who ask still flies between past and future and cannot stop to see eternity, in which nothing passes and everything is present (ch. 11). He refuses the jesting answer, prefers to confess that he does not know, and answers firmly: before creating heaven and earth God was doing nothing, for if he did, he would be making a creature (ch. 12). Moreover: time itself is a creature, so there was no "before" and no ages of idleness, and the question comes undone (ch. 13). God precedes times not in time, but by the height of an ever-present eternity: his today does not yield to tomorrow (ch. 13, par. 16).
From there the question moves from the beginning of the world to what time is. Everyone knows; no one explains (ch. 14). The past no longer is, the future not yet is, and the present, if it stood still, would be eternity; time is only because it tends not to be. We say "long time," but of what? The past no longer is and the future not yet is; the present, divided into century, year, month, day, hour, shrinks to a point without extension (ch. 15). Yet we measure intervals of time while they pass (ch. 16). Augustine then asks himself whether past and future exist in some hidden way: the prophets saw the future, and whoever narrates the past says true things (chs. 17 and 18). He concludes that, wherever they are, they are only as present: of the childhood that is no more, the image remains in memory, and of the sunrise announced, the sign that is already there (chs. 18 and 19). He corrects the way of speaking: strictly speaking there are three presents in the mind, the present of things past (memory), the present of things present (sight) and the present of things future (expectation) (ch. 20).
The problem of measure remains to be solved. We measure the time that passes, but it comes from the future, crosses the present without space and goes into the past: in what space is it measured (ch. 21)? Augustine refuses the thesis that time is the movement of the stars or of any body: if the potter's wheel turned, we would also measure its turning, and when the sun stood still in battle time went on; movement is measured by time, it is not time (chs. 22 to 24). He comes to confess that he knows how to speak of time and does not know what it is (ch. 25), and sees that perhaps time is a distension, but "of what, I do not know" (ch. 26). He examines a voice that sounds and the verse "Deus creator omnium": the short and the long syllable do not coexist, and if the voice still sounds it has no end, and if it has ended it does not exist. What is measured, therefore, is something that stays in memory: it is in the mind that times are measured, by the impression that passing things leave and that remains (ch. 27). The reason is that the mind does three things at once: it expects, attends and remembers, so that the future diminishes and the past grows in the very action of the mind. The example is reciting a known hymn, and the same holds for the longer action, for the whole life and for the history of human beings (ch. 28).
At the close, distension turns into personal confession: life is distension, scattered in times whose order Augustine does not know, and only the Mediator gathers it, so that he may go on, not distended but extended, toward the prize of the heavenly calling (ch. 29). He will be firm in God, in the truth that is his form, and he asks those who still ask "what was God doing before" to see that there is no "never" where there is no time (ch. 30). A last contrast measures the distance: a mind that knew all the past and the future as Augustine knows a hymn would be admirable, but God does not know in this way, because his knowledge does not vary with what is expected and remembered; just as he knows without variation, he made without distension of action (ch. 31).
Analysis
The book begins as prayer and ends as prayer, and the argument in the middle is the answer of someone who asks the God who made him. The question about the "before" is only the trigger: what Augustine really wants is to read "in the beginning" without betraying the text, and for that he must show that time is not a stage where God waited, but something he made. From then on the book changes place: from the world to the soul, where time, which is nowhere outside it, is measured. Whether it is so because Augustine finds no other place where past and future could be, or because the experience of reciting a hymn shows it, the book sustains both readings without separating them.
The distension is not only a theory. It is the way Augustine describes himself after ten books of confession: a life scattered into instants that he gathers only through memory and expectation, and that only the grace of a Mediator brings together. The theory of time and the confession of the scattered mind are the same thing seen from two sides, and that is why the book, apparently a detour into philosophy, belongs to the Confessions.
A Confession That Does Not Inform
Analysis
Subscription
The complete analysis of every chapter of Confessions comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.
How God Made It: Without Matter and Without Syllables
Analysis
The Objection of Before
Analysis
The Refused Answer
Analysis
Time Is a Creature
Analysis
Eternity as Ever Present
Analysis
What Is Time, If No One Asks
Analysis
The Three Presents
Analysis
Where What Is Measured Passes
Analysis
Time Is Not the Movement of Bodies
Analysis
Distension, But of What?
Analysis
The Short Syllable and the Long
Analysis
In You I Measure Times
Analysis
The Known Hymn
Analysis
Life Is Distension
Analysis
God Does Not Know as One Knows a Hymn
Analysis
Questions on this chapter
To discuss
3 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.
Test your reading
8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz