Clavis Libri

Confessions · Book VI

Ambrose, Alypius and Ambition

Chapter summary

Augustine arrives in Milan neither a Manichean nor a Catholic Christian, doubtful that he can find the truth. Monica reaches him by sea and by land, without fear, because God had promised her in a vision that he would arrive safely. On hearing that her son is no longer a Manichean, but not yet a Catholic, she is not alarmed: she knows God will do what is lacking, and she begins to run to church to hear Ambrose (ch. 1). There she obeys without argument the bishop's prohibition against bringing food and wine to the tombs of the martyrs, because she sought piety and not pleasure, and Ambrose esteems her for her religious life, without knowing that her son doubts everything (ch. 2).

Augustine no longer asks for help: he busies himself with seeking and with debating. He judges Ambrose a man happy by worldly standards, honored by the powerful, and only celibacy seems hard to him; he does not know what the bishop keeps in his heart. The crowd around Ambrose prevents him from questioning him alone, and in the few free moments he sees him read without moving his voice (ch. 3). On Sundays he hears him preach and perceives that the knots the Manichees had tied against Scripture come undone, and, through the spiritual children of the Church, he learns that the image of God in man does not mean a God of human form; he is ashamed of having barked at a phantom of carnal thoughts (chs. 3 and 4). He begins to hear the Old Testament read in a spiritual sense without repugnance, but holds back his assent out of fear of the precipice: he wanted a certainty like that of seven and three making ten, and he refused the remedy of faith like one who fears every physician after having met a bad one (ch. 4). Little by little he admits that the whole of human life rests on believing what has not been seen, and that Catholic teaching, which commands belief without demonstration, is more modest than that of the Manichees, who promised knowledge and then demanded belief in fables; he concludes that Scripture, open to all and deep for those who investigate it, exists to be believed and to lead to God (ch. 5).

But he keeps chasing honors, gains, and marriage (ch. 6). One day, while preparing a lying eulogy for the emperor, he passes a cheerful beggar in Milan, already satisfied, and comments to his friends on the madness of seeking the same joy by such painful ways. If someone asked him, he would prefer to be the beggar or to be himself, and anxious, out of vanity of position, he would choose himself: he wanted to please, not to teach (ch. 6).

The book then turns to Alypius, a younger fellow townsman, his student in Thagaste and in Carthage. The circus had swallowed him; Augustine could not admonish him because of a quarrel with Alypius's father, but during a lesson a comparison with the games wounds him without Augustine intending it, and Alypius leaves the circus and overcomes his father's resistance to keep studying with him. He went on to follow Manichaeism, seduced by the appearance of continence (ch. 7). In Rome, dragged by friends to the amphitheater, he declares that he will be there absent in spirit and closes his eyes on arrival, but the roar of the crowd makes him open them, and he leaves the spectacle more intoxicated than the others (ch. 8). In Carthage, wrongly arrested with an axe that was not his, he is saved by an architect and a boy, and learns not to condemn lightly (ch. 9). In Rome he resists a powerful senator who tries to extract an illicit favor from him with promise and threat, and he follows Augustine to Milan, undecided like him about what life to take up. Nebridius also leaves home and land to live with them in the search for truth (ch. 10).

The three groan under their own occupations, but leave nothing, because they see no certainty on the other side. Augustine, at thirty, keeps repeating that tomorrow he will find the truth, calculates the hours he could give to the search, accepts that the Catholic faith does not teach what he supposed, and at the same time promises himself honor, influential friends, the post of governor, and a wife with a dowry, arguing that many wise men lived married. He fears losing what a wife would give him and attributes continence to forces he does not have, without asking God for it (ch. 11). Alypius dissuades him from marrying, because the two could not live together in the peace of wisdom; Augustine resists with the example of wise married men and, without meaning to, infects his friend, who begins to desire marriage out of curiosity (ch. 12). They insist on marriage: Augustine asks for a girl who still needed nearly two years to become marriageable, and Monica wants him married so that baptism may wash him clean; the visions she asked for about the bride never came (ch. 13). A plan among ten friends to live together with common goods, with Romanianus at the head, collapses when someone asks whether the women will consent (ch. 14).

Augustine's companion, the mother of his son, is torn from him and returns to Africa, swearing she will know no other man; he, who is not a lover of marriage but a slave of lust, finds another woman to get through the two years, and the open wound festers (ch. 15). What holds him at the bottom of the abyss is the fear of death and of judgment. He discusses with Alypius and Nebridius the limits of good and evil and says that Epicurus would win if he did not believe in the life of the soul after death; in the end he recognizes that everything is hard outside God and that only in him is there rest (ch. 16).

Analysis

The book is the portrait of a man who already understands and yet does not want to. In Ambrose, Augustine finds the method of reading that undoes the Manichean argument, and the reason to believe without seeing that dismantles the pretext of doubt; his intellect is convinced before his will gives way. What holds him back is what he himself calls cupiditates: honor, money, a woman, and the waiting for his own convenience, which makes him say tomorrow like one who heals by postponing.

The other axis is Alypius, who mirrors and anticipates his friend: the amphitheater shows what trust in oneself does to someone who thinks himself strong, and the senator shows what upright character refuses. Augustine, whom Alypius tries to dissuade from marrying and who ends up infecting his friend with the same desire, sees in the other what he cannot be: he hears the right advice and repels it like one who pushes away the hand that lets him go. The end of the book, with the wound of separation and the question about Epicurus, leaves the problem for Books VII and VIII.

Monica Arrives

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

Subscription

The complete analysis of every chapter of Confessions comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.

See the plansAlready subscribed? Sign in

Ambrose Reading

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

What the Preaching Untied

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

Believing Without Seeing

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

The Beggar of Milan

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

Alypius Corrected Unawares

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

The Amphitheater and the Theft That Did Not Happen

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

Tomorrow, Later, Never

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

Marriage and the Shared Life Project

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

The Wound of Separation

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

The Fear of Death and the Only Rest

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

Questions on this chapter

To discuss

3 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.

Test your reading

8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz