Clavis Libri

Confessions · Book XII

The Heaven of Heaven and the Readings of Genesis

Chapter summary

After asking in Book XI what time is, Augustine returns to the first verse of Genesis, "In the beginning God made heaven and earth," and spends the rest of the work commenting on it. He begins by confessing that the heart is stirred before Scripture, and that inquiry says more than discovery, but that the promise that whoever knocks receives sustains him (ch. 1). He then asks where the "heaven of heaven" of the psalm is, the heaven we do not see and for which the whole visible universe, even our sky, is "earth" (ch. 2). And he asks what the "invisible and formless earth" over which there was darkness was: darkness is the absence of light, as silence is the absence of sound, and formless matter, before receiving figure, was not anything determinate, yet it was not absolute nothing (chs. 3 to 5). He confesses that before he imagined this matter populated with horrid forms, and so did not truly think of it; he came to suspect it only by looking at the change of bodies, which pass from form to form through something formless, not through nothing (ch. 6). Now, if it exists, it exists through God: he made it out of nothing, not out of himself, and therefore made two things, one near himself and the other near nothing (chs. 7 and 8).

From here comes the point that holds up the rest: neither the heaven of heaven nor formless matter is in time. The heaven of heaven is an intellectual creature which, clinging to God in contemplation, does not change and therefore escapes succession; formless matter, without form, does not vary from one form to another, and where nothing varies there are no days (ch. 9). In the middle of the reasoning Augustine breaks off into a prayer: he went astray, returned, heard the voice calling him from behind, and comes back breathless to the source (ch. 10). He takes up again what God told him "in the inner ear": that he is immutable, that everything that is not him was made by him, that the creature who contemplates him without interval knows neither past nor future, and he calls this creature "house of God" (ch. 11). He concludes that there are two beings without time, the fully formed and the wholly formless, and that Scripture, when it says "In the beginning God made heaven and earth" without naming any day, has them in view (chs. 12 and 13).

In ch. 14 the scene changes. Whoever disagrees with him is not an enemy of Scripture but its admirer, and says that Moses did not mean this but something else. Augustine first asks what, of what was shown to him about the eternity of the Creator and the sublime creature, they take to be false, and they grant everything (ch. 15). He then asks God to be the judge between his confessions and their contradictions (ch. 16). He sets out the competing readings: heaven and earth would be the whole visible world; or the confused matter from which the world came; or the invisible and visible creature already formed; or matter still formless (ch. 17), and he combines them with each possible sense of "invisible and formless earth" (ch. 21). To the argument that Moses did not record the creation of matter, he replies that he also did not record that of the waters or of the angels, and that truth teaches that the formless was made from nothing (ch. 22).

Chapter 18 formulates the principle of reading: he does not want to argue over words, and asks what harm there is in understanding a true thing that the author perhaps did not think of. In chs. 19 to 21 he lists the common truths that no one doubts, and shows that each reader draws from them a different sentence. He distinguishes two kinds of disagreement, one about the truth of things and one about the author's will (ch. 23), and confesses that he sees what is true more firmly than he sees what Moses thought (ch. 24). Whoever says "Moses did not feel this, he felt what I say," without denying that both things are true, loves his own opinion because it is his, and not because it is true; truth belongs to everyone, and whoever takes it as private passes from truth to falsehood (ch. 25). Both see what is true in the immutable truth above minds, and fighting over the thought of one's neighbor offends charity, which was the aim of everything Moses said (ch. 25). If he himself were Moses, he would ask for the gift of speaking in such a way that those who do not yet understand would not refuse, and those who already understand would find their truth in it (ch. 26). The image that closes the argument is that of the spring that becomes many streams, and that of two kinds of readers: those still in the nest, to whom the simple letter feeds faith, and those who fly through the bushes and gather hidden fruits (chs. 27 and 28).

In chs. 29 to 32 he returns to the technical point to close it: if "in the beginning" means "first," what was made first is matter, and there are four ways of being "prior" (by eternity, by time, by choice, by origin). Matter is prior to what is made from it as the sound is prior to the song: without an interval of time, but by origin (ch. 29). If they ask him what Moses understood, he answers "I do not know," and knows that the statements are true (ch. 30). He prefers to believe that Moses saw all the senses that can be seen, and wrote in such a way that all of them would resonate (ch. 31). He ends by asking God to show either the reading the author intended or another true one, so that God may nourish him and error may not deceive him, and he asks leave to confess more briefly (ch. 32).

Analysis

The book has two halves that seem to be about different subjects and are the same gesture. In the first, Augustine deals with things that language reaches only by negation: the heaven we do not see, the formless earth, what is not in time; and the proof that he speaks rightly is that he himself confesses he had not thought them through well before. In the second, he applies this humility to the very act of reading: if not even formless matter lets itself be stated with certainty, still less can one guarantee what an ancient author had in mind. For this reason the plurality of readings is not a caprice, but a consequence of knowing how much one does not know.

The measure the book proposes has two checks. One rejects relativism: each reading must be true, and he never ceases to say that there are false ones, from which he keeps his distance. The other rejects possession: no one owns the truth, nor the meaning of a text. It should be remembered that the thesis has its limit within the book itself, when Scripture is taken as the work of a single inspired author; outside that, the argument loses force, and one can also read Augustine as someone who comforts his own method with a guarantee that today's reader perhaps does not have.

The Heaven of Heaven and Formless Matter

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

Subscription

The complete analysis of every chapter of Confessions comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.

See the plansAlready subscribed? Sign in

Outside Time

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

What Moses Meant

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

The Spring and the Streams

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

Questions on this chapter

To discuss

3 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.

Test your reading

8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz