Chapter summary
The book opens with an offering of praise and with the question of where Augustine was when he sought God: those who flee from God do not escape him, and whoever turns back finds him in his own heart (chs. 1 and 2). Then the narrative enters the year he was twenty-nine. The Manichee bishop Faustus of Milevis arrives in Carthage, reputed to be the master of all doctrines, and Augustine had been waiting for him for almost nine years, because the other Manichees, without answers to his objections about the stars, promised him that Faustus would resolve everything. He already knew from philosophy the calculations that predict eclipses, and he compared them with Mani's long myths about the heavens, which did not explain them: in the Manichaean books they ordered him to believe where reason and the eyes had already verified something else (chs. 3 to 6). Hence the digression of ch. 4 and ch. 5: knowing how to measure the sky does not make anyone happy without knowing God, and Mani, in writing about the stars and still attributing what he wrote to the Holy Spirit, showed his falsehood where it could be checked.
When Faustus arrives, he is pleasant and speaks better than the others, but Augustine thirsts for substance and receives a pretty cup. He had already learned, taught by God, that the truth does not depend on whether it is spoken well or badly, and that those who recommended Faustus judged wise whoever delighted them (ch. 6). When Augustine puts his questions to him, he discovers that Faustus, beyond grammar and some readings of Cicero and Seneca, has no science at all. But, faced with what he did not know, Faustus does not pretend: he confesses his ignorance without shame, and this makes him more lovable in Augustine's eyes than the knowledge Augustine was seeking (ch. 7). The result is not a rupture but discouragement: the zeal to advance in the sect ends, and he is content to stay where he is until something better appears. Without wanting or knowing it, Faustus loosened the bond that held him.
Augustine then decides to go teach rhetoric in Rome, and the reason he confesses is that the students of Carthage burst into classes without order, while in Rome they told him discipline was better; besides, his friends promised him more income and honor (ch. 8). His mother, Monica, follows him to the sea and wants either to hold him back or to go along. He deceives her: he pretends to wait for a friend until the wind rises, and he leaves at night, while she stays behind praying at the memorial of Saint Cyprian. She prayed that he would not sail, and God, not granting what she asked, gave her what she had always asked for. In Rome he falls ill with a severe fever, is on the way to hell for his sins and for not believing that Christ truly died, and does not ask for baptism. Monica, unaware, prays for him from afar, and he recovers (chs. 9 and 10). Once recovered, he lodges with a Manichee and remains among the "elect" of the sect, because he preferred to think that it was not he who sinned but another nature within him. He thought of God and of evil as bodily masses, one good and the other evil, and so he feared believing that Christ had been born in the flesh: it would be believing that the flesh had defiled him. The Academics seem prudent to him, for doubting everything, but he does not trust them to heal the soul. The students of Rome are another kind of problem: they do not break the order of lessons, but they stop paying the teacher by agreement, switching teachers, and he hates them more for what he would have to suffer than for the evil they did (chs. 10 to 12).
The way out then appears: Milan asks the prefecture of Rome for a teacher of rhetoric, Augustine applies through the Manichees, and the prefect Symmachus approves him and sends him. In Milan he visits Bishop Saint Ambrose, who receives him with fatherly kindness, and Augustine begins to hear the sermons as a critic of oratory, to see whether the fame is true (ch. 13). Attentive to the how and inattentive to the what, he hears content enter together with form: Ambrose reads spiritually passages of the Old Testament that, taken literally, had killed him, and the Catholic faith stops seeming indefensible without yet seeming victorious. Augustine resolves to leave the Manichees, doubts everything like the Academics, and settles as a catechumen in the Church that his parents had pointed out to him, until something certain appears (ch. 14).
Analysis
The book shows Augustine led by each thing he uses for another purpose: he goes to Faustus seeking answers and loses the sect; he flees his mother to escape Carthage and arrives in Milan; he listens to Ambrose out of a rhetorician's curiosity and is reached by the content. In every case the present account reads as providence what at the time was a calculation of ambition, comfort, and curiosity, and the account lets us see the calculation of the moment beside the providence he recognizes only afterwards.
At the same time, the book records what still holds him: he cannot think of a substance without a body, and it is this, more than any Manichaean argument, that keeps him in error and prevents him from accepting the Incarnation. The way out of academic doubt is provisional, and he knows it: without the name of Christ no philosophy heals, but he does not yet have another name to put in its place.
Where Was I When I Sought You
Analysis
Subscription
The complete analysis of every chapter of Confessions comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.
Faustus of Milevis, and Eloquence Without Content
Analysis
The Eloquence That Does Not Satisfy
Analysis
The Modesty of Faustus
Analysis
The Journey to Rome and the Deceit of His Mother
Analysis
The Illness in Rome
Analysis
The Sin That Was Not Mine
Analysis
Milan: The Meeting with Ambrose
Analysis
The Catechumen
Analysis
Questions on this chapter
To discuss
3 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.
Test your reading
8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz