Clavis Libri

Confessions · Book IX

Ostia and the Death of Monica

Chapter summary

The book opens with Augustine saying that the chains have been broken: what was all his evil, not wanting what he wanted and wanting what God wanted, is over, and the sweetness of the trifles he feared to lose now makes it a joy to let them go (ch. 1). From then on the book tells how he leaves what held him, without tumult. He decides to give up his post as a teacher of rhetoric gently, waiting for the autumn vintage holidays, which were only a few days away, so as not to cause a scandal or appear to want to seem great; a chest illness, which takes away his breath and his strong voice, gives him, as a bonus, an excuse that is not a lie and that calms those who would not want to see him free (chs. 2 to 5). Verecundus, a friend not yet a Christian and bound to marriage with a believing wife, is troubled by their conversion, but offers his property at Cassiciacum; he dies later, already a Christian, while Augustine is in Rome, and Augustine sees in this the mercy that spared him from weeping for a friend outside the flock. Nebridius rejoices and dies shortly after, in Africa, already a Catholic (chs. 3 and 4).

At Cassiciacum, with Alypius, and with Monica beside them while still a catechumen, he reads the psalms, and the fourth psalm shakes him completely: he recognizes his former life in "you love vanity and seek after lies" and wishes the Manichees could hear him (ch. 4). A toothache deprives him of speech; he writes on a tablet a request for prayer for those present, and the pain flees when they kneel. He resigns his chair at the end of the vintage and writes to Saint Ambrose, in Milan, to ask what to read; Ambrose sends the prophet Isaiah, whom he does not yet understand (ch. 5). He returns to Milan to receive baptism, with Alypius and with his son Adeodatus, about fifteen years old, son of his sin and gift of God; the dialogue The Teacher keeps the boy's voice. Once baptized, the restlessness of his past life leaves him, and he weeps as he hears the hymns of the Church (ch. 6). He then recalls the persecution by Justina, mother of the boy king Valentinian, against Ambrose, the people keeping vigil in the church, the introduction of hymns and psalms into the chant, and the discovery of the bodies of the martyrs Protasius and Gervasius, which silenced the queen's fury even without converting her (ch. 7). Evodius joins the group, and all plan to return to Africa; at Ostia, the mouth of the Tiber, Monica dies.

Augustine then pauses: he says he passes quickly over much, but not over all that his soul allows him to say of Monica (ch. 8.17). He recounts her upbringing: the old servant who raised her with strictness; the taste for wine that the girl picked up little by little, until the maid who called her a drunkard showed her how ugly it was and cured her, and he sees in this that God corrects through the mouth of one who only meant to wound (ch. 8.18). Married to Patricius, good-hearted but of violent temper, Monica served him without retaliating, waited for a calm moment to explain herself, advised her friends to see the marriage contract as the instrument of their servitude, and converted her husband at the end of his life; she won over her mother-in-law through obedience; and she was a peacemaker among people in discord (chs. 9.19 to 9.22). In the days when death draws near, mother and son, alone at a window overlooking the garden of the house at Ostia, talk about the eternal life of the saints and climb step by step, from bodily things and the visible sky up to their own minds, and from there to eternal Wisdom, which they touch for a moment with the impulse of the heart; then they come back down to the noise of the mouth (chs. 10.23 to 10.25). Monica then says that nothing holds her to life any longer, because God has granted her to see her son a Catholic (ch. 10.26). She falls ill with fever. In a faint, she asks where she was, asks to be put anywhere at all, and asks that they remember her at the altar. Before, she had cared so much about the tomb beside her husband; Augustine, astonished, sees that this vanity emptied out of her heart without his knowing. She dies on the ninth day, at fifty-six years of age, and he is thirty-three (chs. 11.27 and 11.28).

Augustine closes her eyes and forces his eyes to dry their spring; the boy Adeodatus cries out and is silenced, and Augustine falls silent with him, because the group judges that a funeral is not celebrated amid moans, as if the mother had died wretchedly or altogether (ch. 12.29). What hurts is the daily companionship, suddenly broken (ch. 12.30). Evodius intones the psalm and the house responds; Augustine speaks, represses his grief before the others, and reproaches himself for weakness of affection, which makes him suffer twice. At the burial, at the sacrifice offered beside the tomb, he does not weep; the bath does not relieve him, but sleep does, and on waking he recalls the verses of Ambrose about the night that consoles. Only then, alone, does he let the tears run before God, and he writes so that whoever wishes may judge him (chs. 12.31 to 12.33). The book ends in prayer: cured of the wound, Augustine weeps another kind of tears, those of a spirit shaken before the danger facing every soul, and he asks forgiveness for Monica's debts, and that the readers remember her and Patricius before the altar (chs. 13.34 to 13.37).

Analysis

The book has two halves that mirror each other: in the first, Augustine stops selling words, and his mother, in the background, accompanies him; in the second, the mother occupies the center and he is the one who accompanies her. What links them is the joy at the end of a journey: baptism lifts the weight of the past, the ecstasy at Ostia confirms it, and the death of Monica tests whether the doctrine sustains the one who teaches it. He does not avoid the test: he holds back his weeping out of conviction, and conviction does not heal the pain.

Monica does not appear as a poster saint. The portrait is of a woman who corrected herself (the drinking), who endured (her husband), and who in the end gave up what she wanted most (the tomb beside Patricius). Two readings fit the final prayer: Augustine asks forgiveness for her because he believes that no one, not even she, presents himself before God by his own merit; or, more humanly, because he still does not accept that his mother is beyond the reach of what he can do for her.

Giving Up the Chair

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

Subscription

The complete analysis of every chapter of Confessions comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.

See the plansAlready subscribed? Sign in

The Fourth Psalm

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

The Baptism

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

Monica from Within

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

The Vision at Ostia

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

The Death of Monica

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

Mourning

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

The Final Prayer

Analysis

Unlock with a subscription

Questions on this chapter

To discuss

3 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.

Test your reading

8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz