Clavis Libri

Theme in Confessions

Desire

Wanting: pleasure, appetite, temptation, longing for what one does not have.

The Theme in the Work

The Confessions treat desire as the force that moves the whole book, and the question that runs through it is where it points. In Book I, the restless heart of Augustine names a lack without yet saying where it hurts, and the boy who wants the game, the victory and the applause shows that lack in action. The rest of the work tells of the same force looking for an object.

In Book II, desire begins clean and turns murky: what delighted him was to love and be loved, and the measure of love is lost along the way. In Book III, he arrives in Carthage in love with loving, with nothing yet to love, and in the theater he discovers that the spectator wants the pain the spectacle gives him. Desire has no object of its own; it takes what it finds.

In Book V, the prayer of Monica asks that her son not leave for Rome, and God, who hears the axis of her desire, does not grant the request and grants what she had always asked (ch. 8). In Book VI, Augustine calls himself a slave of lust and not a lover of marriage (ch. 15). In Book VIII, desire acquires an anatomy: from the perverse will is born lust, from served lust is born habit, and from unresisted habit is born necessity (ch. 5), and the two wills of one and the same man tear each other apart.

In Book IX, the will has learned the lesson in a single sentence: not to want what he wanted and to want what God wanted (ch. 1). In Book X, he puts desire at the base of the search: all want to be happy (ch. 20), and to seek God is to seek the happy life. In Book XIII, the image of weight closes the theme: what carries the soul where it goes is its love (ch. 9).

Desire in the Confessions is not the enemy: the error is one of address. Augustine never asks the will to stop wanting; he asks it to want what quiets it, and the whole work is the account of a force that lost itself among creatures before finding where to rest. The text supports two readings of how the address changes. In one, desire is corrected by changing its object, as the Hortensius changes Augustine's vows in Book III. In the other, desire cannot be mended by its own effort: in Book VIII he commands the will to want and the command is not enough, and in Book X he asks God to give what he commands.

Where It Appears

  • Book I: The restless heart opens the book, and the boy Augustine wants the game, the victory and the applause without yet knowing what unsettles him.
  • Book II: Augustine's desire begins in loving and being loved and turns murky in adolescence and in the theft of the pears.
  • Book III: Augustine arrives in Carthage in love with loving, without an object, and the theater shows him a pleasure that feeds on another's pain.
  • Book V: Monica asks that her son not leave, and God, without granting the prayer to the letter, grants the axis of her desire.
  • Book VI: Facing the arranged marriage, Augustine recognizes himself as more a slave of lust than a lover of marriage.
  • Book VIII: Augustine shows the perverse will turning into lust, habit and necessity, and the two wills tear the soul apart until the garden.
  • Book IX: Augustine, converted, discovers that he no longer wants what he wanted and that the will learns to want what God wants.
  • Book X: Augustine observes that all want to be happy, and concludes that to seek God is to seek the happy life.
  • Book XIII: Augustine says that the weight that carries each soul to its place is its love, and that by it he is carried.

Passages

At the beginning of Book II, desire still has a simple form.

Desire begins clean and turns murky:

et quid erat quod me delectabat, nisi amare et amari? (2.2.2), and what was it that delighted me, if not to love and to be loved?
Book II: The Theft of the Pears

In Book III, desire arrives without an object and feeds on itself.

He opens the book with lack: the desire to love has no object, and feeds only on itself. nondum amabam, et amare amabam (3.1.1), I did not yet love, and I loved to love.
Book III: Carthage and the Hortensius

In Book VI, Augustine names what drove him in the planned marriage.

Unable to wait two years, he recognizes what moves him and what he did. quia non amator coniugii sed libidinis servus eram (6.15.25), because I was not a lover of marriage but a slave of lust.
Book VI: Ambrose, Alypius and Ambition

In Book VIII, the prison of desire appears in stages.

On hearing how Victorinus left his school because of Julian's law, Augustine is inflamed to imitate him, but finds himself bound, and describes the prison in stages. ex voluntate perversa facta est libido, et dum servitur libidini, facta est consuetudo, et dum consuetudini non resistitur, facta est necessitas (8.5.10), "from a perverse will came lust, and while lust was served, habit was formed, and while habit was not resisted, necessity came to be."
Book VIII: The Conversion in the Garden

In Book X, the search for God rests on a will that no one lacks.

nota est igitur omnibus, qui una voce si interrogari possent utrum beati esse vellent, sine ulla dubitatione velle responderent (10.20.29), it is therefore known to all: if they could be asked with one voice whether they wished to be happy, they would answer without any hesitation that they did.
Book X: Memory

In Book XIII, the image of weight says what moves the soul.

The physical image of the weight that carries each thing to its place serves as a grammar of love: what moves the soul is what it loves. pondus meum amor meus; eo feror, quocumque feror (13.9.10), my weight is my love; by it I am carried, wherever I am carried.
Book XIII: Creation Read in the Church