The Theme in the Work
The Confessions separate knowledge from wisdom and ask what makes a learned man a wise one. In Book III, the Hortensius of Cicero changes Augustine's vows and desires and makes him a lover of wisdom, but the book kindles him without giving him the name of Christ, and the Scriptures, which he seeks afterward, seem small to his pride (chs. 4 and 5).
In Book V, knowledge of the world, the calculations of the astronomers, is placed beside Mani, and the question becomes a comparison: unhappy is whoever knows all this and does not know God, happy is whoever knows him and ignores the rest (ch. 4). Faustus the Manichee finally arrives, eloquent enough, but he knows nothing of what Augustine expected. In Book VI, Ambrose teaches how to read the letter with the spirit, and Augustine realizes that the whole of life rests on believing what one has not seen, and that the demonstration he demanded from Scripture he does not demand from anything else (ch. 5).
In Book VII, the Platonists give him what was missing in concept, the Word, the light, being, and the verdict is that the Scriptures have everything true in them and more: the face of piety and the tears of confession. In Book VIII, erudition appears as an obstacle: the unlearned rise up and seize heaven, while he and Alypius, with doctrines lacking heart, wallow in the flesh (ch. 8). Knowing what is good is not enough to will it.
In Book X, knowledge turns back toward the knower himself: there is something in man that not even the spirit of man knows (ch. 5), and God, who made him, knows. In Book XI, comes the matter of method: everyone knows what time is until someone asks. In Book XII, knowledge is debated among readers of Genesis, and the question is whether truth can be someone's possession.
For Augustine, knowledge has two opposing ends: the knowledge one possesses and the wisdom one receives. When knowledge is possession, pride and the fight over words are born, and when it is received, the humility of Book XII appears, which sees the true above minds and not in any of them. The text leaves open what a learned man can do with this: either learn to believe, as in Book VI, or learn not to know, as in Book XI, where confessing ignorance is the most honest answer.
Where It Appears
- Book III: Cicero's Hortensius changes Augustine's vows and makes him desire, with incredible ardor, the immortality of wisdom.
- Book V: Augustine places the science of the astronomers beside the fables of Mani and compares knowing the world with knowing God.
- Book VI: Ambrose teaches reading with the spirit, and Augustine sees that the whole of life rests on believing without seeing.
- Book VII: The books of the Platonists give Augustine the Word and the light, but do not give him the Word made flesh.
- Book VIII: Augustine sees his own learning, without heart, churning in the flesh while the unlearned rise and seize heaven.
- Book X: Augustine admits that there is something in man that not even the spirit of man knows, and finds God where he finds truth.
- Book XI: Augustine confesses that he knows what time is while no one asks him, and stops knowing when he tries to explain it.
- Book XII: Augustine argues that truth is no one's possession and stands above the minds of those who argue over the text.
- Book XIII: Augustine holds that a single passage of Scripture admits many truths, understood in many ways without falsehood.
Passages
The Hortensius is the book that stirs what Augustine wants.
It is the turning point of the book and one of the most quoted passages in the work: studying rhetoric, he comes to a book whose content, not its style, changes the course of his desires.ille vero liber mutavit affectum meum, et ad te ipsum, domine, mutavit preces meas, et vota ac desideria mea fecit alia. viluit mihi repente omnis vana spes, et immortalitatem sapientiae concupiscebam aestu cordis incredibili, (3.4.7), but that book changed my disposition, turned my prayers to you yourself, Lord, and made my vows and desires other. Suddenly every empty hope seemed worthless to me, and I desired the immortality of wisdom with an incredible ardor of heart.
Science without God is measured by its effect on man.
Against the science that does not lead to God, a comparative question:
infelix enim homo qui scit illa omnia, te autem nescit; beatus autem qui te scit, etiamsi illa nesciat(5.4.7), unhappy is the man who knows all those things and does not know you; happy is he who knows you, even if he is ignorant of them.
To read Scripture, Augustine accepts the yardstick he uses for the rest of his life.
Little by little God shows him that the whole of life rests on believing what one has not seen, and that the demonstration he demanded from Scripture he does not demand from the rest.quam inconcusse fixum fide retinerem de quibus parentibus ortus essem, quod scire non possem nisi audiendo credidissem(6.5.7), with what firmness I held, by faith, which parents I was born of, something I could not know except by believing what I heard.
In the garden, the knowledge that is not enough appears in the mouth of the wise man himself.
Beside himself, he turns to Alypius and accuses himself and him of wallowing in the flesh while the unlettered take heaven.surgunt indocti et caelum rapiunt, et nos cum doctrinis nostris sine corde, ecce ubi volutamur in carne et sanguine(8.8.19), "the unlearned rise up and seize heaven, and we, with our learning without heart, behold where we wallow, in flesh and blood."
The examination of the spirit reaches the limit of what it knows of itself.
The limit of self-knowledge appears before any analysis.tamen est aliquid hominis quod nec ipse scit spiritus hominis qui in ipso est. tu autem, domine, scis eius omnia, quia fecisti eum(10.5.7), and yet there is something in man that not even the spirit of man, which is within him, knows; but you, Lord, know all of him, because you made him.
In the dispute over Moses, truth leaves each person's possession and goes to a common place.
To the imagined opponent he proposes, in a brotherly tone, a test that changes the ground of the dispute: where, after all, each one sees what he says he sees.nec ego utique in te nec tu in me, sed ambo in ipsa quae supra mentes nostras est incommutabili veritate(12.25.35), neither I certainly in you nor you in me, but both in the very unchangeable truth that is above our minds.