Clavis Libri

Character

Augustine

Who He Is

Augustine is the narrator and the protagonist of the Confessions, and the book builds him in two positions at once: the man who lived the facts, from Carthage to Milan, and the man who tells them to God years later, already a Christian and a bishop. The first nine books are his life, from infancy to his mother's death; the last four are the same man examining memory, time and Scripture. What he wants, from beginning to end, is rest, and the book shows him seeking that rest in things that pass: the game, applause, love, the sect, the career. What he ignores, while he lives, is that the lack that moves him is a lack of God; what the narrator knows, in writing, is that the end was already given. His role in the book is that of one who confesses, and so he speaks to God and not to the reader, who listens.

Trajectory

In Book I, the praise opens with the sentence that sums up the work, that of the restless heart, and the narrative goes back to the infancy he does not remember, to the punishment at school, to the applause for reciting Juno's speech and to the weeping over Dido, which he wept while not weeping for his own death, far from God. He refuses the image of innocent infancy: what is innocent in the baby is the weakness of the limbs, and the desire to have things only for oneself is already there.

The sentence that sums up the book, and by extension the work: Augustine, still at the start of the praise, gives the reason God stirs man to praise him. tu excitas ut laudare te delectet, quia fecisti nos ad te et inquietum est cor nostrum donec requiescat in te (1.1.1), you stir us so that praising you delights us, because you made us for yourself, and our heart is restless until it rests in you.
Book I: Infancy

In Book II, at sixteen years old, the ardor of youth fills three chapters, and then comes the theft of the pears, done without hunger, to throw to the pigs. Augustine seeks the cause and concludes that there was no other than wickedness, and then discovers that alone he would not have done it: the pleasure was in the group, in the "let's go, let's do it," in the shame of not being bold enough.

And the question he puts to his heart has an answer that does not satisfy:

ut essem gratis malus et malitiae meae causa nulla esset nisi malitia (2.4.9), that I might be gratuitously bad, and that there be no cause of my wickedness except wickedness.
Book II: The Theft of the Pears

In Book III, in Carthage, he loves to love, goes to the theater to weep for what he could not bear to live, and at nineteen reads Cicero's Hortensius, which changes his affections and kindles the desire for wisdom. Only the name of Christ, which he had drunk in with his mother's milk, is missing there, and pride keeps him from Scripture, too humble for him; he then falls among the Manichees, who have the name and not the truth.

It is the turn of the book and one of the most cited passages of the work: studying rhetoric, he comes upon a book whose content, not its style, changes the course of his desires. ille vero liber mutavit affectum meum, et ad te ipsum, domine, mutavit preces meas, et vota ac desideria mea fecit alia. viluit mihi repente omnis vana spes, et immortalitatem sapientiae concupiscebam aestu cordis incredibili, (3.4.7), but that book changed my feeling, turned my prayers to you yourself, Lord, and made my vows and desires other. Suddenly every vain hope seemed worthless to me, and I longed for the immortality of wisdom with an incredible burning of the heart.
Book III: Carthage and the Hortensius

In Book IV, from nineteen to twenty-eight years old, he teaches rhetoric, consults astrologers and lives with a single woman. In Thagaste he loses the childhood friend, who had reacted with horror to the mockery of the baptism and died in his absence; the grief darkens everything, and he explains it later: he had loved a mortal as if he were not mortal. The grief, which the book calls the half of the soul that departs, is the scene where he discovers through pain what the rest of the work teaches through doctrine.

Augustine examines his own grief with the same lucidity he brought to the theft: why did he love the wretched life he had more than he feared losing it, if he hated living? The answer he gives himself, citing someone who called his friend "half of the soul," is that friendship had fused two people into one, and so the other's death was, for him, a kind of half death. bene quidam dixit de amico suo: 'dimidium animae' suae (4.6.11), someone spoke well of his friend: "half of his soul."
Book IV: The Death of the Friend

In Book V, at twenty-nine years old, he waits nine years for Faustus of Milevis and finds him affable and without learning, but honest in his ignorance; the bond with the sect loosens. He leaves for Rome deceiving his mother, who prays at the port that he stay, falls ill with fever and does not ask for baptism, and goes on to Milan, where he hears Saint Ambrose first as a critic of oratory and then as one who receives the content together with the form. He leaves the Manichees and stays as a catechumen, waiting for something certain.

In Book VI, in Milan, Augustine already understands and does not yet want. The knots raised against Scripture come undone in Ambrose's sermons, and he admits that his whole life rests on believing what has not been seen. But he keeps chasing honor, money and marriage: his partner is taken from him to make room for the bride, and he finds another to wait two years, a slave to lust. In ch. 11, he sums up the hesitation by what it does to time:

Summing up the hesitation, he describes it by what it does to time. et differebam de die in diem vivere in te et non differebam cotidie in memet ipso mori. amans beatam vitam timebam illam in sede sua et ab ea fugiens quaerebam eam (6.11.20), and I kept postponing from day to day living in you, and I did not postpone dying in myself each day. Loving the happy life, I feared it in its own dwelling, and fleeing from it, I sought it.
Book VI: Ambrose, Alypius and Ambition

In Book VII, already in his thirties, he can only think of God as something corporeal, until Nebridius undoes the hostile mass of the Manichees and the books of the Platonists give him spiritual substance and evil as privation. He sees the immutable light with the eye of the soul and hears that God is he who is, but he cannot sustain the gaze: he lacked the Mediator, whom the Platonists do not have, and only in Paul does the truth he had come near appear with humility.

The same vision teaches what light is, and the answer comes from outside:

immo vero ego sum qui sum (7.10.16), no, rather, I am who I am.
Book VII: The Books of the Platonists

In Book VIII, intellectual doubt is over, and what is missing is a whole will. Simplicianus tells him of Victorinus's conversion, Ponticianus tells him of Antony's and that of the two agents of Trier, and Augustine sees himself as in a mirror, with the "not yet" of twelve years. In the garden, the two wills, the old and the new, tear him apart; under the fig tree he weeps, hears the voice that sings "take and read," opens Paul at Romans 13, and the light of certainty enters.

The new will, which wants to enjoy God for free, still lacks the strength to defeat the old one, and the struggle wounds. ita duae voluntates meae, una vetus, alia nova, illa carnalis, illa spiritalis, confligebant inter se atque discordando dissipabant animam meam (8.5.10), "so my two wills, one old and the other new, one carnal and the other spiritual, were fighting with each other, and in their discord they were tearing my soul apart."
Book VIII: The Conversion in the Garden

In Book IX, the struggle is over: it all came down to not wanting what he wanted and wanting what God wanted. He gives up the chair without scandal, withdraws to Cassiciacum, is baptized in Milan with Alypius and his son Adeodatus, and then comes Ostia, where mother and son touch eternal Wisdom for an instant, and Monica dies. The conviction makes him hold back his weeping, and conviction does not cure the pain; only alone, before God, does he let the tears run.

The book opens at the end of the struggle of Book VIII, and what the will learned fits in one sentence:

et hoc erat totum, nolle quod volebam et velle quod volebas (9.1.1), and this was all: not to want what I wanted, and to want what you wanted.
Book IX: Ostia and the Death of Monica

In Book X, the work changes its genre, and the narrator, now the man Augustine is and not the one he was, examines the instrument with which he told his life: memory. He seeks God in its fields and palaces and does not find him in any of its regions, but above them, and therefore present in it. It is then that the "late have I loved you" comes, with God within and he outside. The second half uses memory for an examination of conscience through the three concupiscences, and it ends in Christ, the only mediator.

Chapter 27 is the highest point of the whole work. sero te amavi, pulchritudo tam antiqua et tam nova, sero te amavi! et ecce intus eras et ego foris, et ibi te quaerebam, et in ista formosa quae fecisti deformis inruebam. mecum eras, et tecum non eram (10.27.38), late have I loved you, beauty so ancient and so new, late have I loved you! And behold, you were within and I was without, and there I sought you, and in those lovely things that you made I, deformed, rushed headlong. You were with me, and I was not with you.
Book X: Memory

In Book XI, back in Scripture, he asks of the first verse of Genesis what God was doing before creating the world. He answers that time is a creature and that there was no "before," and the question shifts from the world to the soul: past and future exist only as presents of memory and expectation, and time is a distension of the mind, which is measured by what things leave behind. The theory is also his own portrait after ten books of confession: a scattered life, which only the Mediator gathers.

What is measured is what remained. non ergo ipsas quae iam non sunt, sed aliquid in memoria mea metior, quod infixum manet (11.27.35), therefore I do not measure those things which now are not, but something in my memory, which remains fixed.
Book XI: Time

In Book XII, the Genesis continues, and he speaks of things that can be reached only by negation: the heaven of heaven, formless matter, what is not in time. The second half carries the humility he showed before these things into the act of reading: whoever disagrees with him about what Moses meant is not an enemy, and the truth both see belongs to no one. When someone asks him what Moses understood, he answers that he does not know.

Someone asks him what Moses understood, and the answer is the shortest in the book, given as a confession. si quis quaerit ex me quid horum Moyses, tuus ille famulus, senserit, non sunt hi sermones confessionum mearum si tibi non confiteor, 'nescio.' (12.30.41), if anyone asks me what of these things Moses, your servant, understood, these words would not be of my confessions if I did not confess to you, "I do not know."
Book XII: The Heaven of Heaven and the Readings of Genesis

In Book XIII, the last of the work, he reads creation as the story of the Church and of the soul, with the Trinity as an enigma in the soul itself, and the weight that carries each thing to its place, which is love. What has changed since Book I is the subject: at the start, the man who turns away and seeks; at the end, the reader who learns to see as God sees. The book ends without narration, with the request that one ask, seek and knock.

The physical image of the weight that carries each thing to its place serves as the grammar of love: what moves the soul is what it loves. pondus meum amor meus; eo feror, quocumque feror (13.9.10), my weight is my love; by it I am carried wherever I am carried.
Book XIII: Creation Read in the Church

Themes Embodied

Augustine passes through all the great themes of the work, because the whole work is him. It is Desire, which seeks rest in created things, from the games of childhood to the marriage that the career requires, and which in Book XIII is called weight. It is God and the divine, seen from the one who seeks him and from the one who was found, from the praise of Book I to the immutable light of Book VII. It is Sin read from within, in the theft without cause and in the habit that becomes necessity. It is Knowledge and wisdom, which goes from the Hortensius to the Platonists and discovers that knowing the way is not walking it. It is Friendship, which wounds him in Book IV and sustains him with Alypius and Nebridius. And it is Memory, the past and Time, which he examines in Books X and XI with the instrument he used to tell his life.

What moves Augustine at each stage is the question, more than the answer: the one the Hortensius kindles, the one the dead friend leaves, the one of where evil comes from. He knows, in writing, where his heart came to rest, and the book tells the journey with the end kept in view. For this reason the character has two voices that the text does not fuse: that of the one who did not know what troubled him, and that of the one who knows, and almost every scene is read by the second as if the first were being led along. There are two readings of what this does to the reader: the narrator sees design where at the time there was calculation of ambition, comfort and curiosity, or, already converted, recognizes in the order of events the remedy he needed. The text sustains both, and Augustine places the calculation of the hour beside providence.

Relationships

  • Monica: the mother, who weeps for him, follows him and waits for him, and whom he deceives when leaving for Rome; she dies in Ostia in Book IX.
  • Ambrose: the bishop of Milan, whose sermons reach him through their content and whose method of reading undoes the Manichean argument.
  • Alypius: the younger friend who accompanies him from Thagaste to Milan and is a witness to the garden; he mirrors and anticipates what Augustine cannot manage to be.
  • Nebridius: the friend who mocks divination and whose argument frees him from the hostile mass of the Manichees.
  • Faustus of Milevis: the Manichean bishop whom he waits nine years for and who, without meaning to, loosens the bond of the sect.
  • Adeodatus: the son, baptized with him in Milan.