Clavis Libri

Theme in Confessions

God and the Divine

God, the gods, and divine action: providence, theophany, intervention of the gods, the divine that acts in history.

The Theme in the Work

The Confessions are speech addressed to God from the first chapter to the last, and what the book says about him changes as the narrator learns to think him. In Book I, the question is whether one calls on him before knowing him, and the answer is the restless heart: man was made for God and does not rest until he rests in him. Augustine piles up attributes that contradict each other (unchanging yet changing all things, always acting and always at rest) and concludes that whoever speaks of him and whoever is silent both fail.

The next deviation is one of imagination. In Book III, he sought God through the sense of the flesh and not through the intellect, and only later understands that the one he sought was more inward than his innermost self (ch. 6). In Book V, he could only think in masses of bodies (ch. 10). In Book VI, he hears from the spiritual children of the Church that man is the image of God without God having the form of a body, and discovers that he had been barking against his own fictions and not against the faith (ch. 3).

In Book VII, the deviation comes undone. The books of the Platonists tell him to enter into himself, and he sees, above the mind, the unchanging light, which answers him that it is he who is (ch. 10). At the end of the book, the accounting is exact: the Platonists have the Word and do not have the Word made flesh.

In Book IX, at Ostia, Monica and her son touch eternal Wisdom for an instant at a window facing the garden and return to the noise of the mouth, and Monica tells her friends that nothing is far from God (ch. 11). In Book X, Augustine asks the world where God is and hears that the world was made by him, and finds God above memory, in the place where truth lets itself be seen. The book has its highest point in chapter 27, when God was within and he was outside.

The three final books make God the express subject. In Book XI, time is a creature and eternity is a today that does not give way to tomorrow. In Book XII, there are creatures outside time that contemplate without interval. In Book XIII, the Trinity appears in a riddle in creation and in the mirror of being, knowing and willing.

The God of the Confessions is ever more inward and ever less describable, and the book makes the reader pass through both. When Augustine imagines him as a body, he cannot think him. When he finds him, it is within and above, without image. The text supports two readings of what allows him to find him. In one, the way is reason guided by the Platonists, which leads him to the unchanging light. In the other, reason does not sustain what it sees, and the one who sustains it is the Mediator: in Book VII the vision withdraws, and it is Christ, humble with the humble, whom he did not yet have.

Where It Appears

  • Book I: Augustine opens the book with a praise that is already a question, and with the heart restless until it rests in God.
  • Book III: God sought through the sense of the flesh, when he was more inward than the innermost self, and the name of Christ missing from the Hortensius.
  • Book IV: Augustine hears the Word ask whether he is withdrawing somewhere and command him to fix his dwelling there.
  • Book V: Augustine, still a Manichaean, can only think God as a mass of bodies, and so cannot think an evil that is not a body.
  • Book VI: The Church dissolves the idea of a God of human form, and Augustine discovers that he had been barking against fictions.
  • Book VII: Augustine glimpses the unchanging light and the being who is, and names what the Platonists do not say: the Word made flesh.
  • Book IX: At Ostia the ecstasy of Augustine and Monica lasts a beat of the heart, and Monica later teaches that nothing is far from God.
  • Book X: Augustine hears the world answer that it was made by God, finds God where truth is seen and confesses that he loved him late.
  • Book XI: Augustine concludes that God's today is eternity, and that God creates through the Word, without prior matter or passing syllables.
  • Book XII: Augustine describes the creature that contemplates God without ceasing, and who therefore has no past to remember nor future to hope for.
  • Book XIII: Augustine sees the Trinity in a riddle and looks for it in his own soul, in being, knowing and willing.

Passages

The sentence that opens the work sets God as the end of restlessness.

The sentence that sums up the book, and by extension the work: Augustine, still at the beginning of the praise, gives the reason God stirs man to praise him, tu excitas ut laudare te delectet, quia fecisti nos ad te et inquietum est cor nostrum donec requiescat in te (1.1.1), you stir him to take delight in praising you, because you have made us for yourself and our heart is restless until it rests in you.
Book I: Infancy

The vision of Book VII comes with the answer God himself gives to what the light is.

The same vision teaches what the light is, and the answer comes from outside:

immo vero ego sum qui sum (7.10.16), on the contrary, I am who I am.
Book VII: The Books of the Platonists

The highest chapter of Book X says what the deviation had hidden.

Chapter 27 is the highest point of the whole work. sero te amavi, pulchritudo tam antiqua et tam nova, sero te amavi! et ecce intus eras et ego foris, et ibi te quaerebam, et in ista formosa quae fecisti deformis inruebam. mecum eras, et tecum non eram (10.27.38), late have I loved you, beauty so ancient and so new, late have I loved you! And behold, you were within, and I was outside, and there I sought you, and I rushed, deformed, upon the lovely things you have made. You were with me, and I was not with you.
Book X: Memory

At Ostia, God is touched for an instant and lost again.

Already a widow of Augustine's father and about to return to Africa, Monica stops with her son at Ostia, awaiting passage. At a window facing the inner garden, the two talk about what the eternal life of the saints would be, and the conversation rises, step by step, from matter to the silence of every creature, culminating in a glimpse that touches eternal Wisdom. et dum loquimur et inhiamus illi, attingimus eam modice toto ictu cordis. et suspiravimus et reliquimus ibi religatas primitias spiritus et remeavimus ad strepitum oris nostri, ubi verbum et incipitur et finitur (9.10.24), and while we speak and strain toward it, we touch it a little with the whole beat of the heart; and we sighed, and left there bound the first fruits of the spirit, and returned to the noise of our mouth, where a word both begins and ends.
Book IX: Ostia and the Death of Monica

Book XI sets eternity against time.

The contrast with time comes now: if God does not precede times within time, he precedes them on another plane. praecedis omnia praeterita celsitudine semper praesentis aeternitatis [...] anni tui dies unus, et dies tuus non cotidie sed hodie, quia hodiernus tuus non cedit crastino; neque enim succedit hesterno. hodiernus tuus aeternitas (11.13.16), you precede all things past by the height of an ever-present eternity [...] your years are one day, and your day is not every day but today, because your today does not give way to tomorrow, nor does it follow yesterday. Your today is eternity.
Book XI: Time

In Book XIII, what God is appears as a riddle, not as a definition.

Rereading the opening verse and the spirit that "moved over the waters," he sees the whole Trinity, but says that he sees it in a riddle. ecce apparet mihi in aenigmate trinitas quod es, deus meus (13.5.6), behold, the trinity that you are appears to me in a riddle, my God.
Book XIII: Creation Read in the Church