Who He Is
Faustus of Milevis is the Manichaean bishop whom Augustine waits for almost nine years as the answer to all the doubts the other adherents could not resolve. He appears in the Confessions in Book V, in Carthage, and what Books III and IV prepare is what the waiting presupposes: a sect that promises truth and does not give it. What Faustus wants, the book shows little: he is a pleasant bishop, who speaks better than the others and teaches the doctrine he knows. His role is that of a disappointment that does not break: when Augustine's questions find him without knowledge, he confesses his ignorance, and that is why the bond with the sect loosens without violence.
Trajectory
In Book III, what awaits him is already said: Augustine falls among the Manichees, who repeat "truth, truth" and have no truth at all.
Disappointed, he falls among the Manichees and describes the sect as an empty tray: the right name, without the content.et dicebant, 'veritas et veritas,' et multum eam dicebant mihi, et nusquam erat in eis, (3.6.10), and they kept saying "truth, truth," and spoke of it to me at length, and it was nowhere to be found among them.
Still in Book III, ch. 10, the sect leads him to believe that the fig weeps when it is picked. In Book IV, ch. 15, when the Manichaean years are summed up, Augustine says what lay at the bottom of the error: a pride he himself barely saw.
At the bottom of the Manichaean error there was a pride he himself barely saw.quid autem superbius quam ut adsererem mira dementia me id esse naturaliter quod tu es(4.15.26), what could be more arrogant than my asserting, with astonishing madness, that I am by nature what you are?
In Book V, chs. 3 to 7, the bishop arrives in Carthage, whom Augustine has waited for almost nine years, because the other Manichees, without answers to his objections about the stars, promised him that Faustus would resolve everything. From where he now writes, Augustine describes him as the devil's snare that entangled many through the sweetness of his speech.
At twenty-nine, after almost nine years among the Manichees, Augustine finally meets Faustus of Milevis, the Manichaean bishop whose arrival in Carthage was awaited as the answer to all the doubts the other adherents could not resolve.iam venerat Carthaginem quidam manichaeorum episcopus, Faustus nomine, magnus laqueus diaboli, et multi implicabantur in eo per inlecebram suaviloquentiae(5.3.3), a bishop of the Manichees named Faustus had already come to Carthage, a great snare of the devil, and many were entangled in him by the lure of sweet eloquence.
What Augustine had already checked before was the sky: the astronomers' calculations predicted eclipses, and Mani, who wrote about them abundantly, did not keep pace with them.
When Augustine sets the astronomers' calculations beside Mani's myths, the rule he applies is already that of the observer:
ibi autem credere iubebar, et ad illas rationes numeris et oculis meis exploratas non occurrebat, et longe diversum erat(5.3.6), there, however, I was ordered to believe; and it did not match those reasons I had checked by calculation and with my own eyes, and it was very different.
When Faustus arrives, he is pleasant and speaks better than the others, but Augustine is thirsty for substance and receives a handsome cup, and he had already learned that truth does not depend on whether it is spoken well or badly.
When the Manichee finally arrives, what Augustine feels is hunger before a handsome tray:
sed quid ad meam sitim pretiosorum poculorum decentissimus ministrator?(5.6.10), but what good is a most becoming server of precious cups to my thirst?
In ch. 7, when he puts his questions to Faustus, Augustine discovers that Faustus, beyond grammar and some readings of Cicero and Seneca, has no knowledge at all, but he does not pretend: he confesses his ignorance without shame, and this makes him dearer to Augustine than the knowledge he was seeking.
The encounter disappoints: the Manichaean bishop speaks pleasantly but ignores the sciences he should command to justify the doctrine, and admits his own ignorance instead of feigning knowledge, which paradoxically raises him in Augustine's eyes.pulchrior est enim temperantia confitentis animi quam illa quae nosse cupiebam(5.7.12), for the self-restraint of a confessing soul is indeed more beautiful than those things I was eager to know.
The text measures Faustus with care, and separates the religious deviation from the character.
Faustus is neither the master Augustine expected nor one of the chatterers he had already endured:
iste vero cor habebat, etsi non rectum ad te, nec tamen nimis incautum ad se ipsum(5.7.12), this man, indeed, had a heart, though not upright toward you, nor yet too unwary toward himself.
The result is not rupture but discouragement: the effort to advance in the sect ends, and Augustine is content to stay where he is until something better appears. Without wanting it or knowing it, Faustus loosened the bond that held him. In Book V, ch. 13, Faustus still serves as a point of comparison: on hearing Ambrose, Augustine still wants the style, which he compares with Faustus's, and already separates what the two taught.
Themes Embodied
Faustus passes through three themes of the work. He is Truth and Falsehood at its finest point: the sect promises knowledge and the bishop confesses he does not have it. He is Language and Narration seen through the side of eloquence without content, which does not satisfy the thirst of one who seeks substance. And he is Knowledge and Wisdom measured against humility: what Augustine finds worthy of esteem in Faustus is what he himself did not know how to seek.
Faustus of Milevis was a historical Manichaean bishop of the fourth century; years later, already a Catholic bishop, Augustine would write against him the treatise Contra Faustum Manichaeum, reusing the disappointment of his youth.
The text leaves two readings of what Augustine feels in face of Faustus. In the first, the sympathy is that of someone who finds honesty where he expected charlatanism; in the second, that of someone who, already distant from the sect, sees in Faustus what he wanted to find. In both, it is humility, not doctrine, that holds him a little longer, and the same man whom Augustine, writing now, calls the devil's snare is, in the account of what happened, the one who sets him free. What Faustus wants, the book does not ask: Augustine only says that he has a heart, though not upright toward God.