Manichaeism was the religion Augustine joined shortly after turning nineteen, in Carthage, and of which he was a member for about nine years. It promised reason without faith and gave evil an explanation he could understand: evil would be a substance, a mass opposed to God.
He came to the sect after reading Cicero's Hortensius, which kindled in him the desire for wisdom but did not bear the name of Christ, and after finding Scripture poor in style and unworthy of comparison with Cicero. The Manichees had the name of God and of Christ on their lips and repeated "truth, truth," but Augustine tells us that they served him the sun, the moon and shining phantoms in place of God (Book III, chs. 4 to 6). He kept asking where evil comes from, and did not yet know that evil is the privation of good (Book III, ch. 7). He even came to believe that the fig weeps when it is picked (Book III, ch. 10).
The way out was slow. In Book V, the Manichean bishop Faustus of Milevis, whom he had awaited for nearly nine years as one who would settle all his doubts, arrives in Carthage, speaks well but cannot answer, and confesses his ignorance without shame. Augustine does not break with the sect there, but loses his zeal to advance in it (Book V, chs. 3 to 7). In Milan, Ambrose's sermons untie the knots the Manichees had tied against Scripture (Book VI, ch. 3).
The decisive blow comes in Book VII. Nebridius had already shown that if the mass of evil could wound God, he would be corruptible, and if it could not, there would be no reason for the struggle (Book VII, ch. 2). After the books of the Platonists, which lead him to seek a truth without body, Augustine arrives, by his own reasoning, at the idea of an evil that is not a thing, but the deviation of a will that turns from the supreme being toward lower things (Book VII, chs. 12 to 16).