Clavis Libri

Questions · Confessions

What was Saint Augustine's sin in the Confessions?

There is not just one sin: the book shows several, and what links them is a movement, that of seeking in creatures the rest that only God gives. The most famous episode is small: at sixteen, he steals, with a gang of boys, pears he did not even want to eat and throws them to the pigs, and he spends Book II asking why he did it, until he concludes that he loved his own wrongdoing and that alone he would not have done it (Book II, chs. 4 to 9).

The others come along the story. In Carthage, he wants to love and be loved and lives for years with a companion without marriage (Book III, ch. 1; Book IV, ch. 2). From nineteen to twenty-eight, he says, he was seduced and seducing, deceived and deceiving (Book IV, ch. 1). In Milan, he longs for honors, gain and marriage (Book VI, ch. 6), and when his companion is sent back to Africa to make room for the bride, he takes another woman, because he cannot bear to wait the two years (Book VI, ch. 15).

The sin the book takes longest to overcome is postponement. Augustine tells that he asked God for chastity and continence, "but not yet" (Book VIII, ch. 7), and he decides only in the garden in Milan. Even after baptism, in Book X, he examines the three temptations that still hold him: the lust of the flesh, the lust of the eyes and worldly ambition (Book X, ch. 30 onward).

More questions about Confessions

See all questions