Clavis Libri

Theme in Confessions

Memory and the Past

Memory and the weight of the past: what is remembered, what is forgotten, nostalgia, the inheritance one did not choose, regret.

The Theme in the Work

In the Confessions, remembering is the gesture that makes the work exist and the subject that Book X examines to the bottom. In Book I, Augustine begins with what he does not remember: infancy and what came before it, and he reconstructs the baby from what he saw in others. In Book II, the purpose of the account is stated: to recall past foulness, not because he loves it, but to love God (ch. 1). Memory, here, is a means of conversion.

In Book IX, the last request of Monica is that they remember her at the altar, and Augustine extends it to the readers of the Confessions, who will make her a remembrance in prayer (ch. 13). The past becomes present through the one who recalls it.

In Book X, the theme fills the whole book. Augustine enters the fields and the palaces of memory (ch. 8), sees that memory is greater than the mind and that he does not grasp all that he is (ch. 8), and distinguishes what it keeps: images from the senses, the things learned themselves and the feelings, remembered without being felt (ch. 14). The paradox of forgetting makes him stumble: to remember forgetting requires that forgetting be there and that memory reach it at the same time (ch. 16). Then comes the problem of God, who cannot be found outside memory without being forgotten and cannot be found within it without being remembered (ch. 17).

In Book XI, memory becomes the measure of time: what is measured is what has remained in memory, not what has passed (ch. 27). The past exists only as the present of what has passed.

Memory in the Confessions does not keep the past as an archive; it keeps it as the possibility of returning to it without suffering it. Book X shows the gain: the confessor remembers joy and fear without feeling them, and for that reason he can narrate his own life. The text sustains two readings of the limit: either memory is the place where God is found, as chapter 24 says, or it is the place where only what was already known is found, and God stands above it, as chapter 26 says.

Where It Appears

  • Book I: Augustine begins with what he does not remember, infancy and the life before it, and confesses that he does not know where he came from.
  • Book II: Augustine states the purpose of the account: to recall past foulness not out of love for it, but to love God.
  • Book IX: Monica asks to be remembered at the altar, and Augustine extends the request to the readers.
  • Book X: Augustine walks through the palaces of memory, the feelings remembered without being felt and the paradox of forgetting, and seeks God beyond it.
  • Book XI: Augustine concludes that time is measured in memory and that the past is a present of the soul, which is remembrance.

Passages

The purpose that opens Book II states why one remembers.

He opens the book with its purpose:

recordari volo transactas foeditates meas et carnales corruptiones animae meae, non quod eas amem, sed ut amem te, deus meus (2.1.1), I want to recall the past foulness and the carnal corruptions of my soul, not because I love them, but so that I may love you, my God.
Book II: The Theft of the Pears

Memory is described as a place with extension and architecture.

Before examining memory, Augustine describes the act of entering it as one who climbs a staircase and arrives at a physical place, with its own extension and architecture. venio in campos et lata praetoria memoriae, ubi sunt thesauri innumerabilium imaginum de cuiuscemodi rebus sensis invectarum (10.8.12), I come into the fields and the wide halls of memory, where are the storehouses of innumerable images brought in from things of every kind perceived by the senses.
Book X: Memory

Memory is greater than the mind that possesses it.

Wonder grows to the most quoted formulation of the book: memory is greater than the mind that possesses it, and Augustine himself does not contain himself entirely. magna ista vis est memoriae, magna nimis, deus meus, penetrale amplum et infinitum. quis ad fundum eius pervenit? et vis est haec animi mei atque ad meam naturam pertinet, nec ego ipse capio totum quod sum (10.8.15), great is this power of memory, very great, my God, an ample and infinite sanctuary. Who has reached its bottom? Yet this power belongs to my mind and pertains to my nature, nor do I myself grasp the whole of what I am.
Book X: Memory

Past feelings are remembered without being felt.

For the affections of the soul, memory keeps a third category, distinct both from the sensible image and from the intelligible thing. nam et laetatum me fuisse reminiscor non laetus, et tristitiam meam praeteritam recordor non tristis, et me aliquando timuisse recolo sine timore et pristinae cupiditatis sine cupiditate sum memor (10.14.21), for I recall that I was glad without being glad, I remember my past sadness without being sad, I recollect that I once feared without fear, and I keep in mind a former desire without desire.
Book X: Memory

Forgetting is remembered, and the paradox stands.

cum vero memini oblivionem, et memoria praesto est et oblivio, memoria qua meminerim, oblivio quam meminerim (10.16.24), but when I remember forgetting, memory and forgetting are present at once: the memory by which I remember, and the forgetting that I remember.
Book X: Memory

What is sought in God runs into memory itself.

si praeter memoriam meam te invenio, immemor tui sum. et quomodo iam inveniam te, si memor non sum tui (10.17.26), if I find you outside my memory, I am forgetful of you. And how shall I find you, if I am not mindful of you?
Book X: Memory