Clavis Libri

Theme in Confessions

Time

The passage of time and what it does: duration, aging, eternity, time lived against the time of the clock.

The Theme in the Work

Time is the theme of Book XI, but it appears before and after as experience and as problem. In Book IV, in passing from grief to doctrine, Augustine says that things which are born and tend to be, the faster they grow, the faster they hurry not to be (ch. 10). In Book VI, he describes the hesitation by what it does to time: it postpones from day to day living in God, and does not postpone dying in itself each day (ch. 11). In Book VIII, the postponement has a voice of its own, "soon, soon" and "let me have just a little while," until the "tomorrow and tomorrow" arrives at the question of why not now (ch. 12).

In Book XI, the subject is posed as a question about God. The objection of whoever asks what he was doing before creating is received with its full force, and the answer refuses the joke: if time is a creature, there was no time before it (chs. 12 and 13). The contrast comes with eternity, the today that does not yield to tomorrow. Hence the most cited passage of the work, that time is known when no one asks and cannot be explained when asked, and the scandal of a present that is only while it tends not to be (ch. 14).

The book takes this difficulty to a place: there are not three times, there are three presents in the soul, memory, direct vision and expectation (ch. 20). What has remained in memory is measured (ch. 27), and time is a distension of the mind. Augustine's life is a distension, and he asks to be stretched out and not distended (ch. 29).

In Book XII and Book XIII, time is the background of the argument about creation. There are creatures without time that contemplate without any interval of change (12.12), and Scripture narrates in time what, in God's vision, has no time (13.29). The work closes on the seventh day, which has no evening: peace without vespers (13.35).

Time in the Confessions is first an experience of life and only afterward a problem of physics: the distension of Book XI is the name the work gives to what Book VI and Book VIII had already shown as postponement. The text sustains two readings of the time of the soul: either distension is the condition of created man, who gathers himself only in God, or it is the state of one who scatters and can still be stretched out. The sabbath without evening at the end gives weight to the second.

Where It Appears

  • Book IV: Augustine moves from grief to doctrine and observes that created things, the faster they grow to be, the more they hurry not to be.
  • Book VI: Augustine postpones from day to day living in God, and does not postpone dying in himself.
  • Book VIII: Augustine, under the fig tree in the garden, trades his "tomorrow and tomorrow" for the question of why not now.
  • Book XI: Augustine concludes that time is a creature, that eternity is a today, that time is measured in the mind and that life is distension.
  • Book XII: Augustine describes the heaven of heaven and formless matter, creatures that stand outside time because in them there is no change.
  • Book XIII: Augustine says that time does not reach the word of God, and the work ends in the peace of the sabbath without evening.

Passages

If time was made, the question of before loses its footing.

If time was made, there was no time before it was made, and the question loses its footing. si autem ante caelum et terram nullum erat tempus, cur quaeritur quid tunc faciebas? non enim erat tunc, ubi non erat tempus (11.13.15), but if there was no time at all before heaven and earth, why is it asked what you were doing then? For there was no "then" where there was no time.
Book XI: Time

The most cited passage of the book says what time does to whoever tries to explain it.

It is the most cited passage of the work: we speak of time all day long and understand one another, but no one explains it to whoever asks. si nemo ex me quaerat, scio; si quaerenti explicare velim, nescio (11.14.17), if no one asks me, I know; if I want to explain it to someone who asks, I do not know.
Book XI: Time

What seemed outside the soul exists only in it.

If past and future can only be as present, strictly speaking there are not three times, there are three presents in the soul. tempora sunt tria, praesens de praeteritis, praesens de praesentibus, praesens de futuris.' sunt enim haec in anima tria quaedam et alibi ea non video, praesens de praeteritis memoria, praesens de praesentibus contuitus, praesens de futuris expectatio (11.20.26), there are three times: a present of past things, a present of present things, a present of future things. For these three exist in the soul, and elsewhere I do not see them: the present of past things is memory, the present of present things is direct sight, and the present of future things is expectation.
Book XI: Time

The measure of time is made with what has remained in memory.

What is measured is what remained. non ergo ipsas quae iam non sunt, sed aliquid in memoria mea metior, quod infixum manet (11.27.35), therefore I do not measure those things which now are not, but something in my memory, which remains fixed.
Book XI: Time

Distension turns into personal confession.

Distension turns into personal confession and stands against another movement. ecce distentio est vita mea [...] non distentus sed extentus, non secundum distentionem sed secundum intentionem sequor (11.29.39), behold, my life is a distension [...] not distended but extended, not according to distension but according to intention I follow.
Book XI: Time

The work closes by asking for what creation promises, the rest without evening.

The whole work ends by asking for what creation promises at the end: the rest of the sabbath. pacem quietis, pacem sabbati, pacem sine vespera (13.35.50), peace of quiet, peace of the sabbath, peace without evening.
Book XIII: Creation Read in the Church