Clavis Libri

Utopia

Discussion Questions

Open questions that the book leaves behind, to bring to class, to a reading group, or to think over on your own.

Letter to Peter Giles: Thomas More to Peter Giles

More says he hardly wrote anything, that he only repeated what he heard. Why does an author pretend to be a mere reporter, and what does the book gain from it?

More worries about the width of a bridge and forgets to ask where the island is. What happens when we attend to the detail and let the essential slip away?

More says he prefers to "say a falsehood" than to "lie." What is the difference between erring without meaning to and deceiving on purpose, and when does a repeated oversight cease to be an oversight?

The theologian calls holy the ambition that is born of piety. How can we tell whether our own desire for office and recognition is of the kind we say it is?

More describes readers of various kinds, from cantankerous critics to the ungrateful guest. Why is it so much easier to criticize a work than to thank whoever made it?

Book I, section 1: The Traveler Raphael Hythloday

More opens the book with the embassy, the offices and the real names before arriving at a traveler whom no one can check. Why mix what exists with what is invented, and how does this make us believe?

More takes Hythloday for a ship's captain, and Peter says he sailed like Ulysses and like Plato. How often do we judge someone by his cloak before hearing what he has seen?

Hythloday leaves his inheritance to his brothers and stays in a distant fort because he prefers to see the world than to have a tomb. What does he gain and what does he lose with this choice?

The proof that the story is true is Peter's word, which repeats Hythloday's. Whom do we trust without checking, and what makes us trust?

Book I, section 2: Raphael's Travels

More leaves the monsters aside because what is hard to find are well-governed cities. What do we look for first in travels and in news: amazement or example?

Hythloday teaches the lodestone and the sailors begin to sail in winter, more sure of themselves than safe. When does a good invention come to serve badly for lack of preparation in those who receive it?

Peter proposes replacing "to serve" with "to render service," and Hythloday says that this is, by a syllable, more. Does changing the name change the thing? When do we accept a post because its name is lighter?

Hythloday says that princes want to conquer more than to govern well. Where do we see this today, and what happens to whoever counsels the opposite?

Hythloday tells that whoever hears an idea from outside answers "this pleased our ancestors." How often do we defend what already exists just so as not to admit that someone saw better?

Book I, section 3: At Cardinal Morton's Table

Hythloday says that the gallows is "too atrocious to avenge thefts and yet insufficient to restrain them." Why does punishing severely one who steals out of need solve so little, and what does a society fail to do when it knows only how to punish?

Hythloday attributes theft to the sheep, that is, to the wealth of a few that drives many off the land. When the profit of a few takes away the sustenance of many, whose fault is the theft that follows?

For the Polylerites, the anger of the law serves to "destroy vices while preserving men." When we punish someone, do we want the person to pay or to become able to live well again?

Everyone scorns Hythloday's idea and praises it when the cardinal repeats it. How often do we judge an idea by what it says, and how often by the authority of the one who says it?

Book I, section 4: The Philosopher and the Counsel of Kings

The council of the king of France discusses how to conquer Milan and Naples and no one asks whether it is worth it. How often do we plan the how without first asking the why?

Hythloday says that "the people choose a king for themselves, not for the king." What does a leader, of a country, a company or a household, owe to those who put him where he is?

Morus proposes playing well the part in the play on the boards, and Hythloday answers that this is complicity. When we try to improve from the inside an organization that errs, where does prudence end and complicity begin?

Hythloday says that preachers bent the doctrine of Christ to customs "like a leaden ruler." Which rules that we say we follow have we already bent until they fit into our lives?

For Hythloday, the root of evil lies in property and in money as the measure of everything; for Morus, without property no one works. Which of the two reasons seems stronger to you, and what does the book gain by leaving both standing?

Book II, section 1: The Island of Utopia

Utopus has his own soldiers dig the canal beside the vanquished, "so that they would not take the labor as an insult." What changes in hard work when everyone shares it, instead of its being imposed on a few?

The fifty-four cities are identical in language, customs, institutions and laws. What is gained and what is lost when everything is the same everywhere?

The Utopians "judge themselves rather its farmers than its lords." Who, in our own lives, behaves as owner of what he should only look after?

No one is obliged to stay more than two years in the country, but whoever likes the work may stay. Why does the freedom to leave, and to stay, matter so much in heavy work?

Book II, section 2: The Cities and Amaurot

Hythloday says that whoever knows one city knows them all. What does a visitor learn in a city identical to the others, and what does he fail to see?

The doors of Amaurot open with a light touch of the hand, and the houses change owners by lot every ten years. What would we gain and what would we lose if nothing at home were only ours?

Each street competes with the others for the most beautiful garden. When does rivalry between neighbors do good, and when does it begin to do harm?

Utopus lays out the city and leaves the finishing to those who will come. What work do we begin without expecting to see it finished?

Book II, section 3: The Magistrates

The prince is elected by secret ballot and governs until he dies, but loses office if there is suspicion of tyranny. Why does a power for a whole lifetime need an exit like this?

Deliberating on common affairs outside the senate is a capital crime, "so that it would not be easy" to oppress the people. What decisions that affect many people are made today far from the eyes of those who suffer them?

No matter is discussed on the day it is proposed. How often do we defend an opinion only because it was the first we said aloud?

The text speaks of a "twisted and perverse shame" that makes one prefer public error to admitting that one foresaw too little. When does the fear of seeming to have erred make us err more?

Book II, section 4: The Trades

On the island, everyone learns farming and one more trade, and whoever wishes may change trades. What changes in a society in which no one is only one thing for his whole life?

The Utopians work six hours, and the rest of the day is "at each person's discretion," but "not so that he may abuse it in luxury or softness." What do we do with free time when we have it to spare?

Hythloday says that, where everything is measured by money, many people work at things "empty and superfluous." How much of our work serves luxury, and not necessity?

On the island, one garment for two years suffices, because more clothing would not make anyone "better dressed, not by a hair." What do we buy to seem, and not to use?

The aim of the republic is to give everyone the maximum time "free from the servitude of the body." What is free time for, in your life?

Book II, section 5: The Citizens' Common Life

Hythloday says that what makes a person "greedy and rapacious" is the fear of want and pride. At what moments in your life do you gather or hoard out of fear, and at which out of a wish to be seen?

Any father of a household takes from the storehouses what he needs, because no one fears that he will go without. What conditions would a society need for "asking only for what is necessary" to come naturally?

The Utopians do not let their citizens grow accustomed to butchering animals, so that clemency may not die. On what small habits does our capacity for pity depend?

At meals, old and young sit mixed together, and the old share the best portions with those around them. What is learned at a table where the ages mingle?

The dirty work of the banquet is done by slaves, and the section passes over it in a single line. What does the cleanliness of a good common life hide, and who pays the price for it?

Book II, section 6: The Utopians' Travels

The Utopian sets out with nothing and "everywhere is at home," because his trade and the sameness of the cities go with him. On what does a free journey depend on money, and on what does it depend on our being well received?

Whoever leaves without leave is "brought back as a fugitive," and on a repeat offense is enslaved. Where does the order of a city end and the surveillance of those who live in it begin?

Even someone strolling through the fields works before eating. What does this rule say about what the Utopians think of idleness?

Hythloday tells that "the eyes of all" are fixed upon each person, with no tavern or hiding place. What is lost in a life with no place where one is not seen?

Book II, section 7: Shared Abundance and the Contempt for Gold

On the island, the senate merely reckons what is left over and what is lacking, and the cities share free of charge. Why, in Hythloday's argument, does poverty disappear when no one needs to hoard for himself?

Gold ends up in chamber pots and in slaves' chains so that no one grows attached to it. Why does this work better than locking it in a tower, and what would the reader of 1516 expect to hear instead?

The ambassadors dress in gold to be admired and are taken for slaves. When you choose a garment or an object, who do you choose it for?

A man of lead has wise men as slaves because of coins. How often do we give someone an honor for what he has that we would not give for who he is?

Book II, section 8: Education, Studies and Pleasure

The Utopians never discuss happiness without adding religion, because without the immortal soul and the rewards after death reason would lead to seeking pleasure by any means. If you believed that nothing comes after death, what would change in your idea of acting well?

The same nature that commands a joyful life commands helping others to have it. Why does Hythloday think that whoever helps another does not lose pleasure but gains it?

Hythloday calls false the pleasure of the fine toga, of nobility and of the stone. Which of your pleasures depends on someone's seeing it, and would continue if no one saw?

For the Utopians, to be without pain but without health is stupor, not pleasure. What does this idea change in the way we understand what a good life is?

Hythloday says that he narrates and does not defend. Why does More, the author, put this reservation in Hythloday's mouth and leave open whether he approves or not of the Utopians?

Book II, section 9: The Laws of the Utopians

The Utopians think the condemned man more useful through labor than through death, and leave hope if he shows repentance. What does this reasoning say about what they expect from a punishment?

The Utopians show the betrothed naked to each other and think it more stupid to choose a wife by seeing only the face. What does the scene show about the care they take in choosing the person one will have for a whole life?

Hythloday says that the easy hope of new marriages does not strengthen the affection of spouses. When does making it easier to leave weaken a commitment, and when does it not?

For the Utopians, the simplest reading of the law is the most just. What happens to a law that only a specialist can understand?

The Utopians say that no one is an enemy unless he has offended, and for this reason they make no treaties. Why does Hythloday think the treaty teaches neighboring peoples to think themselves enemies?

Book II, section 10: War

The Utopians say they abhor war and yet they train, men and women, on set days. When does the preparation for war stop being defense and become custom?

Paying for the head of the enemy prince spares, they say, the lives of many innocents. Why does a humane argument serve so well to justify a means we would condemn in others?

The Utopians pay the Zapoletes very well and do not mind if they die. Who does, in our own life, the dirty work we prefer not to do, and what do we say about it to keep our peace?

They glory in winning by wit, as no animal can. How often do we call intelligence what is only cleverness to avoid bearing the cost of what we do?

Book II, section 11: The Religions of the Utopians

The Utopians accept all religions, but not that of one who denies the immortal soul. Why does a tolerant society need a point that is not open to discussion, and who decides what it is?

Utopus thinks it "insolent and foolish" to demand that others see as true what I see. In what situations of life do we do this without noticing?

The convert was exiled for causing tumult and not for believing. Where does the line fall between defending one's own faith and attacking that of others?

Whoever dies cheerful is celebrated and whoever dies afraid is buried in silence. What does the way someone dies say about how he lived?

In the prayer, each Utopian asks that god correct him if he is wrong. When was the last time you prayed, or asked someone, to show you where you were mistaken?

Book II, section 12: The Praise of the Republic and More's Reply

Hythloday says that, in other nations, everyone talks about the public good and looks after the private one. In what situations in our own lives do we do the same, or say we do the opposite?

He calls a "conspiracy of the rich" laws that decree in the name of the public what serves the rich. How can we tell whether a rule is for the common good or only for the interest of whoever wrote it?

For Hythloday, pride measures prosperity by the disadvantages of others. When do we feel well in life only if the other is worse off?

The narrator has objections and swallows them so as not to seem to nitpick at other people's ideas. When is keeping silent before an idea courtesy, and when is it flight?

More ends by saying that there are things in Utopia that he would "wish" to see in our cities but would not "expect." What difference is there between wishing for a society and expecting it?

The Whole Work

If the one who describes Utopia is Hythloday, the "teller of nonsense," and the one who writes is More, how much of what we read is proposal and how much is game?

The island has no money, but it keeps gold for war and buys with it the death of princes. Does this undo the argument against money, or make it more honest?

Hythloday refuses to serve a king because he would not be heard, and Morus says that one should at least do the lesser evil. Who is right, and does the book give any sign?

The Utopians tolerate all religions and despise whoever denies the immortal soul. Where does the line fall between toleration and control?

More falls silent at the end, says that he does not assent to everything and that he would wish for much of what he heard. What does an author gain by dividing the book between two voices that do not resolve?