Clavis Libri

Utopia · Book II · Section 5

The Citizens' Common Life

Chapter summary

Book II, Section 5 of 12. Before: Book II, Section 4: The Trades. After: Book II, Section 6: The Utopians' Travels.

Raphael Hythloday explains how the citizens live together and how goods are distributed. The city is made up of families, generally formed of relatives. Women, on marrying, pass into the husband's house, and the male children and grandchildren stay in the house and obey the eldest. Each family has from ten to sixteen people past puberty, and each city has six thousand families. When there are too many people in a house, some are moved to smaller ones, and, if the whole island overflows, the citizens found a colony on the nearest continent, on land that the natives leave uncultivated, and accept the natives who wish to live with them. Whoever refuses the laws is expelled, and whoever resists is fought, because the Utopians judge it a most just cause of war when a people holds empty land and denies its use to those who need it. Only twice, because of plague, has a city been so depleted that it was repopulated with people from the colony, and they would rather let the colony die than see a city of the island diminish.

The city is divided into four equal parts, each with a market square. To these go the products of each family's labor, stored in warehouses by kind, and any head of household takes without money what he and his family need. Why would they deny him anything, if there is plenty of everything and no one fears want? What makes animals greedy is the fear of lacking; in man, only pride, which finds glory in surpassing others by the display of the superfluous. Outside the city are the food markets, where running water washes away the putrid fluid and the filth, and where servants slaughter and clean the animals, because the Utopians do not let citizens grow accustomed to butchering them, so as not to kill clemency in them. Each district has ample halls, where the syphogrants live, and to each hall thirty families are assigned, fifteen on each side, who take their meals there. The stewards of the halls go to the market to ask for the food.

The first consideration is for the sick, treated in four public hospitals, outside the walls, so spacious that they look like small towns, well supplied with physicians and with everything that heals, so that almost every sick person prefers to stay there than at home. After the sick, the food is divided among the halls, in equal shares, with due consideration for the prince, the high priest, the tranibors, the ambassadors and foreigners. The whole syphogranty assembles at the sound of a brazen trumpet, and no one is prevented from asking for food to take home, but few do, because the hall has a lavish banquet. The dirtiest services are left to the slaves, and the women, by turns, cook and organize the banquet.

They sit at three tables or more. The men sit by the wall and the women on the outside, so that they can leave without disturbing the others, if they feel unwell, and go to the nurses, who stay apart with the infants, in a room with a fireplace, clean water and cradles. Each woman is nurse to her own children, unless death or illness prevents it, and then a nurse is found without difficulty. Children up to five years stay in the "nurses' grotto"; the older ones serve at table or stand in silence, and eat what those seated hand them. At the highest table sits the syphogrant with his wife and two elders; if there is a temple, the priest and his wife. Young and old are seated alternately, so that the old may restrain the license of the young, since nothing at table escapes the neighbors. To the old the best is served first, and they share it with those around them, so that everyone receives the same advantage.

Every meal begins with a brief reading that serves morals. Afterward, the old converse, without sadness and without tedium, and provoke the young, to test their character and wit. Lunches are brief, and dinners fuller, with music, dessert, perfumes and ointments, for they judge that no pleasure from which no discomfort results is forbidden. In the country, those who live far away eat each in his own house, because nothing is lacking to them, since everything the city eats comes from there.

Analysis

The title. "On Mutual Commerce": the word "commerce" has here the old sense of dealings between people, and not of buying and selling. It is the opposite, in fact: the section shows how people live together who buy and sell nothing among themselves.

What More shows here, through Hythloday's mouth, is a city that has taken the fear of lacking out of life: everything goes to common storehouses, each person takes what he needs, and all eat together, the sick come first, the old have the honor and the young are tested. For Hythloday greed is born of fear and pride, and where the two vanish, no one hoards.

Unlock with a subscription

Subscription

The complete analysis of every chapter of Utopia comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.

See the plansAlready subscribed? Sign in

Questions on this chapter

To discuss

5 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.

Test your reading

8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz