Chapter summary
Book II, Section 4 of 12. Before: Book II, Section 3: The Magistrates. After: Book II, Section 5: The Citizens' Common Life.
Raphael Hythloday begins with work. There is one art common to all, men and women, agriculture, taught from childhood at school and in the fields near the city. Besides it, each person learns a trade: wool-working, linen, masonry, smithing or carpentry, for there are almost no others that employ people. Women generally handle wool and linen, which are lighter, and men the more painful arts. Most follow their father's trade, but whoever feels drawn to another is moved by adoption to a family of that trade, and whoever wants to learn a second may, and practices whichever he wishes, unless the city needs one of them more. Clothing has a single form throughout the island, and distinguishes only sex and the state of being married or single; each family makes it for itself.
The syphogrants' chief duty is to see that no one is idle and no one is worn out like a beast of burden, which Hythloday calls an affliction worse than slavery and the common life of artisans almost everywhere. The Utopians divide the day, counting the night, into twenty-four equal hours and work six: three before noon, after lunch two hours of rest, and three more of work, until supper. They sleep eight hours. The rest of the time belongs to each person, provided it is not spent on luxury or softness. Most give it to learning, in the public lectures before dawn, which many people of all orders attend, and whoever prefers to spend it on his trade, as many do, is not forbidden, and is even praised. After supper, an hour of games and music, in the garden or in the hall: there are no dice, but there is the battle of numbers and a game in which the vices fight the virtues.
Hythloday asks that the listener not be mistaken: six hours suffice, and more than suffice. It is enough to think how many people in other nations live without producing: nearly all the women, or, where they work, the men standing idle; the multitude of priests and religious; the rich, above all the landlords, with their armed retinues; the sturdy beggars who feign illness. And, among those who work, many are busy with empty arts, servants only of luxury, because everything is measured by money. If all those people were put to useful work, little time would be enough.
In Utopia, in the whole city and its surroundings, only some five hundred have an exemption. The syphogrants are entitled to it, but do not use it, to set an example. Those chosen by the people, on the priests' advice, for study also enjoy it, and whoever disappoints goes back to his trade, while an artisan who studies in his free hours may be promoted to the class of scholars. From this class come the ambassadors, the priests, the tranibors and the prince himself, called Barzanes in the old language and Ademus in the more recent. To this are added conveniences: houses last, because repairs are made before ruin and no one builds on a whim, and clothing is of leather or hide, which lasts seven years, with a cloak of natural color over it and a single garment for two years. With all this, sometimes the city sends many people to repair roads, and often announces fewer hours of work. The aim of the republic is to give everyone the maximum free time from the servitude of the body for the liberty and cultivation of the mind, for in this they judge the happiness of life to consist.
Analysis
The title. "On the Trades": the subject is who does what and for how long, and the surprise comes at once, in the number six. Nothing in this section is about luxury or power: it is about the hour of the day, which is the most ordinary and most demanding thing in the life of anyone who works.
What More shows here, through Hythloday's mouth, is that abundance does not require a long working day: it requires that everyone work and that no one produce what is not useful. With everyone in useful work, six hours suffice, and the time left over is for study, conversation and rest. The central idea is that free time is the end of work, and not a prize for those who do not work.
Subscription
The complete analysis of every chapter of Utopia comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.
Questions on this chapter
To discuss
5 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.
Test your reading
8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz