Chapter summary
Book I, Section 3 of 4. Before: Book I, Section 2: Raphael's Travels. After: Book I, Section 4: The Philosopher and the Counsel of Kings.
Hythloday tells More and Peter Giles of a dinner at the house of Cardinal John Morton, Archbishop of Canterbury and chancellor of England, in whose house More was raised. The "I" of this section is Hythloday, not the narrator of the book. He begins with a portrait of the host: a man who was respected without being feared, expert in laws, of prodigious memory, who liked to put petitioners to the test to see each one's presence of mind.
At table, a lay lawyer praises the justice that hangs thieves, as many as twenty on a single gibbet, and wonders that so many are left. Hythloday answers that the penalty is too cruel and does not solve anything: theft does not deserve death, and no punishment keeps from robbing a man who has no other means of living. He points to the causes. There are the maimed soldiers, with no trade. There are the idle nobles, who live like drones off the labor of their tenants and drag along bands of servants who, dismissed when the lord dies or falls ill, know only how to steal. The cardinal says that such people are useful for war; Hythloday answers that France, full of mercenaries, shows the danger of raising such beasts.
The most proper cause in England is the sheep. Where the wool is finest, nobles, gentlemen and even abbots enclose the land for pasture, tear down houses and drive out the tenants, who sell everything for almost nothing, steal, beg or are jailed as vagrants. Without farming, jobs vanish and the prices of wool and cattle rise, because the sale is in the hands of a few rich men. The remedy is to give back the farms, restrain the engrossers and rebuild farming and the wool trade. Otherwise, justice manufactures thieves in order to punish them.
The lawyer prepares to answer in the manner of the schools, but the cardinal cuts him off and asks Hythloday for the alternative. He maintains that to take a life for money is iniquitous, that God forbade killing, that the law of Moses punished theft with restitution and that punishing the thief and the murderer alike pushes the thief to kill the witness. He proposes the Polylerites, a people of Persia: the thief returns to the owner what he took, works on public projects, wears a single color, has his ear cut and hopes to be freed if he reforms.
The lawyer says this would put the republic in danger, and everyone goes over to his side. The cardinal suggests trying it, postponing the execution, and extends the idea to vagabonds. Suddenly everyone praises what they had scorned. A parasite, who plays the buffoon, proposes sending the beggars to the monasteries; a friar theologian takes offense, the parasite retorts that friars are the greatest vagrants, and the cardinal steers the conversation away.
Analysis
The title. "At Cardinal Morton's Table": the scene is a dinner, and the first theme of the book, the death penalty for the thief, is born in a table conversation, among a lawyer, a friar and a buffoon, without the tone of a treatise. The host is a real figure, and the table is the book's first stage: who speaks, and who agrees only after the master of the house agrees, matters as much as what is said.
What More shows here, through Hythloday's mouth, is that theft is largely manufactured by the kingdom itself: wars that leave cripples, nobles who dismiss servants, owners who trade farmers for sheep. The death penalty punishes the effect and leaves the cause standing. And the lawyer and the guests begin to listen only when the idea comes out of the cardinal's mouth.
Subscription
The complete analysis of every chapter of Utopia comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.
Questions on this chapter
To discuss
4 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.
Test your reading
8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz