Chapter summary
Book II, Section 1 of 12. Before: Book I, Section 4: The Philosopher and the Counsel of Kings. After: Book II, Section 2: The Cities and Amaurot.
Book II opens with the discourse of Raphael Hythloday on the best condition of the republic, and it begins with the place. The island of the Utopians is two hundred miles across at its widest and has the shape of a waxing moon, with an arm of the sea between its two horns. This inner sea, calm as a lake, makes almost the whole island a harbor. The entrance is dangerous: shoals on one side, rocks on the other, and only the Utopians themselves know the channels, guided by signs set on the coast. If the signs were moved, an enemy fleet would be lost. On the other coasts landing is so difficult that a few defenders hold off a large army.
According to tradition, the land was not always an island, and was formerly called Abraxa. The victor Utopus, who gave the island his name, landed, conquered at once, brought a rude people to a high degree of culture and had fifteen miles dug at the point where the land joined the continent, so that the sea would surround it. He put the natives to digging, and his soldiers as well, so that the labor would not seem an insult, and the work was finished with incredible speed. The neighbors, who had laughed at the idea, were amazed and afraid.
The island has fifty-four cities, identical in language, customs, institutions and laws, and identical in appearance, as far as the terrain allows. The nearest to another is twenty-four miles away, and from any one it is a day's walk to another. Every year, each city sends three elders to Amaurot to deal with common affairs, because the city is in the middle of the island and is the principal one. Each city has at least twelve miles of countryside around it, and none wants to enlarge its boundaries, since its inhabitants judge themselves farmers of the land, and not lords.
In the countryside there are houses with tools, inhabited in turns. Each rustic family has at least forty people, plus two bound slaves, and a father and a mother of the household, grave and mature, govern it; for every thirty families there is a phylarch. Every year twenty people from each house return to the city, after two years in the country, and as many come from the city to learn from those who have already spent a year there. The rotation ensures that no one is forced into a harsh life for long, and whoever likes the work may stay longer.
The farmers plow, raise animals and bring firewood to the city. They hatch chicks in constant warmth, without the hens, and the chicks follow people as if they were their mothers. They raise few horses, only to exercise the young, and use oxen for all work, because they are more patient, healthier and cheaper to keep, and after service they serve as food. Of grain they use only bread; they drink wine made from grapes, apples or pears, or water, or water boiled with honey or licorice. They sow and raise cattle beyond what the city consumes, to share the rest with the neighbors. What is lacking in the country they ask of the city magistrates without exchange, and at harvest time the phylarchs announce how many reapers they need, and the harvest is done almost in a single day of clear sky.
Analysis
The title. "On the Island of the Utopians": the book now ceases to be conversation and becomes description, and the first subject is the place. The island is described before the people, and that matters: everything Hythloday will tell afterward (the defense, the equality, the work) has its ground here.
What More shows here, through Hythloday's mouth, is an island made by design, and not by chance: a conqueror who cuts the isthmus to isolate the territory and cities all alike, with no desire to grow, in which working the land is a duty of everyone, by turns, and not the lot of a few. Order appears first in the land and in the work of drawing from it; only afterward will come laws and customs.
Subscription
The complete analysis of every chapter of Utopia comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.
Questions on this chapter
To discuss
4 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.
Test your reading
8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz