Chapter summary
Book II, section 11 of 12. Before: Book II, section 10: War. After: Book II, section 12: The Praise of the Republic and More's Reply.
Raphael Hythloday describes the religion of the Utopians, which is plural. Some worship the Sun, the Moon or a star, others a man of ancient virtue. The majority, and the most prudent, believe in a single power, eternal and inexplicable. And all agree on one supreme being, to whom the universe and providence are owed, whom they call in common Mithras, though each imagines him in his own way. Little by little they tend toward the religion that seems the most rational.
When travelers told them of Christ, of the miracles and the martyrs, many joined and were baptized, through divine inspiration, through affinity with their own strongest belief, or, Hythloday supposes, because they heard that Christ approved of life in common. They lack Christian priests, and they discuss whether they may elect one on their own. A newly baptized man of the group was exiled for preaching that all other religions deserved eternal fire: not for his religion, but for the tumult among the people.
Toleration comes from Utopus, the founder. The earlier inhabitants fought wars over religion, and he established that each person may follow the one he likes and try to persuade others only with reasons, without violence or insult; whoever disputes with petulance is exiled or enslaved. He judged that peace and religion itself gain if the question is left open. The only prohibition is to think that the soul dies with the body or that the world goes by chance. Whoever thinks so is despised, without honor or office, and may not argue before the people, but is not punished or forced to pretend: he may argue with priests and grave men.
The customs follow. Whoever dies cheerful is celebrated with songs, whoever dies afraid is buried in silence, and the dead are believed to walk among the living. They laugh at auguries and revere miracles. Some, out of religion, forgo studies and take on the hardest labors. There are two sects, those who do not marry and those who do, the latter held to be more holy and more prudent. The priests are thirteen per city, elected by secret ballot, with no power beyond honor, and they may be widowed women; in battle, they pray for peace and restrain the slaughter. The temples are dark and without images, only Mithras is invoked and no animals are sacrificed. In the common prayer, each gives thanks to have fallen into the best republic and the truest religion, and asks that god correct him if he errs, unless god delights in this variety.
Analysis
The title. "Of Religions" is in the plural, and that is what matters: before saying what the Utopians believe, Hythloday says that they believe different things, and that almost all agree on a single point. The section is the opposite of a catechism: it is the description of how a people lives with beliefs that are not its own.
What More shows here is a republic that lets each person believe what he likes, provided no one attacks another's belief and all admit a god and a life after death. The reason is Utopus's: religion imposed by force produces war and smothers the best religion, while the one defended with reason can win by itself. But the text also shows the limit of this freedom: whoever denies the immortal soul is despised and excluded from every office. Hythloday tells everything with admiration, and the text does not say whether More agrees.
Subscription
The complete analysis of every chapter of Utopia comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.
Questions on this chapter
To discuss
5 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.
Test your reading
8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz