Clavis Libri

Utopia · Book II · Section 8

Education, Studies and Pleasure

Chapter summary

Book II, section 8 of 12. Before: Book II, section 7: Shared Abundance and the Contempt for Gold. After: Book II, section 9: The Laws of the Utopians.

Raphael Hythloday explains where the Utopians' opinions about gold and nobility come from: from an education in a republic without these vices, and from letters. Few are exempted from labor to study full time, those of notable talent, but all the children learn, and many people, men and women, spend their free hours on letters. They study in their own language. They did not know the European philosophers, and they arrived at almost the same discoveries in music, dialectic, arithmetic and geometry; they fall behind the modern logicians, who do not know the rules of the Parva Logicalia or "man in general." They are skilled in the stars and in instruments, and do not believe in astrology.

In moral philosophy they discuss what is discussed among us: goods of the soul, of the body and external goods, virtue and pleasure, and in what happiness consists. They lean, more than is just, toward the party of pleasure, but they never discuss happiness without joining to reason principles drawn from religion: that the soul is immortal and born for happiness, and that there are rewards and punishments after this life. Without them, they say, who would not seek pleasure at any cost? They define virtue as living according to nature, and nature commands us to have a joyful life and to help others to have it; whoever deprives himself fruitlessly, for himself or for another, commits the greatest of follies.

They distinguish true pleasure from false. False are those of the finer toga, of honor, of inherited nobility, of gems, of hidden treasure, of dice and of hunting, which they leave to the butchers, that is, to the slaves. True are those of the soul (knowledge, the memory of a life well lived, hope) and those of the body, of two kinds: that which fills a lack (eating, drinking) and that of equilibrium, health, which they place higher, since eating and drinking serve only it. Hythloday closes by saying that he narrates and does not defend, but that he knows no happier republic.

The portrait of the people continues: agile bodies, well-tended land, woods replanted near the sea, a spirited people, tireless in their studies. When the Europeans brought them Greek letters, they learned them in less than three years. Hythloday brought Plato, Aristotle, Theophrastus (torn up by a monkey), Lascaris, Plutarch, Lucian, the poets and the historians, and a companion brought Hippocrates and Galen. From what they were shown of Aldus's books, they invented paper and printing. They welcome whoever brings knowledge from other lands, but trade little: they would take only iron, gold or silver.

Analysis

The title. "Of Education and the Arts": it begins with schools and the arts, and most of the passage is about pleasure. The reason is in the first sentence: education is the cause of the Utopians' thinking of gold and nobility as they do. The section explains the contempt for gold of the previous one through the people's minds, not only through the laws.

What More shows here, through Hythloday's mouth, is a philosophy of pleasure that presents itself with brakes: the end of life is pleasure, but true pleasure is the honest kind, almost always calm, tied to health, to the soul and to the good of others, and reason reaches this only if accompanied by religious beliefs. The text carefully separates what the Utopians defend from what Hythloday is willing to defend.

Unlock with a subscription

Subscription

The complete analysis of every chapter of Utopia comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.

See the plansAlready subscribed? Sign in

Questions on this chapter

To discuss

5 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.

Test your reading

8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz