Chapter summary
Book I, Section 1 of 4. Before: Letter to Peter Giles: Thomas More to Peter Giles. After: Book I, Section 2: Raphael's Travels.
More opens the book with the title and with his own introduction: he is a citizen and under-sheriff of London and was sent by Henry VIII, king of England, to Flanders, to settle disputes with the prince of Castile, Charles. He travels beside Cuthbert Tunstall, to whom the king had just given an important post, and he does not praise him further because it would be, he says, to show the sun with a lantern. In Bruges they meet the prince's envoys, among them the burgomaster of the city and George Temsice, provost of Cassel, a good orator and a good jurist. As they do not agree on certain points, the Flemings leave for Brussels to consult the prince, and More goes to Antwerp. There, Peter Giles, a learned young man, loyal and good company, visits him often and eases his homesickness, since More had already been away for more than four months. One day, as they leave the service at the church of Our Lady, Peter is talking with a man of advanced age, sunburned face, long beard and a cloak hanging from his shoulder, whom More takes for a ship's captain. Peter corrects him: he sailed like Ulysses and like Plato, not like Palinurus, Aeneas's pilot. He is Raphael Hythloday, a Portuguese, very learned in Greek and little in Latin, of which he knows only something of Seneca and Cicero. He left his inheritance to his brothers, joined Amerigo Vespucci on the last three of the four voyages that are already read everywhere and, on the last, obtained leave to stay at the fort, among the 24 who were left there, more eager to wander than to have a grave. After Vespucci left, he traveled through many regions with five Castilian companions, reached Taprobane and Calicut and, by luck, found Portuguese ships that took him back to his homeland.
Analysis
The title. "The Man on a Journey": instead of presenting a book or a thesis, the section presents a man on the road, and it is through him that the book will reach Utopia. Almost everything that comes afterward is said by this traveler, and so who he is, and who vouches for him, matters more than any piece of information in the section.
What More shows here is how an island that does not exist is prepared: with an embassy, offices and names of people who existed, a real church and a traveler who went about with Vespucci. Hythloday is presented as a man of philosophy who gave up his inheritance to see the world, and it is a friend, Peter, who vouches for him. The truth of the account rests on the word of a friend who trusts the traveler, and this traveler is called Hythloday.
Subscription
The complete analysis of every chapter of Utopia comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.
Questions on this chapter
To discuss
4 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.
Test your reading
8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz