Chapter summary
Book I, Section 2 of 4. Before: Book I, Section 1: The Traveler Raphael Hythloday. After: Book I, Section 3: At Cardinal Morton's Table.
After the greetings, More takes Raphael Hythloday home and, seated on a turf bench in the garden, they listen to him tell what he lived through. After Vespucci left, Hythloday and the companions in the fort gradually approached the peoples of the land until they were befriended by a prince, who gave them provisions and a guide to take them to other princes, by water on rafts and by land in carts. In many days of travel they found cities and well-instituted republics. Near the equator the heat scorches everything and only beasts, serpents and men as wild as they live; farther on the climate grows gentler, peoples and trade by land and sea appear, and the ships of Hythloday and his companions were accepted on all voyages. The boats of the first places had flat keels and sails of papyrus, wicker or leather, and later, pointed keels and sails of hemp. Hythloday won the sailors' gratitude by teaching them the lodestone, which they did not know; they sailed only in summer and now despise winter, more sure of themselves than safe, and More fears that what seemed a great good may become, through imprudence, the cause of great evils. More says he will not report everything and that he has left the monsters aside, because they are nothing new: what is hard to find are well-governed cities. Hythloday pointed out errors here and there, and More announces that he will tell only what he said about the Utopians, after the conversation that led to them. Peter, amazed, asks why Hythloday does not join some king: with what he knows, he would please, instruct and counsel, and look after his own as well. Hythloday answers that he has already shared his goods with relatives and friends, and that he will not hand himself over to servitude to kings. Peter proposes another word, not to serve, but to render service, and Hythloday answers that this is, by a syllable, more than serving. He insists that he lives as he pleases, and that the powerful will not lose much without him. Then More himself, called Morus, argues that a man like him ought to put his learning at the service of public affairs, because from the prince a torrent of goods and evils flows over the people. Hythloday answers that he is wrong twice over. Princes are busier with war and the conquest of new kingdoms than with governing well those they already have; counselors either know so much that they do not need counsel, or think they know and do not approve that of others; they agree only with the absurdities of whoever is in favor with the prince, out of flattery. If someone proposes something he has read or seen elsewhere, those who listen act as if their reputation for wisdom were at stake, and take refuge in "this pleased our ancestors." Hythloday says he has already run up against these proud judgments in other countries and in England, where he was a few months after the disaster in which the civil war of the western English against the king was put down with a wretched massacre.
Analysis
The title. "Raphael's Travels": the section begins as a travel narrative and becomes, in the end, something else, the discussion on serving or not serving kings. The title promises a journey, and Hythloday's journey gradually shows itself to be a journey of ideas. In the last pages it is Hythloday who accuses the councils of kings, not the narrator, who is seated there and answers as someone who thinks the opposite.
What More shows here is the first exchange of arguments between a traveler who prefers to see and a friend who wants to see him useful. Peter and Morus say that a man of such learning should counsel kings; Hythloday answers that kings do not listen, that counselors flatter and that no one accepts a new idea if it would shame the ancestors. The argument is his and the narrator listens to it, but More does not yet say who is right.
Subscription
The complete analysis of every chapter of Utopia comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.
Questions on this chapter
To discuss
5 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.
Test your reading
8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz