The Letter and Book I: The Question
The book opens with a letter. Thomas More, lawyer and under-sheriff of London, writes to his friend Peter Giles, in Antwerp, apologizing for having taken almost a year to send the little book about the republic of the Utopians (Letter to Peter Giles). He says the work was small, because he had only to repeat what the two of them heard from Raphael Hythloday, and he asks his friend to check two points: the length of the bridge at Amaurot and the position of the island, which no one remembered to ask about. He confesses that he has not yet decided to publish. What drives the rest of the book is a question, and it comes from More's own story: what should a man who knows do when power is close at hand?
The scene the letter announces takes place in Flanders, where King Henry VIII sent More to settle disputes with the prince of Castile (Book I, section 1). In Antwerp, as they leave church, Peter Giles introduces him to a man with a sunburned face and a cloak hanging from his shoulder, whom More takes for a ship's captain: he is Raphael Hythloday, a Portuguese very learned in Greek, who left his inheritance to his brothers, followed Amerigo Vespucci on three voyages and preferred to stay at the fort, more eager to wander than to have a grave. In More's garden, on a turf bench (Book I, section 2), Raphael tells of the lands he has seen and leaves the monsters aside, because what is hard to find is well-governed cities. Peter Giles asks why he does not join some king, and Raphael refuses: princes care more about conquering than about governing, and counselors only approve what the prince's favorite has already said.
To prove it, he tells of the dinner at the house of Cardinal Morton, where the lawyer praises the gallows for thieves (Book I, section 3). Raphael answers that the penalty is too cruel and useless: justice manufactures thieves, and the most characteristic cause in England is that of the sheep, which drive the farmers out to make room for pasture. He offers the example of the Polylerites, who make the thief restore and work, the lawyer rejects it, and only when the cardinal suggests trying it do all praise it. Next, Morus, the character, recalls Plato and wants the philosopher to counsel the king, and Raphael imagines the council of the king of France, where the talk is of how to hold Milan and recover Naples (Book I, section 4). Morus defends a "more civil" philosophy, which knows its stage and does as little harm as possible; Raphael answers that this is complicity and takes the conversation to the root: where there are private possessions and everything is measured by money, one cannot govern with justice. Morus says that without property no one works, and Raphael replies that he has not seen Utopia. They have lunch and return to hear about it.
Book II: The Island
Book II is Raphael's discourse. The island has the shape of a waxing moon, was a peninsula until the conqueror Utopus had fifteen miles dug and made the sea flow around it, and has fifty-four identical cities (Book II, section 1). Raphael describes only Amaurot, where he lived for five years, with its river, the stone bridge, the doors that open to anyone and the gardens that the streets compete over (Book II, section 2). The syphogrants, the tranibors and the prince for life govern under rules that prevent haste and conspiracy (Book II, section 3). Everyone works six hours, and the rest of the day is for the mind (Book II, section 4). They eat in common halls, take what they need from the storehouses without money, and the hospitals are so good that almost every sick person prefers to stay in them (Book II, section 5). They travel with permission, with no tavern or hiding place (Book II, section 6).
Then comes what most surprised the readers of the time. The cities share their abundance for free, and gold and silver, kept for war, go into chamber pots and the chains of slaves; the ambassadors of a distant people, covered in gold, are taken for slaves (Book II, section 7). The Utopians study in their free time and discuss true and false pleasure (Book II, section 8). In Book II, Section 9 come the slaves, euthanasia, marriage, the very few laws and the absence of lawyers and treaties. In Book II, Section 10 war is abhorred but waged with bounties, discord and hired soldiers, the Zapoletes. In Book II, Section 11 several religions coexist under a common name for the supreme being, Mithras, and the only thing forbidden is to think that the soul dies with the body.
Raphael closes with the praise of the republic (Book II, section 12): Utopia is the only one that deserves the name, because in the others people look after private interest under the word public, and what he sees in the republics of today is a conspiracy of the rich. When he finishes, the narrator More, instead of rebutting, falls silent: life without money, war and religion seemed absurd to him, but Raphael was tired and had already criticized those who want to seem wise by nibbling at the inventions of others. He praises the institution and the discourse, takes Raphael by the hand and leads him in to supper, saying that there will be another time to discuss it. And he ends: he cannot agree to everything, but there is much in Utopia that he would wish for more than he would expect to see in the cities of his own time. The book ends with the author's signature, the citizen and under-sheriff of London, leaving the reader between desire and expectation.