Chapter summary
Opening of the book. Next: Book I, Section 1: The Traveler Raphael Hythloday.
Thomas More writes to his friend Peter Giles, of Antwerp, to apologize for having taken almost a year to send the little book about the commonwealth of the Utopians, which Peter had expected in a month and a half. He says the labor was small: he did not have to invent or organize the matter, only to repeat what the two of them heard Raphael Hythloday tell, and the plain language serves the truth, the only thing he is concerned with in this work. Even so he found no time: the day goes to courts, visits, wife, children and servants, and he writes only with what he steals from sleep and meals. He then asks Peter to check two points. The first is the length of the bridge of Amaurot: Hythloday said it was five hundred paces, and More's boy, John Clement, recalls that the river there is no more than three hundred wide. If Peter does not remember either, More will leave what seems to him remembered, because he prefers to say a falsehood than to lie. The second is that no one asked in what part of the new world Utopia lies, and More would like to know, partly out of shame and partly because a theologian, a pious man, wants to go there, be made bishop of the Utopians and make the Christian religion grow, which he says has already begun there. More asks Peter to question Hythloday, preferably by showing him the book, and to find out whether he accepts that another should tell his story. He adds that he has not decided to publish: tastes are varied, critics cranky and many readers ungrateful, and he describes them one by one, from the barbarian who rejects whatever is not barbarous to the guest who eats the banquet and does not thank his host. He closes by saying that he will follow the advice of his friends, Peter's first.
Analysis
The title. It is a letter, and not the book: a note from More to a friend, written in the tone of one who delivers a job and accounts for the delay. It is this report-like tone that prepares the reader to take Utopia as a story heard, and not as someone's invention.
What More shows here is an author who presents himself as a mere reporter of a conversation he witnessed, and who says he wants only the truth. He worries about a bridge of five hundred or three hundred paces and forgets to ask where the island lies, says that he prefers to be good than to be prudent and confesses that he has not yet decided whether to publish. The more care with the details, the more the letter draws attention to what no one can check.
Subscription
The complete analysis of every chapter of Utopia comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.
Questions on this chapter
To discuss
5 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.
Test your reading
8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz