Clavis Libri

Utopia · Book I · Section 4

The Philosopher and the Counsel of Kings

Chapter summary

Book I, Section 4 of 4. Before: Book I, Section 3: At Cardinal Morton's Table. After: Book II, Section 1: The Island of Utopia.

Hythloday apologizes for the long story of the dinner, and Morus, the character in the book, says he enjoyed it and that it took him back to the cardinal's house where he was raised. He insists: if Hythloday would accept serving a prince, he would do the public much good. He recalls Plato, for whom republics will be happy only if philosophers reign or kings philosophize. Hythloday answers that philosophers already counsel in books, but that kings, raised in perverse opinions, do not listen to them, as Plato himself saw with Dionysius.

To prove it, he imagines himself on the council of the king of France, where they discuss how to hold Milan, retake Naples, ruin Venice and swallow up Flanders and Burgundy, with alliances made to be broken. If he proposed staying at home, he would cite the Achorians, who after conquering a kingdom saw that keeping it cost as much as conquering it and gave the king the choice of keeping only one. He also imagines counselors who invent ways to fill the treasury: tampering with the coinage, feigning war, collecting fines from forgotten laws, selling dispensations, winning over the judges; Crassus would say that no gold suffices for one who supports an army, and that the people must be kept poor so they will not rebel. Hythloday would answer that the people choose the king for themselves, that misery does not keep the peace and that to reign over beggars is to keep a prison, and would cite the Macarians, whose king swears never to have more than a thousand pounds of gold in the treasury. They would be deaf.

Morus agrees that such speeches would not be heard, but he makes a distinction: scholastic philosophy has no place in the council; another, "more civil," knows its stage and plays the part in the play on the boards, like the actor who does not recite Seneca in a comedy of Plautus. If an evil cannot be cured, it should be made as small as possible, by an indirect route. Hythloday refuses: to dissemble is to be complicit, and the preachers who bent Christ to customs succeeded only in making it possible to be wicked with more security. In the council he would have to approve the worst decrees or be corrupted by his colleagues, and Plato said that the wise, seeing the people out in the rain, withdraw to their houses.

From there he goes to the root: where there are private possessions and everything is measured by money, one does not govern with justice, and only the abolition of property distributes with equality. Morus disagrees: without property no one works, and there would be sedition. Hythloday answers that Morus has not seen Utopia, where he lived more than five years. Peter Giles doubts that a people of the New World could be better instituted; Hythloday says that the Utopians learned from shipwrecked Romans and Egyptians, and that they have more zeal. They ask for the description of the island, have lunch and return to hear it.

Analysis

The title. "The Philosopher and the Counsel of Kings" is the question that occupies the section: what can a man who thinks do when he is close to power? The title of the whole book, in Latin, is "On the Best State of the Commonwealth and the New Island of Utopia," and the end of this section is the passage from one thing to the other: the discussion about serving the king ends when Hythloday asks to speak of the island.

What More shows here is a discussion without a winner about whether a just man should serve an unjust prince. Hythloday thinks that in the king's council there is no place for the truth, because counselors speak only of what the king already wants and whoever says otherwise becomes a laughingstock. Morus thinks it is better to try, with tact, to lessen the evil. The root of the problem, for Hythloday, is private property and money as the measure of everything, and Morus answers that without property no one works. Both are left standing, and Book II will be Hythloday's defense of his own.

Unlock with a subscription

Subscription

The complete analysis of every chapter of Utopia comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.

See the plansAlready subscribed? Sign in

Questions on this chapter

To discuss

5 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.

Test your reading

8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz