Chapter summary
Book II, Section 3 of 12. Before: Book II, Section 2: The Cities and Amaurot. After: Book II, Section 4: The Trades.
Raphael Hythloday passes from the city to those who govern it. For every thirty families, a magistrate is elected each year, the syphogrant, also called phylarch. Over ten syphogrants and their families stands a tranibor, now called protophylarch. The two hundred syphogrants of the city swear to elect the most useful man and, by secret ballot, proclaim prince one of four names that the people have presented, one from each quarter of the city. The prince governs for life, unless he is suspected of having aspired to tyranny. The tranibors are elected every year, but rarely replaced, and all the other magistrates serve a year.
The tranibors meet with the prince every three days, or more if the case requires, to deliberate on public business, and they quickly settle the few disputes between private persons. Two syphogrants enter the senate, on different days. No public matter is valid without having been debated three days in the senate before the decree, and deliberating on common affairs outside the senate or the public assemblies is a capital crime. The reason given is to prevent the prince and the tranibors from uniting to oppress the people and change the regime. That is why what is of great importance goes to the assemblies of the syphogrants, who discuss it with their families, deliberate among themselves and bring the opinion to the senate. Sometimes the question goes to the council of the whole island.
There is also a rule of custom: nothing is discussed on the day it is proposed, and the matter is left for the next senate. Thus no one blurts out whatever came to his mouth and then spends his time looking for reasons to defend what he said, instead of seeking what serves the common good. For, out of a twisted shame, he would rather ruin the public safety than lose the good opinion others have of him, so as not to seem to have foreseen too little at the start. It was his duty to foresee from the beginning and to speak with reflection, and not in haste.
Analysis
The title. "On the Magistrates": the title is dry, and so is the section. It is the first time that Hythloday's discourse enters institutions, and what he shows is who commands and, above all, how anyone is prevented from commanding alone.
What More shows here, through Hythloday's mouth, is a government designed against tyranny: elections every year, secret ballot, a prince for life who loses office under suspicion, three days of debate and a capital crime for anyone who decides outside the senate. The danger the text sees is the power of a few who combine in secret, and the defense is slowness and the sight of everyone. It is also a rule of humility: one who speaks in haste tends to defend what he said, and not the truth.
Subscription
The complete analysis of every chapter of Utopia comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.
Questions on this chapter
To discuss
4 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.
Test your reading
8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz