Chapter summary
Book II, section 10 of 12. Before: Book II, section 9: The Laws of the Utopians. After: Book II, section 11: The Religions of the Utopians.
Raphael Hythloday begins by saying that the Utopians abominate war, a thing of beasts, and that they find nothing more inglorious than glory sought in it. Even so, men and women train on appointed days, so as not to be unfit when the need comes. They undertake it only to defend their borders, to drive invaders from the lands of their friends, to free a people oppressed by a tyrant and to avenge their friends, when consulted in time and after complaining in vain. Included in this list is the injury done to merchants abroad, under color of law. Such was the case of the war they fought, shortly before the narrator's time, for the Nephelogetes against the Alaopolitans: it spread among the neighboring peoples and ended only with the surrender of the Alaopolitans, handed over to the Nephelogetes, since the Utopians were not fighting for themselves. The loss of their own citizens' money they bear, because the damage falls on what was surplus and no one feels it; but if one of their own is wounded or killed, they demand the surrender of the guilty, and without it they declare war.
A bloody victory causes them shame, like merchandise bought too dear. To win by art and guile, however, is glory, because only man wins by wit, while the beasts surpass him in strength. Once war is declared, they secretly post, in enemy territory, proclamations with enormous rewards for whoever kills the opposing prince, smaller rewards per head for those they name, double for whoever hands them over alive, and impunity for the proscribed themselves who betray their companions. They call this humane: few guilty die and many innocents are saved. If that is not enough, they sow discord among the enemy's nobles and pay neighbors to attack him. They spare their citizens and spend without pity the gold and silver, which they have in surplus and in the debts of peoples.
To fight, they hire above all the Zapoletes, a rude mountain people five hundred miles away, who know only war and sell their arm to anyone, to the point of changing sides for one penny more; relatives end up killing each other in opposing armies. The Utopians pay them very well, expose them to the greatest dangers and do not mind if they die, judging that the world would only gain by being rid of people so sordid. After them come the troops of the allies and, last, the citizens who enlist by choice, under a leader of proven virtue who has two deputies. No one is sent abroad against his will, and the timid enter combat only when the homeland is threatened, on the ships or the walls, with no way to retreat. The women may accompany their husbands, and the families fight side by side, which makes the combat long and fierce. The most select young men hunt the enemy leader.
As victors, they capture instead of killing and never pursue fugitives without keeping formation, because they have seen a victory turn into defeat. They fortify the camp with their own hands, fight with axes and arrows and hide the engines until the right hour. They respect truces, spare crops, the unarmed and surrendered cities, and no one takes anything of the booty. In the end, they charge the vanquished for the expenses, in money and in lands that yield more than seven hundred thousand ducats a year, collected by quaestors. If they are invaded, they go out to meet the enemy beyond the borders.
Analysis
The title. "Of the Military Art" promises a manual of how war is made, and the section has a little of that, the camp, the weapons, the formation. But almost everything that matters in it is how not to fight: paying so that the enemy kills his own prince, buying his nobles, letting the Zapoletes die in place of the citizens. The Utopians' military art is the art of not having to fight.
What More shows here is a people who hate war and wage it with method, without feeling any contradiction in it. The one who speaks is Hythloday, not the narrator: he describes everything Utopia does to save the blood of its own, and this care depends on gold, on mercenaries who can die and on well-paid treason. The text does not comment; it lets the reader see what the perfect island does when perfection needs help from outside.
Subscription
The complete analysis of every chapter of Utopia comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.
Questions on this chapter
To discuss
4 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.
Test your reading
8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz