Chapter summary
Book II, section 7 of 12. Before: Book II, section 6: The Utopians' Travels. After: Book II, section 8: Education, Studies and Pleasure.
Raphael Hythloday links the way of life described so far to abundance: since everyone works and things reach everyone equally, no one can be poor or a beggar. Every year the senate of Amaurot, where three men from each city gather, reckons what is left over in each place and where the harvest has been poorer, and the want of some is made up from the surplus of others, free and without exchange. Only when they have provisions for two years do they export the excess (grain, honey, wool, flax, timber, hides, animals): they give a seventh part to the poor of the destination region and sell the rest at a moderate price. From this trade they bring home little more than iron, and a great deal of gold and silver, which they keep as a war treasure, to pay foreign soldiers and buy off enemies, and not to spend.
So that no one may grow attached to these metals, the Utopians use them in the vilest way: chamber pots and sordid vessels, slaves' chains, rings, necklaces and golden crowns on the infamous. Pearls, diamonds and carbuncles, found by chance on the beaches and among the rocks, adorn the children, who leave them off when they grow up, as ours leave off their little balls and dolls. The example is the embassy of the Anemolians, a people who live far away and knew the Utopians poorly: three ambassadors and a hundred attendants enter Amaurot in silk, golden cloaks, necklaces and rings, certain that they will dazzle "the wretched Utopians." The Utopians take the ambassadors for slaves, because of the golden chains, and greet the humblest of the retinue as lords; the boys mock the pearls, and the mother says that one must be "one of the ambassadors' fools." After a day or two, seeing that on a single runaway slave there was more gold and silver in chains than the apparatus of the three had cost, the ambassadors put away their finery, ashamed.
The passage ends with what the Utopians find strange in other peoples: that anyone should delight in a little stone when he has the sun and the stars, that anyone should think himself nobler for a thread of finer wool, that a blockhead of lead should have wise men as slaves just for having coins, and that quasi-divine honors should be paid to a rich man from whom not a penny will ever come.
Analysis
The title. "Of the Equalization of Abundance": the section promises to speak of economics (how the island distributes what it produces) and, in a few pages, becomes a section about the value of things. The equalization the title speaks of is that of goods among the cities and also that of gold with trash: in both cases, what the people do is strip the shine from what other nations fight over.
What More shows here, through the mouth of Hythloday, is that the Utopians' abundance comes from sharing the surplus without charge, and that contempt for gold is a planned institution, not a trait of character. They give gold the lowest use so that no one will value it beyond what its nature deserves, and thus they keep a treasure without growing attached to it. The text does not say the island is virtuous because of this: it shows a people who chose a means of not having the problem of covetousness.
Subscription
The complete analysis of every chapter of Utopia comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.
Questions on this chapter
To discuss
4 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.
Test your reading
8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz