Chapter summary
Book II, section 12 of 12. Before: Book II, section 11: The Religions of the Utopians. This is the last section of the book.
Raphael Hythloday closes the discourse with a eulogy. Utopia, he says, is the only republic that deserves the name, because in the others everyone talks about the public good and looks after his private one, and on the island, where nothing is private, the public good is truly looked after. There no one has anything and all are rich: free from anxiety about their livelihood, their wife, their children, their daughter's dowry, and they also care for those who can no longer work.
Then he compares it with the other nations. What justice is this in which nobles, goldsmiths and usurers, who do nothing necessary, live in splendor, while the day laborer, the carter, the craftsman and the farmer, without whom no republic lasts a year, live worse than beasts of burden and end in old age without resources? The republic that abuses them in the flower of their age repays them with the most wretched death, and the rich still scrape away at the poor man's wages, by fraud and by law. Hythloday concludes that what he sees in the republics of today is "a certain conspiracy of the rich": they gather what they have by evil arts, buy the labor of the poor at a low price, and then decree it as law in the name of the public.
In Utopia, with money removed, frauds, thefts, robberies and murders vanish, and even poverty would diminish. In a year of famine, the granaries of the rich would have grain for all, and it was money, invented to open the way to sustenance, that closes it. The rich feel this, he says, and reason or the authority of Christ would already have brought the world to these laws, were it not for pride, which measures prosperity by the misery of others and is the mother of all plagues. He rejoices that at least the Utopians have this republic, which seems to him made to last.
Raphael finishes, and the narrator, More the character, tells what he thought: much in the Utopians' customs seemed absurd to him, in war, in religion and above all in the life without money, which overturns nobility, magnificence, splendor and majesty. But he kept silent: Raphael was tired, and had already criticized those who want to seem wise by nitpicking at other people's inventions. He praised, took him in to supper and said there would be another time to discuss. And he closes: he cannot assent to everything, but confesses that there is much in Utopia that he would wish for more than he would expect to see in the cities of his time. The book ends with the author's signature, "the most illustrious and most learned man, Master Thomas More, citizen and under-sheriff of London."
Analysis
The title. "Praise of the Utopian Republic" is the text's own, but the praise is Hythloday's, and the chapter has two parts: his discourse and the narrator's reply. It is the point at which the book ends with the narrator's voice, without a response from Hythloday.
What More shows here is, first, an accusation without half measures: the republics of today are a conspiracy of the rich, and pride is what keeps men from changing. But it shows, afterward, a narrator who does not answer Hythloday: he disagrees in silence, out of Hythloday's weariness and out of courtesy, and closes by saying that he wishes for more than he expects. The text does not say whether Utopia is a model, a critique or a game. It leaves the reader with the question.
Subscription
The complete analysis of every chapter of Utopia comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.
Questions on this chapter
To discuss
5 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.
Test your reading
8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz