Chapter summary
Book II, section 9 of 12. Before: Book II, section 8: Education, Studies and Pleasure. After: Book II, section 10: War.
Raphael Hythloday begins with the slaves. The Utopians do not enslave prisoners of war (except those from a war of their own), nor the children of slaves, nor people bought from other nations: a slave is one who has committed a shameful act among them, or one condemned to execution in a foreign city (the most frequent case, and many come free of charge). They labor without end and in chains, and citizens who fall into this are treated more harshly. There is also the poor laborer from another nation who chooses to be a slave among them: he is treated almost as a citizen and may leave whenever he likes.
The sick are treated with affection. To one who suffers from an incurable and painful disease, priests and magistrates advise that he no longer feed the illness: he may leave life by fasting or by painless sleep, or consent to have it taken, of his own will. No one has his life taken against his will, nor is his care lessened; whoever kills himself without the approval of the priests and the senate is thrown unburied into a swamp.
Marriage follows. A woman marries only after eighteen, and a man later. Furtive lust before marriage is punished severely, and the heads of the household where it occurred are made infamous, because few would unite for a whole lifetime if they were not kept from roving intercourse. In the choosing, a matron shows the bride naked to the suitor and a man of integrity shows the groom naked to the bride: Hythloday and his companions laughed, and the Utopians thought it stupid of the peoples who examine the whole colt and choose a wife by seeing only the face. Marriage is dissolved only by death, by adultery, or by intolerable perversity of character, with the leave of the senate, which also examines the cause of divorce by the wish of both. Adultery leads to heavy slavery, and to death for a repeat offense. For other crimes no law fixes the penalty: the senate decrees according to gravity, and almost all the grave ones lead to slavery, which they consider more useful than death and which is eased, by the prince or by the people, for one who shows repentance.
Fools are the delight of the house, and to mock the deformed is a shame to the mocker. Statues of distinguished men stand in the forum; whoever seeks an office is left without hope of it. The magistrates are called fathers. The laws are very few, interpreted in a plain sense, and pleaders are excluded: each person defends his own case. Neighboring peoples ask for Utopian magistrates for a year or a five-year term, because whoever soon returns home does not sell himself or take sides. And the Utopians make no treaties: nature suffices, they say, and whoever has despised it will not care about words.
Analysis
The title. "Of the Laws of the Utopians": what the section gathers, however, is how the law touches the life of those who live on the island: slavery, death, marriage, punishment and the neighbors. The word "laws" covers everything, and what the text affirms in the middle is that they are few.
What More shows here, through the mouth of Hythloday, is an order in which a few simple laws suffice because education has already done the work of forming customs, and in which the penalty for crime is labor and not death. The text describes without hiding what is harsh, such as slavery and advised euthanasia, and what is strange to the European reader, such as the couple seeing each other naked before marriage, as part of the same design: taking deceit out of relations between people.
Subscription
The complete analysis of every chapter of Utopia comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.
Questions on this chapter
To discuss
5 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.
Test your reading
8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz