Clavis Libri

Questions · Utopia

Is there no money in Utopia?

Within the island, no. Each city keeps the products of labor in storehouses, and any head of household takes, without money and without payment, what he and his family need (Book II, section 5). Hythloday explains why no one asks for too much: what makes a person greedy and rapacious is the fear of lacking, and in man, pride, which wants to surpass others by the display of the superfluous. Where nothing is lacking, the fear disappears. And pride is held in check by a design that lets no one stand out, with identical clothing, houses assigned by lot and a common table.

Outside the island, however, there are gold and silver. From trade with other peoples the Utopians bring back iron and a great deal of gold and silver, and they keep these metals as a war reserve, to pay foreign soldiers (Book II, section 7). Hythloday concludes at the end that, once money is removed, frauds, thefts and murders disappear, and that it was money, invented to open access to sustenance, that closes it (Book II, section 12). More, for his part, objects in Book I that without the reason of gain no one works (Book I, section 4), and the book does not decide.

More questions about Utopia

See all questions