Clavis Libri

Questions · Utopia

Did Thomas More endorse Utopia?

The book does not make this clear. More appears in the text in two ways: as the author of the letter to Peter Giles and as a character, called Morus, who argues with Hythloday. The one who defends the island is Hythloday. Morus objects, and the two positions stand in the discussion about serving a prince (Book I, section 4). When Hythloday presents the Utopians' philosophy of pleasure, he himself says that he narrates, and does not defend, their institutions (Book II, section 8).

The most direct answer is at the end. After the praise of the republic, the narrator tells that much in the Utopians' customs seemed absurd to him, in war, in religion and above all in life without money. He keeps silent out of courtesy and concludes that he cannot agree to everything, but that there are very many things in Utopia that he would wish for more than he would expect to see in his own cities (Book II, section 12). The narrator, therefore, says that he disagrees with parts of the island, that he would wish for much of it in his own cities and that he does not expect to see it there. The book leaves it to the reader to decide whether Utopia is a model, a mirror or a warning.

More questions about Utopia

See all questions