Clavis Libri

The Prince

Context

The era in which the work was written, where the story came from, and what that changes in the reading.

A Secretary Removed from Power

Niccolò Machiavelli served the republic of Florence as secretary until 1512, when the Medici returned to power and the regime fell. On behalf of the government, he traveled on missions to the court of the king of France and to that of the emperor Maximilian, and he came to know Cesare Borgia at close range, in 1502. These journeys enter the book as testimony: he heard Cesare himself speak of his plans for his father's death (Chapter VII), talked at Nantes with a French cardinal (Chapter III) and saw how the emperor made decisions (Chapter XXIII). In 1513 he was arrested and interrogated, on suspicion of conspiring against the Medici, and then released. He withdrew from public life and wrote the book, which in a letter of that year he calls a little work, "De principatibus," on principalities. It is from this condition of a man set aside that he speaks in the Dedication, when he asks the addressee to turn his eyes to the low places and see the malignity of fortune that he endures without deserving it.

For Whom the Book Was Written

The book is offered to Lorenzo de' Medici, a young man of the family that governed Florence and nephew of Pope Leo X, whom Machiavelli praises at the close of Chapter XI. The Dedication follows the custom of those who want to win a prince's favor: instead of horses, arms and cloths of gold, he sends knowledge of the actions of great men, reduced to a small volume. The same family reappears at the end, when Chapter XXVI asks the House of Medici to free Italy.

A Divided and Invaded Italy

Machiavelli's Italy was not a state. Chapter XI shows her divided among the pope, the Venetians, the king of Naples, the duke of Milan and the Florentines, who kept watch on one another. In 1494, King Charles VIII of France came down to the peninsula, and from then on foreign armies decided the fate of cities: Louis XII took Milan in 1499 and lost it (Chapter III), Venice was defeated at Agnadello, in 1509 (Chapter XX), and the battle of Ravenna, in 1512, exposed the weight of foreign infantries (Chapter XXVI).

Inside Florence politics was also violent. The friar Girolamo Savonarola dominated the city from 1494 and was burned in the square in 1498 (Chapter VI). Between 1505 and 1506, Machiavelli secured a militia of citizens, which he organized and which the Spaniards defeated at Prato, in 1512 (Chapter XIV). The republic fell soon afterward. That is why the book insists on arms of one's own and blames mercenary soldiers for Italy's having been taken almost without a fight (Chapter XII).

An Old Genre, a New Method

The book belongs to the tradition of mirrors for princes, treatises that described the good ruler by the qualities he ought to have. Among the ancients, Cicero's treatise on duties was the reference, and Machiavelli has it before him when he discusses generosity, fear and keeping one's word (Chapter XVI, Chapter XVII, Chapter XVIII). He takes another path: in Chapter XV, he declares that he prefers the effectual truth of the matter to the imagination of it, because many have imagined republics and principalities that never existed. In place of the ideal model, he offers examples of real men, ancient and modern (Chapter VI, Chapter VII).

The form, too, is unusual. Machiavelli writes in Italian, not in Latin, in a short volume, and warns in the Dedication that he has not adorned it with pompous words: he wanted only the truth of the matter to make it pleasing.

From Manuscript to Disputed Book

Machiavelli died in 1527, and the book was printed only in 1532, in Rome and in Florence, after circulating in manuscript copies. Since then it has been read in opposite ways: as a handbook of cunning for tyrants, as a cold analysis of how power works, as a lesson to the people. In 1559 the Church placed his works on the Index of forbidden books, and the word Machiavellian came to mean, in many languages, unscrupulous cunning. To understand the book, it is better to return to each chapter and to the question it answers, rather than to start from its fame.

Go to the plot