Clavis Libri

The Prince · Chapter XXVI

An Exhortation to Liberate Italy from the Barbarians

Chapter summary

Machiavelli asks whether the times now running in Italy are times to honor a new prince and whether there is matter for a prudent and virtuous man to introduce into it a new form, which would bring him honor and do good to all; he finds that so many things concur in favor that there was never a more fitting time. The virtue of Moses required the people of Israel enslaved in Egypt, that of Cyrus the Persians oppressed by the Medes, that of Theseus the Athenians dispersed; now, to know the virtue of an Italian spirit, Italy had to be more enslaved than the Hebrews, more servile than the Persians, more dispersed than the Athenians, without a leader, beaten, despoiled, overrun. Some glimmer has already appeared, but fortune rejected it at the height of its actions, and Italy waits for someone to heal her wounds.

She prays to God for a redeemer and is ready to follow a banner, and Machiavelli sees no one in whom she can hope more than in the House of Medici, favored by God and by the Church, of which it is now prince. Moses and the others were only men and had a lesser opportunity: the enterprise was neither more just nor easier, nor was God more their friend. Here there is justice, because a war that is necessary is just; there is great readiness; and there are prodigies, the sea opened, the cloud, the rock that poured water, the manna. The rest is up to the prince, because God does not want to do everything. If no Italian has done what is expected, it is because the old institutions were no good and no one found new ones, and nothing honors a man who rises anew so much as the new laws and institutions. There is virtue in the limbs: in duels the Italians excel in strength, dexterity and wit; in armies they do not show, because of the weakness of the leaders, and all the wars of the last twenty years with an Italian army have turned out badly, from the Taro to Mestre.

The foundation is to provide oneself with arms of one's own. The Swiss and Spanish infantry are feared, but each has a defect: the Spanish cannot withstand cavalry and the Swiss fear foot soldiers as obstinate as themselves, as was seen at Ravenna. A third order can resist horses and not fear the infantry, and what makes it is the variation of orders, not the kind of arms. The opportunity must not be allowed to pass: with what love, thirst for vengeance and tears a redeemer would be received by those to whom barbarian rule stinks. The book ends with four lines of Petrarch: virtue will take up arms against fury, and the ancient valor in Italian hearts is not yet dead.

Analysis

The title. "Exhortation" is a genre of oratory: it is the speech that urges to act, and not the one that analyzes. "Barbarians," in the mouth of an Italian of the sixteenth century, are the foreigners who occupy the peninsula, French, Spanish and Swiss. The book, which began with a dedication and a list of principalities, ends with an appeal.

What Machiavelli shows here is that, after twenty-five chapters of cold analysis, he asks the prince to act: to liberate Italy. The argument stands on three feet: the opportunity (Italy is in such a bad way that a redeemer would be received with open arms), the matter (the Italians are good one by one and lack a leader and new institutions) and the means (arms of one's own and a new order for the infantry). God and fortune help, but the rest is up to the prince.

Unlock with a subscription

Subscription

The complete analysis of every chapter of The Prince comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.

See the plansAlready subscribed? Sign in

Questions on this chapter

To discuss

5 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.

Test your reading

8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz