Dedication: To Lorenzo de' Medici
Machiavelli could have brought the prince the usual gift, horses and cloth of gold, and he brings what he knows. What does this say about what he considers valuable, and what do you have that is most your own to offer when you want to be noticed?
He warns that he has not adorned the work, so that only the truth of the matter may make it pleasing. How often do we embellish what we say in order to please, and what is lost when the embellishment is the part most carefully tended?
To know peoples one must be a prince, and to know princes, one must be of the people. When did an outsider ever see something about your situation that you, from the inside, could not?
The book ends the dedication with a request: that the prince look down and see the malignity of fortune that the author endures. What changes in tone when the one who teaches power admits that he too needs it?
Chapter I: How Many Kinds of Principalities There Are and How They Are Acquired
Machiavelli divides all states into republics and principalities, with no ideal state in between. What changes when one thinks about politics only with what exists, and what is lost?
He chooses two examples from his own time, Milan for Sforza and Naples for the king of Spain, instead of an abstract definition. When does a known example teach more than a general rule?
Among the ways of coming to power are fortune and virtù. How much of what you have achieved came from what you did, and how much from circumstances you did not choose?
Chapter II: Of Hereditary Principalities
A prince of ordinary diligence holds on to the inherited state, and only an extraordinary force brings him down. How much of power comes from the place one occupies, and how much from the person who occupies it?
The heir is more loved because he has fewer reasons to offend. When does the affection we receive come from the position we hold, and not from what we have done?
One change, says Machiavelli, leaves a toothing for the building of another. When did changing something small, at home or at work, open the door to changes you did not want?
Chapter III: Of Mixed Principalities
Peoples open the gates to the conqueror believing they will improve and soon see that they are worse off. How many times have you swapped something (a job, a leader, a plan) hoping to improve, and only afterward seen the price?
Machiavelli separates the light injury, which provokes revenge, from the grave one, which prevents it, and concludes that the injury must be such that one need not fear revenge. What does this sentence show about the way he thinks about power, and where would you not follow him?
At the start, he says, the hectic fever is easy to cure and hard to recognize. Which problem of yours is now at that stage, easy to solve and hard to see?
The Romans refused to "enjoy the benefits of time." When is waiting prudence, and when is it merely postponing a problem that will grow?
Whoever is the cause of another's becoming powerful ruins himself, because power given is suspect to the one who received it. Why does the one who helps someone grow come to be viewed with distrust by that person?
Chapter IV: Why the Kingdom of Darius Did Not Rebel
Machiavelli asks why Alexander's state did not rebel, and answers that it depends on how it was built. When does someone's success come more from the ground they stood on than from the talent attributed to them?
Where all power comes from a single lord, it is hard to enter and easy to stay. What happens to a group, a company or a family when everything depends on one person and that person falls?
Whoever enters by the hands of a discontented man has the road open and a debt to pay. Why does the one who helps us arrive often become a problem afterward?
Rebellions continue as long as the memory of the old lords lasts. Which memories of the past still rule what you live through, even if no one wants them to?
Chapter V: How to Govern Cities That Lived Under Their Own Laws
Machiavelli says that, to possess a city that has lived free, there is only one sure way: ruin. Why does he see so little way out in this case, and where do you think his reasoning fails?
The name of liberty and the ancient institutions, he says, are forgotten neither through time nor through benefits. What memory of a people, a family or your own can no benefit erase?
Peoples accustomed to obeying a prince, once his line is extinct, "to live free they do not know how." What liberty did you learn to use only after a long time without it?
The Romans tried to leave Greece free and it did not work for them. When does a good intention toward someone who depends on us fail because it ignores what the other remembers?
Chapter VI: New Principalities Won with One's Own Arms and Virtù
Machiavelli tells us to aim above the target and to imitate the great knowing we will not equal them. Whom do you imitate, and what, exactly, are you trying to copy from them: the result or the path?
Without the opportunity virtù goes out, and without virtù the opportunity passes in vain. How many opportunities have passed you by without your recognizing them as such?
Those who would lose by the change fight in earnest, and those who would gain defend it lukewarmly. Where have you seen this happen to a good idea, and what did the one proposing it do, or fail to do?
Savonarola fell when the people stopped believing in him, and Machiavelli says that unarmed prophets are ruined. Does a just idea sustain itself merely by being just?
Chapter VII: New Principalities Won with Others' Arms and Fortune
Whoever rises by another's hand "flies" without difficulty and meets the problems only after arriving. Have you ever been given something you had not prepared to keep? What happened?
Cesare Borgia gives Ramiro full powers to pacify and then kills him to clear the population's hatred. Who does the hard work for another and then pays for the result, and what does this say about the one who commands?
Machiavelli tells of Ramiro's death without saying whether he approves. Why does he leave the reader to decide, and what does he expect the reader to notice?
Cesare thought of everything except that he would be ill at his father's death. How often do we plan everything that depends on us and forget the point that does not?
Machiavelli says that new benefits do not make old injuries forgotten. Do you trust more the one who offended you and afterward did you a favor, or do you keep waiting for the next blow?
Chapter VIII: Of Those Who Came to Power by Crimes
Machiavelli admits that Agathocles had a captain's virtù, but says that crime takes his glory away. What is the difference between winning and deserving to be remembered?
Oliverotto returns as an honored nephew and uses his uncle's hospitality as a weapon. What does trust between relatives and countrymen protect, and what leaves it defenseless?
Machiavelli says that cruelty well used is that which is done all at once and then ends. Why do the dose and duration of evil matter more than the fact of practicing it?
Injuries should come all together and benefits little by little. Do you remember more a single great pain or small repeated offenses, and what does this change in the way you treat others?
Good done when there is no way out is judged forced and earns no gratitude. When do you truly acknowledge someone's favor, and when do you only collect on it?
Chapter IX: Of the Civil Principality
The people want neither to be commanded nor oppressed, and the great want to command. In a group you know, who wants to command and who wants only not to be harmed, and how does this show up day to day?
Machiavelli says it is easier to satisfy the people than the great. Why does satisfying those who ask only not to be oppressed cost less than satisfying those who want to oppress?
Whoever rises through the great has many who consider themselves his equals, and whoever rises through the people stands alone. Which is harder, to command those who think themselves your equals or those who obey you?
In quiet times everyone promises to die for the state, and in adverse ones few appear. Which of your friends would show up if everything went wrong, and how do you know?
The wise prince sees to it that his citizens always need the state. Does that need produce real fidelity or only dependence?
Chapter X: How the Strength of All Principalities Should Be Measured
Machiavelli measures a state's strength by asking whether it sustains itself alone. If you applied that question to yourself, what would you depend on others for in defending yourself in a crisis?
The German cities store food and work for a year before they need them. What are you leaving in store today for when bad times come?
For Machiavelli, whoever has a strong city and is not hated by the people cannot be attacked. Why is the wall not enough without the goodwill of those who live inside it?
He says that subjects unite more with the prince when they have lost their houses in defending him. Why does one who suffers for a cause come to feel that it owes him something, and where do you see this outside war?
Chapter XI: Of Ecclesiastical Principalities
Machiavelli says that only ecclesiastical principalities are secure and happy, and at once states that he will not speak of them. Why does he announce that he is silent and then speak?
The barons of Rome, divided into Orsini and Colonna, kept the pope weak. Why does one who governs a group usually prefer that rivals weaken by fighting one another?
Alexander VI wanted to enlarge his son, and the result was the greatness of the Church. Can an action done out of self-interest serve a greater good? What does this change in how we judge the one who acts?
Machiavelli says that the two previous popes made the Church great with arms and hopes that Leo X will make it venerable with goodness. How does one read a compliment written to someone who can give the author employment?
Chapter XII: The Kinds of Militia and Mercenary Soldiers
Machiavelli says that there cannot be good laws without good arms, nor good arms without good laws. Why does law need force, and force need law?
The mercenary has only a little pay and does not want to die for the one who pays him. In what situations of your life do you depend on someone who is there only for the pay?
Against those who blamed the people's sins, Machiavelli points to a concrete cause: mercenary arms. How often do we give a failure a grand explanation and fail to see the small, concrete cause?
For Machiavelli, the prince should go to war himself and the republic should send its citizens. What changes when the one who takes the risk is the owner of the cause?
The Italian captains organized war so as to run less risk: they did not kill one another, did not dig ditches, did not camp in winter. What happens to a profession that writes its own rules to avoid danger?
Chapter XIII: Auxiliary, Mixed and Own Soldiers
Julius II called the king of Spain to help him and avoided becoming his prisoner only by chance. When we ask help of someone stronger, what do we come to owe him?
For Machiavelli, in mercenaries the danger is cowardice and in auxiliaries it is courage. Why can a strong ally be more dangerous than a weak one?
Cesare Borgia was greatly esteemed only when everyone saw that he was master of his own arms. How does being the owner of one's own instrument change the way others treat us?
Saul's arms fell off David's body. When did you use another person's method, clothing or idea and realize that it was not yours?
Machiavelli says that whoever recognizes evils only when they are born is not truly wise, and that this is given to few. What small signs have you been letting pass today?
Chapter XIV: A Prince's Duties Concerning the Militia
Machiavelli says that the first cause of losing the state is despising the art of war. What art do you despise that nevertheless sustains what you have?
The sons of Francesco Sforza lost the duchy by avoiding the fatigues that made their father a duke. Why does the second generation usually lose what the first conquered?
For Machiavelli, the armed man does not obey the unarmed willingly, and the unarmed man is not secure among the armed. Why does one who commands without understanding the trade of others lose their respect?
Philopoemen imagined, in time of peace, what he would do if the enemy were on that hill. What difficult situation do you rehearse in your head before it arrives?
Alexander imitated Achilles, Caesar imitated Alexander, Scipio imitated Cyrus. Who is your model, and what have you read about his life?
Chapter XV: Of Those Things for Which Men, and Especially Princes, Are Praised or Blamed
Machiavelli prefers "the effectual truth of the matter" to the imagination of it, and says he writes for those who understand. What is gained, and what is risked, by describing things as they are and not as they ought to be?
Whoever abandons what is done for what ought to be done learns his own ruin. When did you see someone ruin himself by acting as the world ought to be and not as it is?
The prince must learn to be able not to be good. What changes when this is understood as a capacity, and not as a decision to be bad?
There is something that looks like virtue and ruins, and something that looks like vice and saves. Which attitude of yours, held to be a virtue, has already cost you dearly?
Chapter XVI: Of Liberality and Meanness
To be held liberal one must give ostentatiously. What does this say about the generosity that wants to be seen?
The prince who spends everything ends up collecting from the people and falls into the reputation of miser. What happens to one who tries to buy esteem and is left without the means to maintain it?
Saving displeases the few who do not receive, and gives security to many. When is the quiet good done to many worth more than the grand gesture to a few?
Spending what is others' increases reputation, and spending what is one's own harms it. Why does this idea disturb, and what does Machiavelli want the reader to see in it?
Liberality consumes itself. Which good things that you do are exhausted the more you use them?
Chapter XVII: Of Cruelty and Clemency, and Whether It Is Better to Be Loved or Feared
Cesare Borgia was held to be cruel and left the Romagna at peace, and Florence, to avoid the name of cruel, let Pistoia destroy itself. When does avoiding the reputation of being hard cost more than being hard?
Machiavelli says that men offer everything while need is far away and rebel when it arrives. When has someone promised you everything and vanished at the moment of pressure?
Love is a bond of obligation that breaks when it suits, and fear is a punishment that does not leave. What does this reveal about a relationship sustained by only one of the two?
Men forget the death of a father sooner than the loss of a patrimony. What does this say about what wounds us most?
Machiavelli tells the prince to found himself on what is his, and not on what is others'. What in your life depends only on you, and what depends on the goodwill of others?
Chapter XVIII: How Princes Should Keep Their Word
Machiavelli says there is fighting by laws, proper to men, and fighting by force, proper to beasts, and that the first often does not suffice. When rules stop being enough, what is left to one who wants to act?
Machiavelli tells that the ancients gave princes a half-man, half-beast teacher. Why does he need a myth to say something so harsh?
One must be a fox to see the traps and a lion to frighten the wolves. In what situation was your firmness not enough, for lack of the cunning to see the snare?
Alexander VI swore as no one else did and kept his word less, and deception always worked for him. What makes it so easy to deceive, according to Machiavelli, and what does this say about the one who lets himself be deceived?
Everyone sees what you appear to be, few feel what you are. How often do we prefer to appear good rather than to be?
Chapter XIX: How Contempt and Hatred Should Be Avoided
The prince must flee what makes him hateful, like taking property and women, and what makes him contemptible, like inconstancy. Which of the two brings down more people in your daily life, hatred or contempt?
Whoever conspires needs discontented accomplices, and each one may gain more by denouncing. What does this say about secrets that depend on many people?
The Bolognese went to fetch a blacksmith's son from Florence because they loved the Bentivoglio name. What sustains someone's authority, the person or the affection that their house has left behind?
Pertinax and Alexander were just and fell, because hatred is born also of good deeds. When does doing good to someone who does not want it become an offense?
Machiavelli tells us to take from Severus what founds and from Marcus what preserves. At what stage of your life are you imitating the wrong model?
Chapter XX: Whether Fortresses and Other Things That Princes Do Are Useful or Harmful
Arming subjects makes them faithful, and disarming them shows distrust and breeds hatred. Why does trusting a person bind more than watching them, and when someone trusted you enough to give you power, did it make you more loyal?
The Venetians nourished divisions in the subject cities and lost everything when war came. What short-term advantage have you bought with a division that, at the hour of pressure, became your weak point?
Those who were suspect at the start work harder to prove their worth than the trusted. What changes in a person who needs to wipe out a bad reputation, and why does the comfort of one who feels secure weaken service?
The best fortress is not to be hated by the people. How often do we trust in walls, like position, contract or regulation, instead of caring about being well liked by those around us?
Chapter XXI: What a Prince Should Do to Be Esteemed
Ferdinand keeps the barons busy with war while he gains power over them, "without their perceiving it." When in your life were you so busy with a great cause that you did not even notice who was gaining power over you?
Machiavelli calls what Ferdinand does under Religion a "pious cruelty." How often do we give the noblest reason for a decision whose real motive is another?
Whoever stays neutral loses the esteem of the winner and of the loser. When staying out was your choice, what did you lose on both sides?
No course is safe, and prudence is taking the lesser evil. What decision have you put off, waiting for a cost-free option that does not exist?
Chapter XXII: Of the Secretaries of Princes
The first conjecture about a lord is to look at the men he has around him. What do the people you surround yourself with say about you, and did you choose them or merely inherit them?
Machiavelli does not require the prince to have ideas of his own: it is enough to recognize good and evil in the work of those who serve him. Do you know how to evaluate good work in the areas you do not master?
The minister who thinks more of himself than of you will never be good. What signs, in someone's work, show for whom he truly works?
Machiavelli binds the minister with honors, riches and charges. What keeps someone faithful to you: gratitude, interest or dependence?
Chapter XXIII: How Flatterers Should Be Avoided
Men take such pleasure in their own things that they scarcely defend themselves from flatterers. On what subject do you most like to be praised, and therefore check least?
If everyone can tell the prince the truth, respect for him is lacking. Why is the truth told to those who command so often felt as an offense, and what is lost when only what pleases is said?
The prince chooses a few wise men and asks them only what he wants to know. Whom do you give leave to tell you the truth, and what should you ask those people?
Maximilian decides alone, but gives up when those around him oppose him. What makes a decision withstand the first opposition?
Good counsel is born of the prince's prudence, and not the other way around. Do you trust your own judgment more, or the number of opinions you gather before deciding?
Chapter XXIV: Why the Princes of Italy Lost Their States
The new prince is watched far more than the hereditary one, and for that reason his good actions weigh more. In what situation of your life was being new an advantage?
The princes who lost their States blamed fortune, and Machiavelli says the fault was their sloth. When was the last time you blamed luck for something you could have avoided?
No one takes the storm into account in fair weather. What do you fail to prepare in your calm times?
The princes fled, hoping the people would call them back. Which plan of yours depends on someone coming to rescue you?
Chapter XXV: How Much Fortune Can Do in Human Affairs and How to Resist Her
Machiavelli gives fortune half of our actions and leaves the other half with us. In what recent decision did you treat as the work of luck something that was in your half?
The river cannot be stopped, but the dikes are built in calm times. What dike do you need to raise now, while things are going well?
Two men with different ways reach the same end, and of two with the same way, one arrives and the other does not: the difference is the times. What do your success, or your failure, owe to the age in which you sought it?
The cautious man does not know how to turn impetuous when the times change. In what situation did your way of acting, which had always worked, stop working, and you insisted anyway?
Machiavelli prefers impetuosity to caution, because fortune yields to the one who commands her with audacity. On what occasion was acting at once better than waiting for everything to be arranged?
Chapter XXVI: An Exhortation to Liberate Italy from the Barbarians
The virtue of Moses, of Cyrus and of Theseus appeared only because the people were oppressed. What difficulty, in the worst phase of your life, brought out in you a capacity you had not known before?
Machiavelli says that a war that is necessary is just. When did you call necessary something that was merely convenient?
God does not want to do everything, so as not to take from us free will and the part of glory that falls to us. What do you expect someone to do for you that only you can do?
There is virtue in the limbs and lack of it in the heads, because those who know do not obey and each thinks he knows. In which group around you is this the problem?
The foundation of every enterprise is to provide oneself with arms of one's own. What "arm of your own" have you not yet built and keep renting from others?
The Whole Work
Machiavelli describes the cruelty of Cesare Borgia without approving or condemning. What is gained, and what is lost, by leaving the reader to decide?
The book says it is safer to be feared than loved, but commands the prince to avoid hatred. What difference does the text see between fear and hatred, and why does it matter so much?
If fortune is the arbiter of half our actions, how can one know which half is one's own?
The prince needs to seem pious, faithful and religious without always being so. At what point does seeming stop protecting the State and begin to corrode it?
The book ends by asking a Medici to liberate Italy. Does this change the way of reading the earlier chapters, or do they stand without the last?