Clavis Libri

The Prince · Chapter XXIV

Why the Princes of Italy Lost Their States

Chapter summary

The things said so far, observed with prudence, make a new prince seem old and make him more secure in the State than if he had grown old in it. The new prince is watched far more than the hereditary one, and when his actions are recognized as virtuous they win and oblige men more than ancient blood, because men are attached more to the present than to the past and, finding good in it, defend it, so long as the prince does not fail himself. He will have double glory for having begun a principality and for having adorned it with good laws, good arms, good friends and good examples, and double shame will fall on him who was born a prince and lost it through lack of prudence.

The lords who lost their State in Italy in his time, such as the king of Naples and the duke of Milan, had in common a defect regarding arms, which chapters 12 to 14 treated; afterward, some had the peoples as enemies, and others, having the people as friends, did not know how to secure themselves against the great. Without these defects, States that have strength enough to keep an army in the field are not lost.

The counterexample is Philip of Macedon, not the father of Alexander the Great, but the one defeated by Titus Quinctius. He had little State compared with the greatness of Rome and of the Greece that attacked him, but, being a man of war, knowing how to keep the peoples and secure himself against the great, he sustained the war for many years; he lost dominion over some cities, but the kingdom remained to him. The princes of Italy who stood for many years in the principality and lost it should not accuse fortune, but their own sloth: they never thought, in quiet times, that things could change, and when adverse times came they thought of fleeing and hoped that the peoples, sated with the insolence of the victors, would call them back. This course is good when the others are lacking, but it is very bad to have abandoned the other remedies for it, because no one should want to fall in the belief that he will afterward find someone to lift him up. Only those defenses are good, certain and lasting which depend on yourself and on your virtue.

Analysis

The title. The "why" is the question of one taking stock: after teaching how a State is conquered and kept, Machiavelli looks at the recent cases of those who lost, and the causes he finds are the same ones the book has been showing. The title already says that the loss has an explanation.

What Machiavelli shows here is that the successful new prince is worth more to his subjects than the heir, because he is seen at close range and his good actions are recognized. And that the princes of Italy who lost their States were not victims of fortune: they had no arms of their own, did not know how to secure themselves against the people or the great, and did not prepare for the storm. The only secure defense is the one that depends on oneself.

Unlock with a subscription

Subscription

The complete analysis of every chapter of The Prince comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.

See the plansAlready subscribed? Sign in

Questions on this chapter

To discuss

4 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.

Test your reading

8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz